Lothar Böttcher | September 2006
Lothar Böttcher, Ignus Gerber & Justice Mokoena
“The lighter side”
In Lothar Böttcher’s sculptures glass becomes the focal point. Through glass the artist aims to manipulate and in a sense capture light. He attempts to make the viewer aware of the surroundings within the glass. Creating lenses, he offers a point of view (abstractly), changing perspective and observation of the contiguous space.
Böttcher asks whether we really observe or understand our role in the world around us due to filters like beliefs and personal experiences. Everybody has a unique point of view. The variables are infinite.
“Without light there is no subject. Without subject (particles and waves) there will be no light. Call it the “Ubuntu” of the Universe. There’s a funny side to existence if one thinks of everything as black and therefore invisible, until there’s light! Until it happens…” – Ignus Gerber
“Sound is capable to create various environments transporting the listener into a virtual world. Sound cannot only be heard, but can be felt and even seen, creating all kinds of possibilities. Just close your eyes and see the light within”- Justice Mokoena
Mokoena is strongly influenced by his ancestral background and native language, Lobedu. Since his youth he has been fascinated by various sounds from all walks of life. The artist attempts to use these sounds to communicate to others his perspective in life and a unique cultural background.
Source | http://saartsemerging.org/artist/rainforest/
Tuesday, February 20, 2007
Friday, February 16, 2007
Eria Sane Nsubuga | Uganda
The Source: The Weekly Observer
http://www.ugandaobserver.com/new/ent/ent2007020112.php
A Piece of ‘Sane’ Art
For a young artist in Uganda, Eria Sane Nsubuga is doing well. Recently, the 28-year-old held his fourth solo exhibition sponsored by Alliance Française and held at their premises in Kamwokya.
Nsubuga does paintings, sculptures and illustration print-making in books or magazines. The exhibition attracted an enthusiastic crowd that included French Ambassador Jeremy Garrancher who bought himself a bicycle made of brass.
The jovial Nsubuga began commercial art in 1999 at the age of 20. Nsubuga's work isn't the abstract art that is hard to understand.
He says he's inspired by nature and human activity and most of his paintings and sculptures are of flora and fauna.
"People here want to buy art pieces that are overtly explainable. It's European customers that want the complicated art work. That's why my art is plain and simple."
Gospel music is also part of his inspiration as he reiterates his strong attachment to church work among the youth in Entebbe where he lives. Knowing this, it isn't surprising that he plans to release a gospel music album this year.
"I have been learning the guitar and I am mastering it now. It's for this reason that I want to sing too," he laughs.
Classical music, Bebe and Cece Winans keep him company late into the night in his workroom at home as he thinks up new ideas and draws.
Presently, Nsubuga has two European art collectors who buy his pieces and re-sell them. Also, he has made himself a website www.saneart.com and www.africapainters.com on which his pieces can be seen and ordered for.
Author John Vianney Nsimbe
Etona | Angola
Artist Etona on Exhibit at the Altharetta Yeargin Museum
The work of Antonio Tomas Ana, better known as Etona, was featured in an exhibit held November 4 - 12 at the Altharetta Yeargin Art Museum in Houston, Texas in celebration of the 30th anniversary of Angola`s independence. The artist who was present at the opening is well known within his native Angola and has made a name for himself in the international world of art as well. His work has been exhibited in varied venues including the Park of the National Museum and Gallery in England, and the Museum of Africa in Cuba. He has been honored by having his work selected for the Best of African Painters Collection and was awarded The International Prize of Fine Arts by the Aznar Association in Spain in 2005.
The work on display at the Altharetta Yeargin Art Museum was made up of the two major media in which he chooses to work, sculpture and painting. His sculpture is primarily in wood with a few smaller pieces in stone while his choice of painting media is acrylic.
His paintings are of moderate size and show a consistency in style, color and composition from one canvas to another. The majority of canvases feature a thinly painted background made up of areas of flat color divided by narrow lines that allow the white of the canvas to show through. Using an asymmetrical composition a group of human figures may be painted into one of the lower corners of the painting. These will often be monochromatic and, in contrast to the flat background, are carefully modeled to show the depth and shape of the figures although facial features are often omitted. The subjects of these paintings are people from his country in traditional garb engaged in every day tasks such as transporting baskets of produce on their heads or a mother with her children. But these scenes of everyday life are small in relation to the background and are always placed in one corner or another as though they are not really the actual subject of the painting.
In viewing these paintings one feels an emptiness as though the artist has deliberately under painted the richness of his country through choosing to use flat unmodeled and undetailed backgrounds. To add to this impression of emptiness, content is moved to one corner or side with little color or definition provided. In speaking with the artist and reading his statements about his art, we know the pain and sadness he feels about the exploitation of his country and his people. These deep feelings of grief seem well illustrated in the choice of subject matter and composition of his paintings.
Etona`s sculpture, on the surface, presents a different story. In its elegance and beauty it seems a celebration and homage to the long and rich heritage of African sculpture. Most are made of hard woods and are worked to show a high polish and glow. On some of the pieces he has left areas of roughness created by nature or insects or accident and in the same piece may be a beautifully sculpted head with detailed hair and features.
He seems a virtuoso with wood. The pieces may twist and writhe in much the same way as branches grow on trees but at the same time they take on human forms that fit with the movement. Some pieces are completely naturalistic in detail while others are left deliberately unfinished or without detail as though the artist wishes the viewer to stop and ponder on the reason for this inconsistency. Some very interesting ones even reflect themes of African art of the past but these have been brought into the twentieth century with new subject matter and detailing. But, as in his paintings, the sculpture too expresses Etona`s concern for his people and his country. Perhaps none more so than the two small stone figures that seemed to represent strong figures trying to emerge into their own identity much as the country of Angola is trying to do as it gets past its years of being exploited by the strong world powers and becomes a nation with its own identity..
Dr. Phyllis Knerl Miller
Professor Emeritus
University of Houston
Thursday, February 15, 2007
Iraqi Artist Living In Tunisia | Samir Nanoo
Meeting the Artists in TunisiaLast week I was in Tunisia after deciding last minute to take a short break to start out the New Year. Forever dreaming of seeing more of Africa I thought it best to bite the bullet and hook up with some remarkable African artists. Of course I was thrilled and excited by the prospect of being on African soil again. Once more living amongst the Creatives, those known and unknown, all working tirelessly, struggling to be heard. I found, to my delight, that it was a fantastic choice and finally I was living amongst the original, "Vandals" of North Africa. They made me feel truly at home.
The original inhabitants of Tunisia were the Berbers, now absorbed into the Arab population and accountable for much of its culture, especially the introduction of the, now, national dish, "Couscous". The first cities in Tunisia were built by the Phoenicians, a maritime trading nation from the Lebanon, whose Carthaginian colonists carved out an Empire that even dared to challenge the might of the Romans. The challenge ended in the destruction of the Phoenicians and a Roman invasion. The Romans left behind more than just ruins such as the mosaic delights found in the destroyed city of Carthage and the majestic amphitheatre of El Jem, also the intriguing lion eating men of Haidra, now the Algerian/Tunisian boarder town. The Romans established Tunisia's original infrastructure and introduced the olive and cork trees that dominate the countryside even to this day. Tunisia has had it fare share of invaders from the Roman, the Turks, the French and even Islamic invaders yet instead of becoming cultural schizophrenics there is a definite strong sense of National identity. Tunisia is very proud of the country's moderate Muslim outlook and also the country's unique interpretation of the Koran and seems extremely confident in Tunisia's position within the world of Islam.My journey starts in Monastir, a former fishing port on the Sahel coast. The town is infamous as the birthplace of the first President of Tunisia, Habib Bourguiba - 20th March 1956 (Tunisian Independence Day). On arriving at the airport the air was surprisingly cold and one could detect a pleasant scent of the sea and fresh citrus fruit ripening on the branches. Following a quick tour of the town and the Golden Statue of Habib, I jumped on a bus and travelled up the coastal road to a small town just outside the capital, Tunis, the beautiful hideaway known as Hammamet. On the one and half hour journey up to Hammamet the scenery was magnificent, breathtaking in fact, with lush green mountains on the left, warm dusting roads and beautiful views out to the Mediterranean Sea, to my right. Personally, I was surprised at the level of development the country has experienced since Independence with new roads; petrol stations; street lighting and the overall upkeep of the central Squares throughout the country were immaculate. Strangely the Tunisian don't have an abundance of natural resources like neighbouring Libya and Algeria but still the country has a 5% development growth year on year. Ironically, with figures like these within a decade of two Tunisia is likely to become more developed than France.
Hammamet in January is a rich, fertile yet sleepy town waiting for tourists, money and the heat of Spring. Everybody was busy painting, whitewashing their shops; restaurants and guesthouses. They pay little heed to the ramblings of the occasional tourist at this time of the year. Hammamet itself, houses some of the best contemporary artists in the country.My first port of call was to see Baker Ben Fredj and his wife Nadia at their art gallery in the town centre. I spent several days talking, thinking, photographing, eating, walking and drinking expresso coffees and large whiskeys with the Ben Fredj's. Baker introduced me to his famous artistic neighbour Abderrazak Sahli, the best-known artist in Tunisia, who constantly travels between homes in Paris and Hammamet. The time spent with the two artists and their family's was most enjoyable but I was greedy to meet more Tunisian artists, especially those from the capital, Tunis. Baker and Nadia encouraged and insisted that I meet up with the President of the Union of Artists in Tunis. The man in question was Baker's University lecturer and friend, Sami Ben Ameur. They rang Samir on his mobile and we were to meet the following day. That evening I went to bed remarkably early and woke refreshed ready for the day ahead. Subsequent to an atrocious German breakfast, consisting of beetroot, hard-boiled eggs and watery cabbage, I uncomfortably left the hotel and proceeded to stuff myself into an awaiting yellow taxi, which took me to the Louage (local bus station) finally heading forthe capital. Firmly carrying my newly bought bright orange satchel I squeezed into the tightly packed minibus and after a matter of minutes it quickly filled up and we were well on our way. The sights on the way up to Tunis were wonderful. The sun was beating rhythmically overhead and the grandiose mountains loomed over the minibus outstretched to the horizon, casting unruffled shadows to those below. The mountains were full of seasoned trees alive with greenery while, the cool, fresh, clean sea breeze blew in from the coast. We arrived in good time and I was eager to make my way to the heart of the city. Nadia had kindly given me an art catalogue from the Union of Tunisian Artists, which I rapidly produced out of my new beige camel satchel on arrival in Tunis. I clambered out of the minibus and swiftly leapt into another yellow NYC style cab and in my best French asked the driver to take me to Maison de la Culture Ibn Khaldoun, El Magharibia, Rue Ibn Khaldoun. Of course the driver couldn't understand a word I was saying and I ended up hot, sweaty, fed up and furiously pointing at the address on the back of the catalogue. The driver smiled, shrugged his shoulders and took me into the city centre. The two of us silently sat nervously side by side, perpetually puffing away at out cheap Mars Light cigarettes, smoking rapidly to avoid conversation with the occasional eyebrow lift followed by an awkward smile. Oddly enough this was probably one of the most enjoyable drives of my trip. As I went to open the car door the driver handed me a notebook and asked me to leave feedback. So I did and wrote, "Thoroughly impressed with your communication skills. Full marks for the driving and if smoking becomes an Olympic sport this driver should be put forward for Team Tunisia."
I arrived at the Union building mid morning and made my way to the top floor. By the fourth floor I was sweating profusely and panting like an unhealthy aging mutt and by the fifth the Union had literally taken my breath away. Red faced and resting both my arms on the doorframe I seemingly barred all natural light from entering the room. I attempted to introduce myself. Finally, I made a rather pathetic whispery introduction to two exceedingly glamour ladies sitting quietly at their desks, astonished by my behaviour."Hi, my name is Joe. I'm from England. Is Sami Ben Ameur here?" I airlessly gulped.Confident that I had made an extraordinary first impression I continued by puffing out my best pigeon French. The women looked blankly at each other then back at me. Silence; and after a short and uncomfortable pause I eventually and sheepishly resorted to my trusty catalogue and the furious finger pointing technique. I tried to explain about the efforts I had made on the Internet with various websites about African Painters, whilst at the same time trying desperately to explain about the importance of MySpace and YouTube but to no avail. While I was ranting, kneeling on the floor and fumbling around with the women's computers trying dreadfully to bring up numerous websites an elderly man wearing glasses on his forehead entered the room. He opened his case, brought out a pen and calmly started inoffensively to write notes. This charade with the gorgeous women and the congenial gentleman onlooker lasted a good ten minutes, explaining what it was that I did, have done, would like to do scenario. In due course the old man quietly took his glasses off his forehand and carefully brought them down onto the bridge of his nose. He slowly lifted his head and put his hand to his mouth and clearedhis throat with a polite cough. After a dramatic pause he articulated in perfect English. "What is it that you do exactly?"I let out a surprised laugh and shook my head, I briskly introduced myself and promptly returned with, "And you are, Sir?" he abruptly replied and spoke with the confidence only an aging artist has, "Well, I am the Iraqi artist, living in Tunisia. Samir Nanoo. Nice to meet you!"I recognised his name immediately as he was a featured artist in the catalogue and I had been speaking about his work with Baker and Abderrazak in Hammamet.

"Wow, Nanoo. Samir Nanoo. Really it's an honour to meet you," I shamefacedly replied.
Together, we went out of the office and took an interesting tour around the gallery with artworks randomly placed all around the room, some good, some not so good. As we wondered between the different artists we spoke candidly about the quality of the artwork and the general state of contemporary art in the country. I enjoyed the man's company and when he invited me for a coffeeoutside I was delighted to accompany him to the nearby local café. Samir told me he was born in 1944 in Iraq and moved to Germany seventeen years ago and he had chosen Tunisia to make his Arabic home for security reasons. We talked about his son and how he was an Oman in England and he told me how he had brought him up to be clear-headed and quintessentially good and how proud he was of him. I reached into my bag and pulled out a camera to make a record of our meeting. He stood fantastically grand and egotistical as I photographed him in a rather public place. "He, an artist!" I explained and to Samir delighted followed with, "Don't you recognise the artist?"People looked askance as we swiftly made our way out of the café. We made our way onto the busy Avenue Habib Bourguiba between Place de l'independence and Place d'Africque, which is a typical French style tree lined avenue, with an effective tram system running up and down along with plenty of angry, hooting drivers. We stood in the middle of this confusion and spoke about Samir's new work. He withdrew a series of images from his black
workbag.

As he showed me the images he explained the news he had received from Baghdad. He quietly explained to me that the inmates in the American prison in Baghdad, who were there under suspicion of terrorism or anti-establishment behaviour, had been given no rights, no freedoms of expression, no liberty, whatsoever. The prisoners were treated as the true enemy and were tortured and some even died. Many of the inmates weren't criminals or terrorist, weren't even anti-establishment in anyway, mere civilians. They knew that they being bullied and used as scapegoats. Infuriated by the incarceration, some of the inmates in a moment of despair felt that the only thing they had left to do was post their views on the walls of their cell. They decided to cut their legs and arms with their own fingernails and to use their own excrement to post messages back to their families and loved ones with their fingers. They cut and smeared through the night sending love and well wishes to their friends and family members. The cells were awash with desperate Arabic script displayed curiously on the walls.Come the morning the American Guards saw the cells and shouted;
"You filthy Arab! You filthy Arab, bastards! What have you done, you filthy bastards? Are you expecting us to clean your filthy mess? Ahhh…what can WE expect from you dirty Arabs..……?….You dogs…You low-life Osama Bin Laden loving scum."
Throughout the day the Americans tortured the prisoners and over a series of several weeks the noble American soldiers systematically killed their so-called terrorist hostages. Their thinking was; "the fewer the better."When the dust settled and the bodies were taken from the cells a Muslim Oman came to pick up the dead from the cell. He stood in the room stunned. He looked carefully at all the walls, studying vigilantly what graffiti was written. Attentively reading all that had been seemingly smeared onto the walls. Tears started to fall down the Oman's cheeks as he read the smeared Arabic script.

Firstly he read:
"Ismail. My only son - As your father I want you to be the best a man can be!"….
Then beneath read – "Fatma, I have loved you from birth, find happiness and a good man. Love Daddy."
Then below– "Brother Yusuf. I love you . Remember me always!"
And finally – "Mother. Here is your son. I love you and will forever love you. Father don't forget me! Your son Omar."
The Oman walked out of the prison, tears streaming from his cheeks. As Samir finished his story, he too had tears welling up in his eyes and said, "I was so touch by these messages that I felt duty bound to speak out on their behalf", and he continued to show me his interpretation of the graffiti on the cell walls. Picture by picture. Samir's work is so extremely important and needs to be seen and spoken about.It is only now when I have return to the comfort of home that the full impact of his story hits and continues to hit me. What are we doing in the name of Democracy? What a mess we have gotten ourselves into?……
African Painters | The Artists
Here are some of the artists I have met our would have liked to meet. They are heroes each and every one.
Take a closer look at the work of these African heroes.
Take a closer look at the work of these African heroes.
Monday, November 27, 2006
Chris Abani

Chris Abani
Chris Abani`s novels are GraceLand Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2004 and Masters of the Board Delta, 1985. His poetry collections include Dog Woman Red Hen, Fall 2004, Daphne’s Lot Red Hen, 2003, and Kalakuta Republic Saqi, 2001. He teaches in the MFA Program at Antioch University, Los Angeles and is a Visiting Assistant Professor at the University of California, Riverside. A Middleton Fellow at the University of Southern California, he is the recipient of the 2001 PEN USA Freedom-to-Write Award, the 2001 Prince Claus Award and a 2003 Lannan Literary Fellowship.
AWARDS/GRANTS
2003 - Lannan Foundation Literary Fellowship, USA.
2003 - Hellman/Hammet Grant from Human Rights Watch, USA.
2002 - Imbonge Yesizwe Poetry International Award, South Africa.
2001 - PEN USA West Freedom - to - Write Award, USA.
2001 - Prince Claus Award for Literature & Culture, The Netherlands.
2001 - Middleton Fellowship, University of Southern California, USA.
1983 - Delta Fiction Award, Nigeria.
Alex La Guma | Time of the Butcherbird

Time of the Butcherbird
Synopsis
Out on the flat, featureless South African veld, a small mining town is waiting for rain. As the oppressive summer wears on, the white Afrikaner townspeople seem to be unaware of the storm brewing out on the plain. Out in the bush, a shepherd recalls the riddle of the butcherbird.
---------------------------------
Review by Lexi Wades from United Kingdom
La Guma mixes white decadence with black injustice in this story of segregation and the changing face of South African society in the middle of the twentieth century. Our sympathy is shared between a young white woman bored with her life and the sequence of events that have led her to where she is and a pair of black brothers who are naive to the ways of an unjust society.
TOTB is an interesting an enlightening novel and defiantly worth reading if you are interested in African society.
Alex La Guma | Time of the Butcherbird

Time of the Butcherbird
Synopsis
Out on the flat, featureless South African veld, a small mining town is waiting for rain. As the oppressive summer wears on, the white Afrikaner townspeople seem to be unaware of the storm brewing out on the plain. Out in the bush, a shepherd recalls the riddle of the butcherbird.
---------------------------------
Review by Lexi Wades from United Kingdom
La Guma mixes white decadence with black injustice in this story of segregation and the changing face of South African society in the middle of the twentieth century. Our sympathy is shared between a young white woman bored with her life and the sequence of events that have led her to where she is and a pair of black brothers who are naive to the ways of an unjust society.
TOTB is an interesting an enlightening novel and defiantly worth reading if you are interested in African society.
Alex La Gama | In the Fog of the Season's End
Alex de Gama | A Walk in the Night
Alex La Guma | South Africa

Alex La Guma
1925-1985
La Guma was a writer, a leader of the South African Coloured People`s Organisation SACPO and a defendant in the Treason Trial. Born in 1925 in Cape Town, the son of James La Guma. After graduating from the Trafalgar High School, he joined the Young Communist League in 1947 and became a member of the Communist Party a year later. He helped organise the Congress of the People. He was chairman of SACPO in the Western Cape in the 1950s and an executive member of the SACPO later called the South African Coloured People`s Congress in the 1960s. He wrote for New Age from 1955. He wrote many articles for Fighting Talk in which he captured the atmosphere of the trial proceedings. He was placed under 24-hour house arrest in 1962, and then detained again in 1963. He left South Africa in 1966. He wrote four novels and many short stories, and received the 1969 Lotus Prize for Literature, awarded by the Afro-Asian Writers` Conference. He edited Apartheid: A Collection of Writings on South African Racism by South Africans 1972.
`Alex La Guma is considered one of South Africa`s major twentieth century writers. His first book, A Walk in the Night 1962 was followed by And a Threefold Cord 1967, The Stone Country 1969, The Fog at the Season`s End 1972 and Time of the Butcherbird 1979. A native of District Six, Cape Town, La Guma was also an important political figure. Charged with treason, banned, house arrested and eventually forced into exile, he was chief representative of the African National Congress in the Caribbean at the time of his death in 1985.
Liberation Chabalala: The World of Alex La Guma.
From Protest to Challenge, Political Profiles Volume 4, p52
Maroon Arts: Cultural Vitality in the African Diaspora

Maroon Arts: Cultural Vitality in the African Diaspora
by Sally Price, Richard Price
Synopsis
A stunning record of African-American history and culture through anthropological and artistic eyes - Sally and Richard Price`s groundbreaking work put the history back into the art history of the African diaspora, carefully documenting three centuries of struggle, debate, imitation, and innovation in one of the world`s most beautiful artistic traditions. - J. Lorand Matory, professor of Afro-American Studies and Anthropology, Harvard University - Lavishly illustrated with more than 300 images - Will appeal to art lovers, historians, those interested in museum studies, African American history and culture, and collectors of African Art
From the Publisher
Advance Praise for Maroon Arts
Sally and Richard Price`s groundbreaking work puts the history back into the art history of the African Diaspora, carefully decumenting three centuries of struggle, debate, imitation, and innovation in one of the world`s most beautiful artistic traditions. --J. Lorand Matory, professor of Afro-American studies and anthropology, Harvard University
Maroon Arts is a tribute to the continued power of ethnography and careful attention to the people who are anthropology`s subjects. This is a true marriage of anthropology and art history, and there is nothing in the anthropology of art yet like this kind of placement of expression in sociohistorical context. --Fred Myers, chair, department of anthropology, New York University
Another marvelous achievement by the Prices. Building upon years of intimate contact with the Saramaka, they have produced a work that is at once informative, sympathetic, insightful, and richly illustrated. It is a major contribution to our understanding of the cultural systems of the African Diaspora. --Colin Palmer, distinguished professor of history, The Graduate School, City University of New York
The Maroon peoples of Suriname are decended from slaves imported from West and Central Africa who escaped from Dutch plantations in the 18th century. Their art is a rich mix of African American aesthetics and the strong spirit of individual creativity. The authors who share the Dittman Chair in American Studies at the College of William and Mary examine textiles, woodcarving, calabash decorations, and ritual performance with an anthropologist`s regard for historical and cultural context. . . . An important contribution to the literature of anthropolgy and art. --Library Journal --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
Kentecloth: Southwest Voices of the African Diaspora : the Oral Tradition Comes to the Page

Kentecloth: Southwest Voices of the African Diaspora : the Oral Tradition Comes to the Page
Edited by Jas Mardis
From the Publisher
Kente Cloth editor Mardis wins Pushcart Prize
From the Dallas Morning News
Dallas writer James Mardis` poem Invisible Man has been selected as one of the 28 poetry winners of the 24th annual Pushcart Prize.
The Pushcart Prize honors the best of small literary presses the winning works are selected by 200 contributing editors.Chosen from 5.000 nominations, the 62 selections--including poems, short stories and essays--will be published in November in the anthology The Pushcart Prize XXIV. --This text refers to the Paperback edition.
Reviewer: Karen Celestan from New Orleans
KENTE CLOTH WADES INTO STORYTELLERS` WATERS
From a full-length performance poem in script form to a teen-ager`s image-laden perception of self, Kente Cloth: Southwest Voices of The African Diaspora University of North Texas Press revives on paper the ancient tradition of griots or storytellers. James Mardis, an award-winning poet and radio commentator in Dallas, has compiled an anthology that features mostly unpublished writers. Collecting the work of more than 45 scribes primarily from Louisiana and Texas, Mardis has succeeded in capturing the rhythm-and-blues lives of people in a common-folk vernacular. Simple, earnest and true. Kente Cloth is divided into four basic categories: Witnesses, Performers, Tellers and Signifiers, with a range of styles and tales that tantalize the reader into jumping into a pool of griots. Jesse Truvillion`s A Stray Dog`s Great Day, Nadir Bomani`s Someone`s Knockin` at My Door and Phyllis Allen`s The Red Swing run the gamut from tribute to modern-day vignette. The poetry of Monica Denise Spears, Bertram Barnes, Zenaura Melynia Smith, Gayle Bell, Freddi Evans, Glenn Joshua, Mawiyah Bomani and Kalamu ya Salaam are lyrical emotion-rides, while the prose of Bernestine Singley, Charley Moon, and James Thomas Jackson invoke fiery responses. Lovve/Rituals & Rage by Sharon Bridgforth brings the joy of performance art to the page and the gentle Soul Soother by Zenaura Smith, a freshman at John Ehret High School in New Orleans, offers a touch of innocent love. Even editor Mardis slips in a folktale and a couple of poems, most notably Sting, an ode that balances lemonade and death. A dozen New Orleans writers add their unique perspectives to this collection, including Michael Ollie Clayton, saddi khali, Cassandra Bailey, Nadir Bomani, Barnes, Evans, Joshua, Perkins, Salaam, Smith, Spears and Mawiyah Bomani. The African-American literary scene is a steadily evolving and expanding landscape, and Kente Cloth turns the spotlight around to shine on the South. Mardis wanted this collection to represent the joy of the oral tradition, The elders may be gone in body, but their lessons linger in the living and sharing of these stories, poems and plays. Listen for the voices...the oral dance of tongue to teeth and song to heart. Kente Cloth is a visual tribute to the legions of unscripted griots and a worthy addition to any shelf that holds African-American literature.
Ethiopian Passages: Dialogues in the Diaspora

Ethiopian Passages: Dialogues in the Diaspora
by Elizabeth Harney
Synopsis
In the global arena, African artists have contributed significantly to the inventiveness and creative vitality of the contemporary art world. This impact has been more immediate and pronounced for Western audiences as African artists move into the growing and significant diaspora in America and Europe. This study introduces audiences to the importance of the arts in the African diaspora and tells of the important histories of migration and the myriad negotiations of artistic, cultural, group and personal identities among African artists in the diaspora. The book brings together artists from across several generations, who have addressed issues of identity, experienced displacement and created new homelands. The evidence of these encounters and personal experiences can be seen in the works of art that are included, which demonstrate the magnificence and arresting power of contemporary African art.
Diaspora and Visual Culture

Diaspora and Visual Culture
by Nicholas Mirzoeff Editor
Synopsis
This text marks the importance of diaspora as a means of understanding the new modes of postnational identity. In examining the visual culture of the classic African and Jewish diasporas, contributors address different aspects of the multiple viewpoints inherent in diasporic cultures. Two introductory essays by Stuart Hall and the painter R.B. Kitaj highlight the intersections of diaspora and cultural identity. The subsequent essays examine individual instances of diaspora as diverse as homosexuality in the Dreyfus Affair, the Caribbean-Jewish Impressionist painter Camille Pissarro, Yoruba diaspora art and performance in Brazil and New York, identity in the art of African-American women in the 19th and 20th centuries, the formation of American, European and Israeli artistic identity and the possibility that queer culture is diasporic.
Borders, Exiles, Diasporas

Borders, Exiles, Diasporas
by Elazar Barkan Editor, Marie-Denise Shelton Editor
Synopsis
How do the concepts border, exile, and diaspora shape individual and group identities across cultures? Taking this question as a point of departure, this wide-ranging volume explores the ways that people create and represent a home away from home. Throughout, the authors emphasize the multiple subjectivities, cultural displacements, and identity politics that have characterized the postcolonial and post-World War II eras. They simultaneously affirm and challenge previous understandings of these three terms, and they investigate their malleability the extent to which they apply to diverse communities. Once the idea of diaspora is dissociated from the historical experiences of a particular group of people, it becomes a universal designation, applicable to all displaced groups. This understanding of diaspora also allows for the creation of a nonnormative intellectual community, one experienced by many contemporary critics and with which they identify. In the postcolonial context, a global middle voice emerges that incorporates the critic and his or her identity as the participant-observer of the discourses on identity. As personal narratives transcend the autobiographical, they become indispensable guarantors of a free theoretical field, without a priori boundaries. The diaspora s voice is thus national and cultural, but it lacks the nation or the geographical definition that would constrain its subject.
New Talent | Anagossi Gratien | Grek

Grek | Anagossi Gratien
Republic of Benin
b.1974 - Present
Grek Art
Grek is one of the exciting young talented artists of West Africa from the Republic of Benin. Originally from the Republic of Togo he moved to neighbouring Benin in his teens and is now in his early 30`s. He has worked for the French Cultural Centre in Cotonou and most recently, has set-up a design group in the Port of Cotonou.
His work is similar to Alberto Burni and Antoni Tapies of the Art Informel Movement of the 1950`s but I believe this is more by accident rather than design. I use the term Art Informel from the French informe, meaning unformed or formless to refer to the antigeometric, antinaturalistic, and nonfigurative formal preoccupations which is so obvious in Grek`s work, stressing his pursuit for spontaneity, looseness of form, and the irrational. His work is pushing forward new ideas of seeing and using whatever materials are closest at hand. His work is extensively about the plight of the empoverished and his inventive techniques of leaving painted canvas in the sun for weeks on end is extremely effective. The end product is a painting that looks like it`s about to fall to pieces, which is purposefully symbolic in the way in which he chooses to reflect his own condition.
Grek`s work leans towards the gestural and expressive, with repetitive anticompositional formats related to Abstract Expressionism. If ever there was an artist who represented African modernity it is Grek. He is a dedicated artist and we are delighted to represent him on the site.
New Talent | Krisito Assangni
Krisito Assangni Togo/France
b.1975 - Present
SOLO EXHIBITIONS
2005 Galerie Pierre-Michel Dugast, Paris
2004 Sela Gallery, Leeds, United Kingdom
Galerie 43, Paris
2003 Mondiaal Centrum, Maastricht, Netherlands
Galerie Mailletz , Paris
2002 Galerie du Médoc, Bordeaux, France
GROUP EXHIBITIONS
2005 Lines on paper, Oö Landesmuseum, Linz, Austria Limited, Toast Gallery, Brussels, Belgium
2004 Foire internationale des arts derniers, les Afriques, Musée des
Arts Derniers, Paris
15 th, Kolb Halle, Cologne, Germany
Atout coeur d’artiste, Musée du collage, Sergines, France
Symposium Art Kollage , Proldiv, Bulgaria
2003 Mail art, Cultural center of Sucy-en-Brie France, Belgrade Serbia, Bietighem-Bissigen Germany
Les signes, Galerie Pierre-Michel Dugast, Paris
2002 Africavui, Galeria Greca, Barcelone, Spain
2001 8 artistes, Galerie du Médoc, Bordeaux, France
Grands et Jeunes, Galerie Am Tunnel, Luxembourg
2000 Grands et Jeunes, Espace Eiffel-Branly, Paris Le Phare Togo-Bretagne, Assemblée Nationale, Paris
1/2000 , Galerie Jacques Cartier, Chauny, France
1999 Journées Photographiques de Lome
-------------
ACADEMIC
2002 Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts, Paris
1999 Atelier of Beat Presser, Goethe institut, Lome, Togo
New Talent | Kossi Ankude | Laka
Kossi Ankude | Laka b. 02/08/1970
The Republic of Togo
Personal Details
Name: ANKUDE
Christian Name: Kossi
Artistic Name: Laka
Date of Birth: 02 August 1970 in Lomé TOGO
Adresse : BP 4806 Lomé TOGO
Formation : Self Taught Painter
Genre : Painting, Drawing, sculptures, installations
Education: Diplômes : BAC série C - DEUG in Economie
Exhibitions 2003 Exposition collective GODODO, au siège du PSIC à LoméTogo
Exposition collective, galerie METISSAGE, Manosque France
2002 Exposition collective, galerie LA TOUR D`ARGENT, Lisle sur la SorgeFrance
2001 Résidence de créations de peintures et exposition collective à l`ATELIER NOMADE ALOUGBINE DINE, Cotonou Bénin
2000 Expositions avec Claude MAKELELA
Restaurant le MAQUIS, MontpellierFrance
Soirée organisée par HANDICAPS SANS FRONTIERES, Laval France
1999 Exposition au GOETHE INSTITUT de Lomé Togo
Musée Municipal d`Art Contemporain de Cocody, Abidjan Côte d`Ivoire
Exposition collective « Grande célébration », Hôtel SARAKAWA, Premier Prix du Concours UAC-WAX-VLISCO intitulé « Le pagne de l`An 2000 » Lomé Togo
1998 Expositions à l`Hôtel MERIDIEN RE-NDAMA de librevilleGabon: . Avec Claude MAKELELA . Avec la galerie LE LUTRIN
1997 Foire Internationale de Libreville, exposition collective à l`occasion du Sommet ACP-UE
Salon de thé le CAFE CHAUD, Libreville Gabon
1996 SALON D`OCTOBRE au CCF de Libreville Gabon
Exposition avec Mr Simon MIZERE au CCF de Libreville
Exposition collective à l`Hôtel INTERCONTINENTAL de Libreville
Exposition collective à la galerie OLIMA de Libreville
1995 18e Foire Internationale de Libreville, salon VIP de Shell- Gabon
1994 Galerie OLIMA, Libreville Gabon
Permanent Exhibition
Galerie OLIMA, Libreville Gabon
Other Events
Logo de la Fêtes des Cultures de Libreville Gabon
Sunday, November 26, 2006
Suzanne Ouedraogo

Suzanne Ouedraogo
Artist from Burkina Faso
Features in Anthology of Contemporary African Art
Revue Noire Suzanne Ouedraogo born in 1973, Bestiary no1, 1999
Photo by Joe Pollitt
From Library Journal
Editors with the Paris-based publisher Revue Noire, Fall and Pivin have put together a volume that will inspire and inform experts and neophytes alike. Including 500 color and 51 black-and-white images, this book provides a depth and breadth no other volume can boast of on the subject of contemporary African art. Breathtakingly thorough and overwhelming in its comprehensiveness, this volume contains a representative selection that covers all genres and reaches into every region of sub-Saharan Africa. The undertaking is enhanced by the penetrating insights of several distinguished writers, whose masterly essays recall history, provide context, and interpret uniquely African phenomena while also revealing the universality of selected works, presenting them as expressions of a modernity that is concretely African but has roots in the interconnectedness of all humans. The brief descriptions and histories accompanying each work are invaluable guides. Recommended for public and academic libraries and indispensable for any African studies collection.
Edward K. Owusu-Ansah, CUNY Coll. of Staten Island Lib.
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
About the Author
N`Gone Fall is the editor of Revue Noire.
Jean Loup Pivin is the cofounder and director of publications of Revue Noire.
Book Description
The term Modern African Art is not an abuse of language. The 20th century has seen, but not properly documented, the birth, development, and maturation of contemporary art in sub-Saharan Africa, an art which was not simply imported in the 1950s but which finds its sources both in colonial realities and in local cultures and civilizations. Anthology of African Art: The Twentieth Century does not propose to document any one African art, but rather to open up this vast but underexplored field to include a diverse theoretical, historical, geographical, and critical map of this dense and ancient region. Contributions by more than 30 international authors recount the birth of art schools in the 1930s, the development of urban design and public art, and the importance of socially-concerned art during the Independence movements. From Ethiopia, Nigeria, and the Belgian Congo to Ghana, Senegal, and Angola, through the works of hundreds of artists working in every conceivable medium and context, this anthology manages the continental and unique feat of providing a thorough, expansive, diversified, and fully illustrated history of African art in the 20th century. Since 1991, Paris-based Revue Noire Editions has dedicated itself to the multidisciplinary artistic production of the African continent and the African diaspora. Publishers of the critically-acclaimed An Anthology of African Photography, a comprehensive chronicle of African photography from the mid-1800s to the present, Revue Noire also produces a self-titled magazine devoted to contemporary African art and culture. With his proverbial cynicism, Henry Kissinger said some time ago that Africa was for the 21st century to solve. Well, now we`re there. --Josep Ramoneda, Director of the Centre de Cultura Contemporania de Barcelona
Edited by Jean Loup Pivin & N`Gone Fall. Essays by Francisco d`Almeida, Marie-Helene Boisdur de Toffol, Joelle Busca, Sabine Cornelis, Elsbeth Court, N`Gone Fall, Etienne Feau, Till Forster, Joseph Gazari Seini, Joanna Grabski, Sigrid Horsch-Albert, Bennetta Jules-Rosette, George Kyeyune, Alexandra Loumpet-Galitzine, Marylin Martin, Elikia M`Bokolo, Adriano Mixinge, Simon Njami, Sylvester Ogbechie, Richard Pankhurst, Blaise Patrix, Thierry Payet, John Picton, Jean Loup Pivin, Sunanda K. Sanyal, Konjit Seyoum, Ousmane Sow Huchard, Yvonne Vera, Jean-Luc Vellut, Sue Williamson and Gaving Younge.
9.25 x 12.5 in.
Olu Oguibe

Olu Oguibe
The Culture Game
Editorial Reviews
Book Description
In self-congratulatory tones of tolerance and open-mindedness, the Western gatekeepers of the contemporary art world-gallery owners and museum curators, patrons and promoters-take great pains to demonstrate their inclusive vision of world culture. They highlight the Latin American show mounted a few years ago or the African works featured in a recent exhibition of non-Western artists. Non-Western artists soon discover that this veneer of liberalism masks an array of unwritten, unspoken, and unseemly codes and quotas dictating the acquisition and exhibition of their works and the success of their careers. In past decades, cultural institutions and the critical establishment in the West resisted difference today, they are obsessed with exoticism. Both attitudes reflect firmly entrenched prejudices that prescribe the rules of what Nigerian-born artist, curator, and scholar Olu Oguibe terms the culture game.
In the celebrated, controversial essays gathered here, Oguibe exposes the disparities and inconsistencies of the reception and treatment afforded Western and non-Western artists the obstacles that these contradictions create for non-Western and minority artists, especially those who live and practice in the Western metropolis and the nature and peculiar concerns of contemporary non-Western art as it deals with the ramifications and residues of the colonial encounter as well as its own historical and cultural past. Ranging from the impact of the West`s appetite for difference on global cultural relations and the existence of a digital Third World to the African redefinition of modernity, Oguibe`s uncompromising and unapologetic criticism provides a uniquely global vision of contemporary art and culture.
Olu Oguibe is a visual artist, writer, scholar, and curator. He is associate professor of art and art history at the University of Connecticut.
Ingrid Mwangi

Ingrid Mwangi
Your Own Soul: Ingrid Mwangi
by Ingrid Mwangi, Gislind Nabakowski, Jan Hoet
Book Description
Ingrid Mwangi is an artist of Kenyan origin, living in Germany since she was fifteen. In her videos, installations, performances, and photo works, Mwangi incessantly explores her blackness as well as her biracial heritage. Her works document the journey to herself, dealing with deeply rooted patterns of behavior and attitudes that lead to social, political, and cultural stigmatization. As a self-confident -person, the young media performer explores and presents her own corporeality determined by her body, her skin, her dreadlocks, and her voice. The unmediated experience of cultural differences has allowed Mwangi to develop a special sensitivity that generates an artistic prism through which she view herself and the world.
Iba N`Diaye

Iba N`Diaye
PRIMITIVE? SAYS WHO? IBA NDIAYE, PAINTER BETWEEN CONTINENTS
by Franz Kaiser and Okwui Enwezor
- For full details contact the Publisher below -
A new book on Iba Ndiaye entitled Primitive? Says Who? - Iba Ndiaye, Painter Between Continents was brought out in January 2002 by renown french publisher, Adam Biro. This well illustrated monograph -- in French and English -- focuses on Iba`s new work, from 2000-2001. The books` authors are Okwui Enwezor, Curator of The Short Century and Director of Documenta XI, and Franz-W Kaiser, Director of Exhibitions at the Gemeentemuseum in The Hague.
The book`s dust jacket sums up the it`s orientation:
Contemporary art is in fashion, particularly if it comes from faraway lands like Africa. But who decides what is art? Who controls the quality of artists? According to which criteria? It is clear that, almost a half-century after decolonization, in order to be recognized, Africans must in one way or another produce art that is primitive, meaning naïve, picturesque, lacking in technique, colorful, tribal, exotic.
The European inventions of primitivism and the noble savage are difficult to overcome. Iba Ndiaye sees himself as neither noble nor savage. He sees himself simply as a painter. One can only be a painter through one`s relationship with the history of painting -- by borrowing, rejecting and innovating in order to build a personal style. Ndiaye knows this, and he rejects the dubious ideology of the clean slate. Like any true artist, he sees painting for what it is: the means of finding his own personal identity, which lies between Africa, where he was born, and Europe, where he lives.
- soft-cover
- 22 x 28 cm
- 40 images, 30 in colour
- 64 pages
- ISBN : 2-84660-332-2
- On Sale : January 2002
- price : 18 €.
Adam Biro publishers
28 rue de Sévigné, 75004 Paris
Contact :
Aleksandra Sokolov
Fax : 01 44 59 87 17
Mobile : 06 08 32 10 39
Representations of Blackness and the Performance of Identities

Representations of Blackness and the Performance of Identities
by Jean Muteba Rahier Editor
This anthology offers a comparative approach for the study of performances of African diaspora identities in various locales of the Black Atlantic. Articles discuss the spatial dimensions of blackness the relations between blackness, gender constructs, and social classes Native American views.
The essays in this volume deal with representations of blackness and the performance of black identities in various historically determined societal contexts of the Americas, Benin and Spain. The book is grounded on the premise that representations constitute, in part, the world in which we live.
Souls of Black Folk by W.E.B. Du Bois

Souls of Black Folk
by William Edward Burghardt Du Bois
William Edward Burghardt Du Bois 1868--1963 is the greatest of African-American intellectuals--a sociologist, historian, novelist, and activist whose astounding career spanned the nation`s history from Reconstruction to the civil rights movement. Born in Massachusetts and educated at Fisk, Harvard, and the University of Berlin, Du Bois penned his epochal masterpiece, The Souls of Black Folk, in 1903. It remains his most studied and popular work its insights into Negro life at the turn of the 20th century still ring true.
With a dash of the Victorian and Enlightenment influences that peppered his impassioned yet formal prose, the book`s largely autobiographical chapters take the reader through the momentous and moody maze of Afro-American life after the Emancipation Proclamation--from poverty, the neoslavery of the sharecropper, illiteracy, miseducation and lynching, to the heights of humanity reached by the spiritual sorrow songs that birthed gospel and the blues. The most memorable passages are contained in On Booker T Washington and Others, where Du Bois criticises his famous contemporary`s rejection of higher education and accommodationist stance toward white racism: Mr. Washington`s programme practically accepts the alleged inferiority of the Negro races, he writes, further complaining that Washington`s thinking withdraws many of the high demands of Negroes as men and American citizens. The capstone of The Souls of Black Folk, though, is Du Bois` haunting, eloquent description of the concept of the black psyche`s double consciousness, which he described as a peculiar sensation....One ever feels this twoness--an American, a Negro two souls, two thoughts, two unreconciled strivings two warring ideals in one dark body, whose dogged strength alone keeps it from being torn asunder. Thanks to WEB Du Bois` commitment and foresight--and the intellectual excellence expressed in this timeless literary gem--black Americans can today look in the mirror and rejoice in their beautiful black, brown and beige reflections. --Eugene Holley Jr --This text refers to the Paperback edition.
Synopsis
First published in Arpril, 1903, Souls of the Black Folk was one of Modern Librarys 100 Best Nonfiction Books of the 20th Century.
The Birth of Cool: Dress Culture of the African Diaspora (Materializing Culture)
Getahun Assefa | Arab 4 | EthiopiaFocusing on counter- and sub-cultural contexts, this volume investigates the role of dress in the creation and assertion of Black identity. Tracing the home-dressmaking of Jamaican women, through to the Harlem Renaissance and contemporary street styles such as Hip Hop and Raggamuffin, the book identifies Black Britons, African Americans and Jamaicans as being at the forefront of establishing a variety of Black identities through dress.
From the zoot suit and Black dandy through to Rastafarianism and beyond, Black style has had a profound influence on the history of dress in the twentieth century. Yet despite this high profile, the dress styles worn by men and women of the African diaspora have received scant attention, even though the culture itself has been widely documented from historical, sociological and political perspectives. Focusing on counter - and sub-cultural contexts, this book investigates the role of dress in the creation and assertion of Black identity. From the home-dressmaking of Jamaican women, through to the Harlem Renaissance and contemporary streetstyles such as Hip-Hop and Raggamuffin, Black Britons, African Americans and Jamaicans have been at the forefront of establishing a variety of Black identities. In their search for a self-image that expresses their diaspora experience, members of these groups have embraced the cultural shapers of modernity and postmodernity in their dress. Drawing on materials from the United States, Britain and Jamaica, this book fills a gap in both the history of Black culture and the history of dress, which has until recently focused on high fashion in Europe. Because dress can both initiate and confirm change, it provides an especially useful tool for analyzing identity and resistance.
Looking Both Ways: Art of the Contemporary African Diaspora

Looking Both Ways: Art of the Contemporary African Diaspora
Ann Laurie Farrell
Out on the 1 March, 2004
Book Description
This book showcases 12 artists from North, South, East, and West Africa who live and work in Western countries. The title refers to the artists’ practice of looking in the psychic terrain between Africa and the West, a terrain of shifting physical contexts, aesthetic ambitions and expressions.
Exhibition catalogue edited by Laurie Ann Farrell with contributions by Valentijn Byvanck, Allan deSouza, José António Fernandes Dias, Okwui Enwezor, Laurie Ann Farrell, Lauri Firstenberg, Salah Hassan, Kobena Mercer, Steven Nelson, Simon Njami, Edith-Marie Pasquier, John Peffer, Jérôme Sans, and Sue Williamson. Published by the Museum for African Art, New York and Snoeck-Ducaju & Zoon, Gent, March, 2003. 180 pp.
Islam`s Black Slaves: The History of Africa`s Other Black Diaspora

Islam`s Black Slaves: The History of Africa`s Other Black Diaspora
by Ronald Segal
Synopsis
This work tells the fascinating and horrifying story of the Islamic slave trade. It documents a centuries-old institution that still survives, and traces the business of slavery and its repercussions from Islam`s inception in the 7th century, through its history in China, India, Iran, Turkey, Egypt, Libya and Spain, and on to Sudan and Mauritania, where, even today, slaves continue to be sold. Segal reveals the numbers involved in this trade - as many millions as were transported to the Americas - and explores the differences between the traffic in the East and the West. Beginning some eight centuries earlier than the Atlantic Trade, the Islamic Trade was conducted on a different scale, and provided slaves more often for domestic - including sexual - and military service than for plantation labour. Some slaves rose to positions of authority, and a few even became rulers. Because of specific spiritual teachings, Islam was generally more humane than the West in its treatment of slaves and in its willingness to grant them their freedom, although the processes of captivity and transport victimized untold numbers of innocent people, as did the creation of eunuchs for the Islamic market.
You Look Beautiful Like That: The Portrait Photographs of Seydou Keita and Malick Sidibe

You Look Beautiful Like That: The Portrait Photographs of Seydou Keita and Malick Sidibe
by Michelle Lamuniere, Sidibe Malick
Editorial Reviews
From Publishers Weekly
The catalogue of a recent Harvard University exhibition, You Look Beautiful Like That: The Portrait Photographs of Seydou Keita and Malick Sidib‚ chronicles the two portrait photographers` work in Mali. Ke‹ta and Sidib‚ took countless studio portraits of Malinese people before and after the country became independent from France in 1960. Michelle LamuniŠre, a curatorial research assistant at Harvard`s Fogg Museum, includes an essay on the history of West African portrait photography with images dating back to the turn of the century and portions of recent interviews with the two artists. The 79 images ranging from people in strictly traditional dress to friends in hip Westernized get-ups to men posed in a boxing scene are striking for their subjects` arresting gazes and poses as well as for their superior production value.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Photographs have been taken in Africa since the 1840s, but only recently have scholars begun to pay attention to the work of indigenous African photographers, who typically blend Western technology and techniques with an African perspective and aesthetic sensibility. This catalog, which accompanies an exhibition at Harvard`s Fogg Art Museum, focuses on commercial portraits by two Bamako, Mali, photographers, whose photos are drawn from the collection of noted African art collector Jean Pigozzi.
Book Description
Seydou Keïta and Malick Sidibé, two important and widely known commercial photographers from Mali, took mesmerizing photographs of members of their communities during the decades before and after the country`s independence from France in 1960. This book presents a range of these portraits, as well as excerpts of recent interviews with the artists and an essay placing the photographers within the context of the history of portrait photography in West Africa since its beginnings in the 1840s. In contrast to the early photographs of Africans produced by Western colonial powers, Keïta and Sidibé`s photographs represent the work of Africans controlling the camera to create images of African subjects for an African audience. Keïta combined formulas of Western portrait photography with local aesthetics to create images that reflect both his clients` social identity and status within the community and an enthusiastic embrace of modernity. Later, as portrait conventions and societal roles became more flexible, Sidibé`s subjects took a more active part in constructing the images of themselves that they wanted to convey. Africans have valued photography for its unique ability to capture a person`s likeness, which, says Sidibé, was regarded as more eternal than the subjects themselves. This book is a striking collection of such likenesses.
Veil: Veiling,Representation and Contemporary Art

Veil: Veiling,Representation and Contemporary Art
David A. Bailey Editor, Gilane Tawadros Editor
Reviews
Synopsis
No single item of dothing has had greater influence on Western images of Middle Eastern and North African women than the veil. The fascination of Western writers, artists, and photographers with the veil reflects the voyeuristic nature of our interest in what is strange and other. Veil, which accompanies an exhibition organized by the Institute of International Visual Arts in London, explores the representation of the veil in contemporary visual arts. Providing a context for the commissioned essays are a number of classical historical texts crossing religions, cultures, genders, and ages - from Greek myths to articles published in the aftermath of September 11, 2001. Some of the contemporary artists and scholars write autobiographically about the meaning of the veil in their lives. Others take a more political approach, discussing, for example, how the events of September 11 changed the use and reception of veil imagery throughout the world. Still others take a historical approach, examining how nineteenth-century technological developments in travel and photography led to photographic depictions of both the veiled and unveiled body in relation to landscape.
Touhami Ennadre: Moira

Touhami Ennadre: Moira
by Okwui Enwezor, Lauri Firstenberg
Book Description
As early as 1978, critics have compared the striking works of French photo artist Touhami Ennadre to the intensity of Van Gogh, and others have since identified affinities with Caravaggio and the poetry of Rimbaud. In the words of author Tilman Spengler, Ennadre presents images that appear and disappear at the same time. Often insistent to the point of obsession, these works imitate Creation in their own unique fashion, posing the question of how light and shadow become form and figure in a dialogue of equals. Author François Aubral coined the term black light with reference to this aspect of Ennadre`s work. Moïra features an impressive selection of Ennadre`s beautifully modeled photographs, and presents for the first time his recent Danse series, shot on the New York City club scene.
Essays by Okwui Enwezor, Lauri Firstenberg and Nancy Spector.
Hardcover, 10.5 x 13.75 in./144 pgs / 110 duotone.
Touhami Ennadre: Black Light

Touhami Ennadre: Black Light
by Francois Aubral
Synopsis
This work is a monograph on Touhami Ennadre, an artist whose visionary photographic depiction of life and death has made him the focus of attention in international photographic circles. His work, especially the Hands and Parisian Suburbs series, has become increasingly popular. Works by Ennadre were included in an exhibition at New York`s Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum in 1996, and his pictures are now to be found in major collections of contemporary photography throughout the world. By intense concentration on the subjects depicted, submerged in a background of deep black, Ennadre excludes superfluous narrative elements. He insists that he is not a photographer, and the unusual methods he uses certainly resemble those of a painter more than those of a conventional photographer. His works are often deeply disturbing and have a strong impact on the viewer. They take us aside into the shadows of our civilization and draw us closer and closer to the subject of birth and death - the extremes of human experience.
The Black Female Body: A Photographic History

The Black Female Body: A Photographic History
by Deborah Willis, Carla Williams
Synopsis
Searching for photographs of black women, the authors of this text were startled to find them by the hundreds. This work offers an array of familiar and many virtually unknown photographs, showing how photographs reflected and reinforced Western culture`s fascination with black women`s bodies.
Photography`s Other Histories Objects/Histories

Photography`s Other Histories Objects/Histories
by Christopher Pinney Editor, Nicolas Peterson Editor, Jack Kramer
Editorial Reviews
About the Author
Christopher Pinney is Reader in Anthropology and Visual Culture at University College London. He is author of Camera Indica: The Social Life of Indian Photographs and coeditor of Pleasure and the Nation and Beyond Aesthetics. Nicolas Peterson is Reader in Anthropology at the Australian National University. He is coauthor of Aboriginal Territorial Organization.
Book Description
Moving the critical debate about photography away from its current Euro-American center of gravity, Photography’s Other Histories breaks with the notion that photographic history is best seen as the explosion of a Western technology advanced by the work of singular individuals. This collection presents a radically different account, describing photography as a globally disseminated and locally appropriated medium. Essays firmly grounded in photographic practice—in the actual making of pictures—suggest the extraordinary diversity of nonwestern photography.
Richly illustrated with over one hundred images, Photography’s Other Histories explores from a variety of geographic, cultural, and historic perspectives the role of photography in raising historical consciousness. It includes two first-person pieces by indigenous Australians and one by a Seminole/Muskogee/Dine` artist. Some of the essays analyze representations of colonial subjects—from the limited ways Westerners have depicted Navajos to Japanese photos recording the occupation of Manchuria and from the changing nature of the contract between Aboriginal subjects and photographers to the surprising range of cultural influences evident in the photographs colonialist F. R. Barton took in New Guinea in the late 1800s and early 1900s. Focusing on photographic self-fashioning and the development of vernacular modernisms, other essays highlight the visionary quality of much popular photography. Case studies centered in early-twentieth-century Peru and contemporary India, Kenya, and Nigeria chronicle the diverse practices that have flourished in postcolonial societies. Photography’s Other Histories recasts popular photography around the world, as not simply reproducing culture but creating it.
Contributors. Michael Aird, Heike Behrend, Jo-Anne Driessens, James Faris, Morris Low, Nicolas Peterson, Christopher Pinney, Roslyn Poignant, Deborah Poole, Stephen Sprague, Hulleah Tsinhnahjinnie, Christopher Wright
In/sight: African Photographers, 1940 to the Present

In/sight: African Photographers, 1940 to the Present
Okwui Enwezor
Reviews
Synopsis
Presenting the work of 30 diverse photographers from throughout Africa since 1940, this is the complete catalogue of an exhibition at the Guggenheim Museum in New York. Studio portraits of the 1940s by photographers such as the Ivory Coast`s Cornelius Yao Azaglo Augustt, Senegal`s Salla Casset and Meissa Gay, and Mali`s Seydou Keita depict a period of great transformation in Africa. Examples of the 1950s include work by Bob Gasani, Peter Magubane and Lionel Oostendorp for the magazine Drum, and featured photographers of the 1960s and 1970s include Samuel Fosso Central African Republic, David Goldblatt South Africa, Ricardo Rangel Mozambique and Malick Sidibe Mali. These more recent photographs chronicle the development of independent countries and the emergence of Africa as part of the modern world. Contemporary artists in North Africa and Nigeria are represented by work on new themes. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
Flash Afrique! Photography from West Africa

Flash Afrique! Photography from West Africa
by Thomas Miessgang Editor, Olu Oguibe, Gerald Matt Editor, Barbara Schroder Editor, Kunsthall
Editorial Reviews
From Library Journal
As attention is increasingly directed to the study and appreciation of contemporary African art, the work of indigenous photographers has been made available to a larger audience through exhibitions and publications. This volume, which accompanies a show curated by Matt and Miessgang at Vienna`s Kunsthalle gallery, focuses on the work of six 20th-century photographers from Ghana, Mali, Senegal, and the Ivory Coast. The 57 works range from staged studio portraits to documentary shots of street life. However, this is much more than a simple catalog of images. The text, consisting of essays and interviews by scholars, critics, and the artists themselves, analyzes the aesthetics and meaning behind the photographs. In addition, artists` biographies are separately provided. While the interpretive nature of the text and the variety of works reproduced make this a valuable addition to academic libraries specializing in art or African studies, general collections are still better served by a survey, such as In/Sight: African Photographers, 1840-1981. Eugene C. Burt, Data Arts, Seattle
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Book Description
Terra incognito? Heart of darkness? How about stylish continent, as some magazine once wrote? The gigantic landmass that is Africa, over which a colonial shadow still looms, is a territory of projections and misunderstandings. The West African photographers presented in Flash Afrique! tell stories about the tension between dreams and reality. Elaborately arranged studio portraits reveal how Africa sees itself. Documentary images comment on the sheer craziness of overpopulated cities. And conversations with the photographers open up an art scene only recently begun to emerge from shadow.
Edited by Gerald Matt, Thomas Miessgang. Essays by Olu Oguibe, Koyo Kouoh, Simon Njami. Photographers include: Philip Kwame Apagya, Dorris Haron Kasco, Seydou Keita, Boubacar Toure Mandemory, Bouna Medoune Seye, Malick Sidibe.
7.75 x 10.25 in.
57 color and duotone illustrations
Committed to the Image: Contemporary Black Photographers
Black Bodies

Black Bodies
by Jules Allen
Synopsis
In this volume, an African-American photographer seeks to confront and challenge the traditional ways in which the black female form has been presented. The images produced explore stereotypes of passivity and exoticism, removing the negativity associated with the black body.
Black Beauty: A History and a Celebration

Black Beauty: A History and a Celebration
by Ben Arogundade
Review by a reader from Geneva,Switzerland
Black Beauty examines the often complex and elusive subject of beauty and all its tenets in regards to continental Africans and more so, Africans of the diaspora.The text is rich in history and starts with an account of Saartje Baartman-the `Hottentot venus` in 1810.
We are further treated to a close look at Black representation throughout the 20th century,with chapters such as `Black Venus` 1940`s to 60, `Black is beautiful `1960`s heralding the emergence of Black Power, civil rights leaders such as Malcolm X and the general era of celebrating `Blackness` and self determination.The final chapter `Painted Black` deals with today`s icons, especially in the field of music and cinema, are highlighted and their global contributions and impact in shaping the Black existance and experience is examined. Brothers like Spike Lee and Tupac by virtue of greater access to,and in some cases,control of the mass media are featured,amongst many others.Sisters are there too!
No study of Black beauty could be complete without reference to the impact of the African slave trade-this is elucidated fully. Equally too, are the Black queens of Egypt and Ethiopia, as is the politics of beauty the wearing of the afro and dreadlocks, the significance of skin bleaching and the continual debate of dark skin Blacks being less attractive than lighter toned Blacks or Mixed race,etc.
Black Beauty is packed full of numerous excellent photographs and images, some rare, such as queen Charlotte Sophia of Mecklenburg-Strelitz, the Black wife of Englands George III. Jack Johnson, Ophella Devore, Donyale Luna Vogue`s first Black covergirl, Bob Marley, Tyson Beckford, Lil` Kim, Erykah Badu-in short, they are all there!!
Most definately not a book to be missed. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition
Three Artists in Symbolic Discourse by Zenzele Chulu
Image: Zenzele Chulu | Will PowerThree Artists in Symbolic Discourse
By Zenzele Chulu from Zambia
The Bag Factory Artists Studios, situated along Mahlatini street in Newtown, Johannesburg is hosting the KOPANO Residency, an artistic discourse between three artists under the banner `Revival of African Traditions`. Participating artists include Zambia`s Zenzele Chulu,
Sikhulile Sibanda from Zimbabwe and South Africa`s Madi Phala. An assortment of their collective works produced during the duration of their residence period, which begun from April to June are on display. A concurrent exhibition which is running between 14th to 22th
June 2005 was also christened `The Revival of African Traditions` - a theme, which is reflected visibly on the works of art showcased.
Artistic contents depicted on canvas and myriad sculptures, bear traditional infuences though expressed from a contemporary context. Zenzele`s works portray ancestral codes called schematic tantrums, inspired from the ancient first ever rock galleries on earth, while
Sikhulile`s sculptural expressions in metal - tell a story of joyful childhood experiences prevalent in typical African settings.And notwithstanding evident traces of being similar to rock art, her oil colour prints further depict human figures in flight. The Herdboyz,
signed by Madi Phala, is a colourful yet abstract imagery ot cattle-raring tradition and its related myths.
common threads
A flicker of professional camaraderie can be discerned from the use of the name KOPANO, which supposedly symbolizes the artistic re-connection of Madi, Sikhulile and Zenzele`s cultural elements, attributed to the common threads inherent in their Bantu and San
heritage. Their creative discourse and collaboration, nurtured during the residency has further spawned an artistic-inclined sense of belonging - thanks to their mutual and strong historical bond. - chuzen2410@yahoo.com
The Lost Art
Image: Suzanne Ouedraogo | Circumcision 2003The Lost Art
June 26, 2005 Edition 1
Author: Mary Corrigall
Source: The Sunday Independent | South Africa
Web Page: http://www.sundayindependent.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=1088&fArticleId=2598217
What makes an African artefact authentic?
Sacred objects that were once imbued with spiritual and cultural meaning are being mass produced across Africa and sold to tourists.
Stone sculptures, bead necklaces, wooden masks, animals made from wire and beads are being flogged en masse.
Have traditional artworks lost their significance as they gain monetary value? Do tourists still believe that these African knick-knacks are products of cultural expression? What makes an African artefact authentic?
Since the 1880s European colonialists have been fascinated by "primitive" objects produced by traditional African artisans.
This obsessive interest saw explorers, scientists and missionaries importing a wide range of artefacts back to their homelands. These objects were not only offered as proof that a "dark uncivilised world" existed parallel to their own but embodied an alternative belief system.
Most of these artefacts, which were not perceived to conform to western concepts of art, ended up on display in museums of ethnology and anthropology in European centres. Curiosity surrounding these African artefacts would not only kick-start the Modernist movement but came to symbolise a naive and simple way of life that industrialised societies believed they had altogether lost touch with.
Centuries later Africa still draws crowds of curious tourists in search of the stereotypical African experience. Part of this experience also entails tourists taking home their own piece of idealised Africa. African artisans, wishing to profit from tourist preconceptions, are only too happy to comply.
Jozi's Rosebank African Art Market is a popular pit stop for tourists. Lined with stalls selling objects from around Africa, one can pick up a mask from Senegal, a batik printed bolt of cloth from Zimbabwe or an Ndebele necklace.
Joe Flex, from Zimbabwe, has been selling African goods for seven years. His stand is packed with objects to satisfy any taste. Masks from Ivory Coast, Sierra Leone, Mali, Senegal and Congo. He says that he makes two trips a year to West Africa to stock up on goodies.
Flex infers that tourists have become wary about the origins of African objects. They aren't interested in artefacts mass produced in a factory, as that would not conform to their idea that African objects are shaped by primitive and spiritual culture found only in rural destinations.
Flex says that all his products are directly acquired from artisans in rural villages. He is, however, very vague about the makers of his products and how each piece is produced.
According to Flex, most of his clientele ask about the spiritual significance of his wares. Flex can tell a story about every item in his stall. "This is a mask from Ivory Coast," he says pointing to a wooden mask with horns. "It is used during royal ceremonies to pray for rain."
Aside from the masks, Flex sells a wide range of colonial figures.
Flex says that these brightly coloured wooden renderings of Africans in western dress were made in the Ivory Coast during colonisation.
According to Engaging Modernities, compiled by art historians at Wits university, these colonial figures are derived from the Baulé figures from the Ivory Coast, which were designed as a means to engage with spirit lovers in the other world. The emergence of western dress on these figures expressed high status.
Westerners were apparently fascinated by these figures, which were thought to reflect their own image.
As a result the Baulé figures were re-fashioned and carvers expanded their repertoire in the mid-1980s to meet the growing international demand for these wooden figurines.
Flex is a businessman, not an art historian; one would not expect him to know the origin of the objects he sells. However, most of his foreign clients are keen to know the history of an object.
Millicent Sirengo, from Kenya, who also sells at the Rosebank market, says that one can't just make up a meaning about an object to ensure a sale. Some tourists have done a bit of research themselves.
"Customers always ask where an object comes from and what [cultural] meaning it has," says Sirengo wearily.
Most of Sirengo's products hail from Zaire. Sirengo has never been to Zaire. She places her orders for the wooden sculptures over the phone. She asks her suppliers to provide her with details about the products, which she then passes onto her customers.
Although the elongated models of African ladies that she sells are manufactured in Zaire, she gets local Zulu crafters to embellish the figurines with beads. So in essence these objects are not strictly the product of one culture but a synthesis of two different cultures.
Aside from the free-standing sculptures at Sirengo's stall, she sells wooden sculptures of animals and other objects that come framed. The ornate wooden frames that box these wooden sculptures, says Sirengo, make it easier for tourists to display their wooden animals in their homes. This sort of presentation also makes it easier for tourists to perceive the sculptures as artworks.
The goods being sold at Sirengo's stall are not unique; three stalls down, another trader is selling identical artworks.
In a shopping mall, not far from the Rosebank African Art Market, there are a number of curios selling similar goods.
Batanai Artworks is one such shop. However, in this establishment one finds the crafters of the artworks busy at work. Tawanda Marufu, from Zimbabwe, is one of the artists. He says he learnt the craft from his father.
Most of the larger items on sale come with a certificate of authenticity. Marufu says that the certificates were introduced as a way of differentiating their products from the sculptures that are sold at flea markets. The certificate not only authenticates the artworks but it also gives a detailed description about the meaning and origin of the artworks.
Since the introduction of the certificates, Marufu says sales have increased dramatically. Although one can find identical looking sculptures at the market, Marfu says that their products are made from African stone and not soapstone, which makes the artworks more authentic and therefore more valuable. A sculpture that costs around R200 at the market will cost more than R1 000 here.
Marfu says that a lot of the wooden sculptures sold at markets are not made from treated woods; they are merely covered in shoe polish to create a more authentic look.
At Wits university's African art gallery, The Studio, one finds a collection of African artefacts that, based on appearances, do not look too dissimilar to some of the tourist art sold on the side of the road. What makes these artworks collectable, valuable and authentic?
Curator Julia Charlton consults experts to authenticate pieces for the gallery. However, she does suggest that accepted models used to discover authenticity in relation to African art is a contentious issue.
"The kinds of criteria that are usually applied to the concept of authenticity rarely hold up," Charlton says.
"The kinds of things that are usually considered are whether the item was made for use within their own community. But that implies a set of circumstances that are not borne out in the field.
"You may have a ritualist carver whose job it would have been to make ritual objects and he would be known as such, so you would have people coming from far and wide to him to have items commissioned."
Charlton suggests that artworks that are specifically produced for sale to tourists are often deemed inauthentic.
Charlton says that the age of a piece doesn't necessarily guarantee authenticity either; for many of the materials used to make African cultural objects don't stand the test of time, as they were not made to last.
Charlton also proposes that using the age of an artwork as a determining factor to substantiate authenticity presupposes "a static golden past from which there has been a steady slope downhill, which is not real".
Traditional African artworks that have incorporated modern materials or subject matter, Charlton says, shouldn't devalue an artwork either.
The value of an African artwork depends heavily on the buyer. For instance, Charlton says she is interested in acquiring pieces for the gallery that conform to traditional motifs and forms in appearance but have been fashioned out of a modern material like plastic.
Charlton suggests that international art buyers would not consider such an item to be of any value.
Fraud within the African art trade is rife, she says. Charlton says that after a gallery publishes a catalogue of a collection, identical objects copied from the photographs suddenly flood the market.
"Any tourist wants a souvenir, whether it's a postcard or a little something. However, tourists that come to Africa come with a lot of baggage [from the past]."
Crisis in Global Capital and The War on Culture

Image: Soly Cisse | Une Vie Social
Crisis in Global Capital and The War on Culture
The Artist as Producer in Times of Crisis
Source: http://t4.antville.org/stories/736829/
Okwui Enwezor: The Artist as Producer in Times of Crisis
On April 27, 1934 Walter Benjamin delivered a lecture at the Institute for the Study of Fascism in Paris. In the lecture, The Author as Producer, Benjamin addressed an important question that, since, has not ceased to pose itself, namely to what degree does political awareness in a work of art becomes a tool for the deracination of the autonomy of the work and that of the author? Benjamin’s second point was to locate what a radical critical spirit in art could be in a time of such momentous, yet undecided direction in the political consciousness of Europe: between the Bolshevik revolution in Russia and the productivist model of artistic practice it instantiated and the storms of repression unleashed by fascism and Nazism in Western Europe. In a sense, Benjamin’s lecture addressed the question of the artist’s or writer’s commitment under certain social conditions. This would lead him to ask What is the attitude of a work to the relations of production of its time? Georg Lukács posed a similar question in his 1932 essay Tendency or Partisanship? The conditions of production of the time, was the struggle between capitalism and socialism as the driving force behind modern subjectivity.
It is my intention in this lecture to extend the questions raised by these two thinkers and apply them to the critical context of contemporary culture today. Ever more so, Benjamin and Lukács are not only relevant, but crucial to understanding a visible turn that has become increasingly evident in the field of culture at large, that is the extent to which a certain critical activism in contemporary art has become a way to pose the questions raised seventy years ago anew through collective practices. My focus is not on activism per se, but on work driven by the spirit of activism that bear direct relationship to Benjamin’s and Lukács`s essays.
To that end, recent confrontations within the field of contemporary art have precipitated an awareness that there have emerged in increasing numbers, within the last decade, new critical, artistic formations that foreground and privilege the mode of collective and collaborative production. Is this return an acknowledgment of the repressed memory of a social unconscious? Is the collectivisation of artistic production not a critique of the poverty of the language of contemporary art in the face of large-scale co modifications of culture, which have merged the identity of the artist with the corporate logo of global capitalism? These questions shadow the return of collectivity in contemporary artistic practice and in so insistent a manner, across a broad geographic area that to ignore the consequences is to miss the vital power of dissonance that is part of its appeal to the contemporary thinkers and artists who propose collectivity as a course artistic work. Of course, we need not to be reminded that there is nothing novel about collectivity in art as such. It’s been a crucial strategy of the avant-garde throughout the 20th century. Therefore, a proper understanding of collectivity today would have to be traced through its affinities with past examples. This story belongs to the history of modernism proper.
The position of the artist working within collective and collaborative processes subtend earlier manifestations of this type of activity throughout the 20th century. Collectivity performs an operation of irruption and transformation on traditional mechanisms and activities of artistic production, which locates the sole figure of the individual artist at the centre of authorship. Under the historical conditions of modernist reification, collective or collaborative practices that is the making of an artwork by multiple authors across porous disciplinary lines generate a radical critique of artistic ontology qua the artist and as such also questions the enduring legacy of the artist as an autonomous, individual within modernist art. This concerns the question of the authenticity of the work of art and its link to a specific author. However, there is a level at which the immanence of this discourse is also evidenced in the critique of the author in postmodernism. On both levels, I would argue that the anxieties that circumscribe questions concerning the authenticity of either the work of art or the supremacy of the artist as author are symptomatic of a cyclical crisis in modernity about the status of art to its social context and the artist as more than an actor within the economic sphere. This crisis has been exceptionally visible since the last decade of the twentieth century. The political climate of the current global imperium adumbrates it further.
If we look back historically collectives tend to emerge during periods of crisis in moments of social upheaval and political uncertainty within society. Such crisis often forces reappraisals of conditions of production, re-evaluation of the nature of artistic work, and reconfiguration of the position of the artist in relation to economic, social, and political institutions. There are two types of collective formations and collaborative practices that are important for this discussion. The first type can be summarized as possessing a structured modus vivendi based on permanent, fixed groupings of practitioners working over a sustained period. In such collectives, authorship represents the expression of the group rather than that of the individual artist. The second type of collectives, tend to emphasize a flexible, non-permanent course of affiliation, privileging collaboration on project basis than on a permanent alliance. This type of collective formation can be designated as networked collectives. Such networks are far more prevalent today due to radical advances in communication technologies and globalisation. However, we shall trace the emergence of the artist as producer in times of crisis by first linking up with modernism. In collective work we witness how such work complicates modernism’s idealization of the artwork as the unique object of individual creativity. In collective work we also witness the simultaneous emporia of artwork and artist. This tends to lend collective work a social rather than artistic character.
Consequently, the collective imaginary has often been understood as essentially political in orientation with minimal artistic instrumentality. In other instances shared labour collaborative practice the collective conceptualisation of artistic work have been understood as the critique of the reification of art and the co modification of the artist. Though collaborative or collective work has long been accepted as normal in the kind of artistic production that requires ensemble work such as in music, in the context of visual art under which the individual artistic talent reigns such loss of singularity of the artist is much less the norm, particularly under the operative conditions of capitalism.
© Okwui Enwezor
What is Non-Art Made Of?
Image: Charly D'Almeida | GithareWhat is Non-Art Made Of?
Author: Marco Senaldi
Surprisingly, Duchamp did not take kindly to being called an anti-artist, preferring to be known as a non-artist. The anti-artist is like the atheist: he denies God because deep down he still believes in Him. The non-artist, meanwhile, does not believe, period. He does not believe in Art with a capital A, indeed he doubts the very identity of art.
Negation upon negation means we are left with no such thing as Art with a capital A, as the development of contemporary art goes hand in hand with its estrangement from the real world. What we now have is committed, realist, appropriationist art, from sources such as television and so on, yet try as it might to deny it, it mysteriously remains art. Why?
Like many other spiritual forms, art has shifted from symbolically legitimizing its products and producers, to an imaginary place which sees its very modus overturned and inverted. Whereas art once legitimized whoever produced it as an artist and the product as art anti-art has always been a sworn enemy of this, the situation as it stands today is different. The drawn-out struggle, first by the avantgardes, then by the post-war movements no exceptions to change the meaning, nature and essence of art has finally met with success. The process might be compared to the history of Coca Cola which, following years of pop exaltation and after various attempts to bring it down, has finally come up with non-Coca Cola: Diet Coke, which is Coke-free while remaining Coke. In other words, after all the struggles against essence without appearance and appearance without essence, we find ourselves with the essence in its overturned stage. While it might appear to be the contrary of itself, it nevertheless remains itself through its own denial.
The same can be applied to art. Contemporary art does not represent the most recent piece but the scrupulous and total re-flexion of art. Basically, all the destructively heated debate centering around art, prompted both by artists and by art itself, was not actually aimed at debunking the burden of old art in favor of new art, but had the often unwitting purpose of transubstantiating the mystical body of art itself, reducing it to an essence that was the inverse of itself.
What has sprung from this is non-art, not as the bastard progeny of a cross between the noble world of art and the spuriousness of the world out there, but the pure distillation of the highest possible reflection of art on itself - a diet-art which, while intrinsically art, remains art-free. Unable to exert anything but this reflection as an activity of symbolic adjustment it had already been brought to a close during Hegel`s time, art has devoured itself. Just when, perhaps with Duchamp, or even earlier, it coincided with its own definition, art was also signing its own spiritual last will and testament. Since then, art has transformed itself into an imaginary fact, an exercise of contradictory legitimization. Non-art is the sphere of life, the tin cans in the supermarket, the paving stones transplanted into the gallery, the fight against the powers that be translated into attractive images for magazines such as Artforum. It is and will remain art, but in a way that is twice-overturned, the identity of a spiritual form gained through negation and intended as a dialectic moment of reciprocal definition. Defining what is or what it is not art is not only the task of contemporary art but its very essence as the art-non-art of our times, an essence twice overturned, and therefore real.
Non-art is therefore marked by the constant inversion of the placement of every thing to which a symbolic value and identity is assigned: so, if a given thing is defined as art, it will immediately receive the status of other-than-art Brillo Box, game, divertissement, simulacrum and so on. Meanwhile, that which is other-than-art can be understood only in terms of its pertinence to art ready-made, installation, performance…. The constant paradoxical transition from one term of reference to another is inevitable.
The persistent contradiction between the thing and its reiteration without solution is what might be defined as the imaginary level of art or its status of double inversion, in other words obversion. What we must not overlook is that the imaginary is not confined to fantasy, and nor is it oneiric or surreally distant from reality. Malleability, for instance, is one of the features of the imaginary. It is certainly no coincidence that artists concerned with space, such as Lucio Fontana, should turn repeatedly to ceramics Fontana produced a range of bizarre ceramic objects that were mid-way between his spatial canvases and decoration. Spatialism is rooted in the malleability of something that is conceptually rigid such as space, a lesson we learn from the plastic spaces created by Giò Colombo. Earlier still, the futurists were pioneering the rediscovery of ceramics. Remember, they had spoken in terms of the futurist reconstruction of the universe, their crazed recipes even featuring a certain plasticmeat.
Obviously, plastic proved to be the ideal material for the imaginary realm, a material that allowed the impossible dream of objects that resisted deformation - unbreakable glasses, virtually eternal multicolored containers - to become reality. But the imaginary is also recursive, it turns on its own oversights, unable to contemplate that its own memories will evaporate, and that something might fall outside of its range of retrieval. Plastic would soon take over as the foremost material in our lives, just as wood was to the Medieval period, or iron during the industrial 1800s, to such an extent that ceramic today is not seen as the progenitor of plastic but as a substitute for it, bringing with it characteristics we had originally frowned upon: fragility, difficulties in the manufacturing process, a certain preciousness and so on.
The characteristic trait of our non-epoch is that the art non-art it expresses brings with it certain values belonging to the past - manual skill, imitation, craftsmanly quality and so forth - values which, precisely because they are outmoded, turn a thing into a salvage object, in the same spirit in which we protect certain species of animals because they are in danger of becoming extinct. This form of reflexive salvage would account for the fact that almost all the pieces by the artists invited to participate in this first edition of the Biennial of Ceramic in Contemporary Art are characterized by their non-identity. Although the artists present in this exhibition are representing a host of different disciplines and all pursue their own personal poetics, their relation with the ancient but futurable material, ceramic it is, after all, post-plastic, ensures the presence of true non-objects, objects which are at the same time more and less than themselves.
Cecchini`s fragile and therefore un-usable helmets, the pseudo-wigs, courtesy of Nina Childress, Torimitsu`s fake furs, Vitone`s phony amygdales, Perino and Vele`s rigid cushion, Costa Vece`s inedible cake, Sislej Xhafa`s living room manhole, Daniel Firman`s impossible yet functioning! LP`s, Pancrazzi`s mimetic but, alas, ceramic credit card, to name but a few, are all perfect examples of this simultaneous excess and constitutive dearth. They are all works that can be termed art, not so much for their pertinence to any cultural tradition as for the fact that they are the fruit of craftsmanly insight. In short, they are non-objects produced by a non-artistic will - they are in fact counterfeits, true paradoxes, contradictions in terms.
We should show deep-felt sympathy for these non-objects because they resemble us more than we could ever resemble ourselves. As false fossils, they represent not so much our history as our history as we would like it to be told. As evidence of the imaginary, neither subversive nor perverse but obverse, they explain perfectly our status as non-individuals, subjects with broken bones - though nonetheless committed to reconstructing those bones, perhaps in the highly fragile material that is ceramic.
Author: Marco Senaldi
Marco Senaldi is an art critic and philosopher. Teaches Phenomenology of Contemporary Art at the Carrara Academy of Fine Arts, Bergamo Italy.
His writings have appeared in numerous catalogues and collective publications. Translated and curated the Italian edition of texts by philosophers, Gilles Deleuze Spinoza, Guerini 1991, and Slavoj Zizek Il Grande Altro. Nazionalismo, godimento, cultura di massa, Feltrinelli ed. 1999. With A. Piotti, he wrote the essay Lo Spirito e gli Ultracorpi. Vicissitudine della ragione tra i sintomi dell`Immaginario, Franco Angeli, Milan, 1999. Writing of a further text, a work for four hands, titled Maccarone m`hai provocato! La Commedia all`italiana del Piccolo Sé is underway with Bulzoni Editore, Rome.
Senaldi is also working on Temi e comportamenti dell`arte contemporanea, Electa. He collaborates with Flash Art magazine, among other contemporary art and philosophy magazines, and wrote Italian cultural TV program Le notti dell`angelo 1994/95 for Canale 5 Onda Anomala, for Rai Tre 1998/99 and Cenerentola, 1999/2000.
Shifting Forward Through Art | Mustafa Maluka

Shifting Forward Through Art
Source: http://www.chico.mweb.co.za/art/2006/2006apr/060421-art.html
Mustafa Maluka’s gigantic portraits make us confront individuals from the outside. He spoke to Niren Tolsi
ike a runny-nosed kid begging on Long Street, there is a hunger to artist Mustafa Maluka. Only, his glue is information. His bleeding-heart Scandinavian backpacker is his own determination “to be a great painter” and for ragged clothes and mournful pleas, substitute paint, canvas and an ability to incisively interrogate notions of ourselves and “the other”.
Having grown up in Bishop Lavis on the Cape Flats, he left Cape Town as the typical clichéd struggling artist in 2000 to study at De Ateliers in Amsterdam and returned in 2004 with a Tollman Young Artist Award and an international reputation built on solo exhibitions in The Netherlands including 2001’s The Realness at the Galerie Tanya Rumpff, Haarlem and Hard Living (An Ethnomethodological Approach) at De Ateliers.
He has also participated in several group exhibitions, including Personal Affects: Power and Poetics in Contemporary South African Art at New York’s Museum for African Art in 2004 and at the 4th Biennale of the Pan African Circle of Artists in Lagos, Nigeria.
Maluka, who also runs a website called africanhiphop.com and helps release mix-tapes of young Cape Flats artists on his Aevenger label admits to the early positive effects of hip-hop culture: “Like most young people of my generation we grew up with hip-hop culture, we had it all around and you -- this culture and this consciousness -- and I’m grateful for that.
“For young people from the Cape Flats it’s provided us with an outlet, a passageway for us to reach higher goals. It still plays an important role and it shaped what and who I am today, but there is a certain point when you go off in your own direction when you start finding yourself and what your voice is,” he says.
Hip-hop culture which on the Cape Flats can be traced back to the Eighties and groups such as Prophets of da City and Black Noise, which are still involved in grassroots activity with youngsters -- has been the saviour for many people in ghettos filled with button-smoking-induced apathy and gangsterism. Maluka feels it instilled in him a “do-it-yourself attitude”, which saw him hold his first solo exhibition (Melanin Millennium) at the Mau-Mau Gallery in Cape Town in 1997. But it wasn’t just hip-hop. Maluka points to a politically conscious family and a father who started off as a bricklayer and is now a teacher studying towards his doctorate as further inspiration: “My father was the person who taught me about social constructions, this was before I even knew what it was. Then I started doing my own research and started reading philosophy, psychology, cognitive dissidence, which in some ways have led me to the themes I examine now.”
He studied graphic design for two years at Peninsula Technikon before having to drop out because of a lack of funds. While studying art theory there he “got introduced to all these artists like Andy Warhol, Roy Liechtenstein and Jean Michel Basquiat and I just latched on to what they were doing”. This proved a starting point for Maluka, who feels moving to Amsterdam and being surrounded by talented artists on a daily basis, the rigours of “the boot camp for young artists which was De Ateliers” and economic and social conditions conducive to focusing on his art helped his work shift forward aesthetically.
The experience of moving from being the Cape Flats outsider in Cape Town to being the outsider in a foreign land also impacted on what was a critical point in his development as both an artist and an adult.
Attempting to confound and question our preconceived notions, our stereotypical responses to language and people -- the “fragile” stickers on the socialised baggage we carry around with us -- Maluka combines elements of graffiti, pop art and graphic design in his work and likens an exhibition to “putting on a play”.
“I have these characters that I use ... I have this world that I have created with these people saying things, but these people represent people in the real world. Normally with each show I do I try and flesh out who they are and the experiences they go through.”
He held his first solo South African exhibition in seven years, Accented Living (A Rough Guide), at Michael Stevenson in Cape Town last year. According to Maluka, the figures represented “all had accents”.
“What are accents? Your accent is only noticed when you leave where you come from. It’s like a kid from the Cape Flats going into the city: he’s accented. He’s entering a world and a space that is foreign to him, it’s different to where he comes from, but it is the dominant world. And there is this negotiation that goes on. That’s an example to localise it. But I was thinking about me being in Amsterdam and being accented, a guy moving from India to England getting accented because accented people get treated differently depending on what kind of accent you have ... So in this Rough Guide, I was fleshing out aspects of these people’s personalities and the things they have to go through, which is mainly an immigrant experience.
“This is something I say over and over again: I feel that my generation of black people in this country, we are immigrants into South Africa. We are the new South Africans, South Africa is a country that already existed, but it was a white country from which we were excluded. We have been entering this space only in the past 10 years and in this process there is a lot of negotiation and renegotiation that is taking place and what you find is that people need to switch accents in order to fit in with the dominant group -- which is white people in society.”
About the artistic process, Maluka said: “How I produce these paintings, the portraits especially, is that I collect images with a particular gaze, they have to have a particular strength and pride. That’s a kind of starting point and I use these images as a shell. I’m not painting the person in the picture, it’s just a shell and I flesh it out with meaning by applying paint. That is when it becomes a painting.”
New Painting runs at the KZNSA Gallery in Durban until April 23 and moves to the Unisa Art Gallery, Pretoria from May 9 to June 2
David Goldblatt | Photographer | South Africa

David Goldblatt
The Humanity of Forms
South African photographer David Goldblatt exhibits at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. Alex Dodd speaks to him about the structure of things then and now.
The thing that sticks in my mind about that first conversation with photographer David Goldblatt is his insistence on the absence of a colon. He titles his exhibition, due to open at the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York this month, South Africa the Structure of Things Then. Under the circumstances, his particular zealousness about the fact that there should be no colon after the words South Africa seems intriguing - even a little amusing, at first.
But, once I start paging through his books, halted for minutes at a time by the stark and soulful images before me, a clue emerges. In Some Afrikaners Photographed (1975), I notice the way "the ladies from the office staff of the Mine Workers Union" fold their hands on their laps and consciously keep their knees together beneath the hems of their crimplene dresses. In On the Mines (1973), his beautifully real exploration of life on the Reef, I'm moved by the painful aptness of a quote by Albert Camus: "This people, plunged wholly in the present, lives with neither myths nor consolation." In Lifetimes Under Apartheid, "a maid on Abel Road, Hillbrow" protests against the blankness of the standard maid's overall with her furry hat and her distinctive spectacles.
Goldblatt's rigorous, almost religious attention to detail - whether it be in a seemingly innocuous comma or the Coca-Cola sign in the window of a corner café - is one of the things that makes him the artist he is today.
Not only is he the only South African photographer whose work is part of MoMA's permanent photographic collection. When his exhibition opens there in mid-July he'll become the only South African photographer to have a solo exhibition at the museum - one of the world's greatest repositories of modern art.
The images on show will be a selection of about 40 to 50 from a body of 135 images that make up a book due to be published by Oxford University Press in South Africa and Monacelli Press in New York.
In
South Africa the Structure of Things Then Goldblatt explores a wide variety of structures - "anything from churches to shops to huts to houses to government buildings to monuments to scrap to vehicles". He has sought out "the structures in South Africa which gave expression to or were evidence of some of the forces that shaped our society before the end of apartheid".
Although his work has been widely published and appreciated in Europe and the United States, Goldblatt has always made his photographs with a South African audience in mind. His work is proudly parochial, yet deeply universal in its concerns.
Writes Susan Kismaric, the curator of the MoMA exhibition: "As an American, my first reaction is to respond to the photographs with a kind of chilled revulsion. As I continue to look, I find them to be increasingly complex. The aspiration toward 'higher goals' - spirituality, striving, courage, refuge ... - as expressed in many of the buildings initially appears as something separate from or in violation of the land and its people ...The work resonates for me in many ways, not the least of which is that it captures how absolute, how pervasive the evil of apartheid is. The contrast between these structures and those that were destroyed reveals yet another aspect of the story."
A little nervous of terms like "the pervasive evil of apartheid", I find myself sitting opposite Goldblatt in his garden in Fellside, Johannesburg, and noticing the way my fork enters the tomato on my plate. I'm certain it is his way of speaking, his way of articulating himself so consciously that has brought my attention to the tomato and the way I am cutting it. I'm aware of the vertical and the horizontal that make up the table and of the limitless expanse of winter sky above us. "Structures?" I ask. "What motivated your decision to move away from human subject matter?"
"I don't see any difference between these structures and humanity - they are really an extension of each other. I've always felt that if you wanted to do a portrait of a person, why the face? What's peculiar about the face? Why not the foot, the backside, the back, the arm? And, by extension, why not the things people value and build? People put emotion into the things that they build.
"So to me buildings are real extensions of us. If I'm photographing a person, I'm very interested to see their home. It's a part of them. These things to me are very important and always have been. They're simply an extension of the human being."
I am reminded of a phrase from In Boksburg in which Goldblatt writes of his search for "intimacy and dispassion". It's the dispassion I'm interested in. It recalls an idea put forward by American cultural analyst Susan Sontag in her book On Photography. In it she speaks about how the action of shooting a subject distances the photographer from the reality of the moment. So, in a sense, the photographer ends up processing the image chemically instead of metaphysically.
"I think Susan Sontag touched on some valid matters. It is very easy to take shelter behind the lens - to look at the subject from behind this machine so that the subject is naked and you're protected," says Goldblatt, "But what she didn't explore is that in photography it's possible to become aware of these things and work with that awareness.
"Once I became aware that this was happening to me, I deliberately reconstructed my way of working. If I'm doing a portrait, for example, as far as is possible I don't look through the camera. I set up the camera, I frame the picture and then I'm one-to-one with you."
Sweet elucidation - Goldblatt's words shed light on the honesty, the directness of the gaze, the openness and trust in his portraits. Looking at them, one is overcome by a sense of miracle - that people have allowed him in. That, despite our ruthless divisions, Afrikaners and Jews, Italians and Zulus have granted him access into their most private worlds - their once necessarily sheltered South African ghettoes.
And yet, says Goldblatt, "I very seldom try to build up a relationship in the sense of talking and putting people at ease. I don't want to. For me the most interesting photographs have tension in them and tension doesn't come from comfort.
"Not that I deliberately try to make the subject feel ill at ease. But I want to retain a certain kind of tension so that the subject feels he/she is actually on view. And 'how shall I show myself if I'm on view?' It's a very subtle thing that happens. This is the way I work."
I am drawn in by this austere love with which Goldblatt seems to approach the world - again this notion of intimacy and dispassion. "They have to go together. There needs to be a certain distancing. In the sense that you're aware of what you're seeing. You're seeing perhaps a woman who is broken by all sorts of personal things - her marriage is on the rocks ... You need to see how this is actually working. At the same time you need to become quite intimate with her.
"It's almost a sexual thing. Not because she's a woman. The subject might be a man, a woman or a building. It's sexual in the sense that you establish a very strong momentary relationship with the subject. I think the photographic act is very close to a sexual act. When the photographic act reaches its climax and it's a good one, it's like a sexual climax.
"And things that might turn you on in photography might seem very strange, but to me they're very sexual. Light! I mean I can wake up in the Highveld light and become almost maddened by the quality of the light. So this is part of being alive. Sex is part of being alive. To me these things are not separate compartments. They're one."
In terms of what he says about this "sexual moment", does Goldblatt experience a difference between photographing a human being and a building? "It doesn't differ at all," he says, "because in both you have to try to penetrate the nature of what you're seeing. You have to somehow grasp its essentials. Exactly that has to apply to a building. The essential difference is that the building is completely inanimate. It doesn't respond to you."
So you're in greater control? "Yes, but at that same time, you're in a much more difficult situation. Because the building will do absolutely nothing for you. You have to walk around it, walk through it - in it. Smell it, touch it, look at it from different angles, climb a koppie. So you have to find those aspects of a structure. And usually you'll find there's a way of looking at the building that seems logically, emotionally, in every way to bring it all together.
"Even though it might be a higgledy-piggledy structure, there were certain human needs that had to be met, so they built it in a certain way. Now you've somehow got to find, by looking at it, how that would best be shown in a photograph."
The building might be a Dutch Reformed church and it might be a grass hut built by a woman in KwaZulu. Either way, engagement with the building is, to Goldblatt, a kind of indirect relationship with the architect. This is the essence of his exhibition - to explore the human ethos behind the structures he photographs.
"Very often," he says, "the more sophisticated a building becomes, the more obfuscated its meaning is. Then you're dealing with the architect's understanding of what the client needs or wants, and the architect's desire to impose on that his own expressive needs, professional prerogatives or politics.
"In South Africa I feel this has happened to a far lesser extent than it has in, say, Europe or America. Our structures tend to be quite bare, quite naked. We declare ourselves with extraordinary frankness in what be build. It's as though we hold our souls up for the rest of the world to see."
Contemporary Visual Art from Ghana
Image: George Hughes | GangstaContemporary Visual Art from Ghana
by George Hughes
Painting by George Hughes
An Overview
Museums and galleries all over the world regard traditional African art of high aesthetic value. A reputation ignited by the overwhelming influence African art had on modernist European artists at the beginning of the twentieth century. This impact and positive status of traditional African art has over decades resulted in laudable exhibitions, acquisition and documentation of such antiques. Nevertheless, not much favorable interest and documentation is offered most contemporary art of Africa. It is being criticized for being universal and failing to meet the stereotypical African art tradition. This is also the case for contemporary art in Ghana.
Contemporary art in Ghana
The idea of grouping Ghanaian artists is an anomaly because of its complexity. The artistic climate of Ghana is made up of a variety of styles. This stylistic pluralism may be due to several factors and influences such as ethnicity, religion, education, westernization, globalization and aesthetic preferences of the individual artist under consideration. The complex social structure of the Ghanaian society is due in part to the fact that there are about 79 languages spoken in a country whose population is about 19 million in the year 2000. The Ghanaian cultural melting pot is compounded by the fact that several religions are being practiced. It is within this social fabric that most Ghanaian artists coexist and evolve their aesthetic ideas.
Stylistic groupings create problems such as marginalization, especially when such divisions reference the hierarchy of what is, and what is not art - a barrier that pushes some artists to the periphery and favors a few others.
The intent, purpose and dynamics of ongoing African art has changed to become much more eclectic because of the continent`s experience with proselytism, slavery, and colonialism. Art of any historic era is a direct reflection of the circumstantial ambience past and present within that very setting. Culture is dynamic and susceptible to influence and change. Current art created in Africa is a fabric of the cosmopolitan melting pot, a protean of its past, a reality of its present and a determinant of its future. To this effect, therefore contemporary Ghanaian visual art is a direct offspring of the poly-traumatic African chronicle.
From a general perspective, one may be tempted to categorize Ghanaian visual artists into groups due to which generation they belong to, or the stylistic similarities and differences, within their work. I am much more interested in looking at the Ghanaian art scene from a panoramic viewpoint of the various artistic modes of expression. I am also compelled to concentrate only on those fine artists who have gone beyond formative years, attained a personal stylistic consistency, allowed progressive experimentation, and have been working. This is by no means a complete representation of all the Professional visual artists working in Ghana today.
General characteristics
Contemporary Ghanaian visual artists are usually unaffiliated to any artistic movements. They are open to a tremendous exploration of indigenous and universal ideas, formal or informal, and are poised to exhibit their works to both local and international audience. In addition some of these independent fine artists create work that shows evidence of experimentation, of research, and an openness that seeks to break the barriers of cultural stagnation through the combination of emotional and intellectual acuity. Ghanaian artists receive art training from varied sources. Some are self-taught and the majority of them receive formal training in Ghana and abroad. They either receive tertiary education at the College of Art, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, training from private institutions such as Ghanatta or Ankle School of Art, both located in Accra apprenticeship from private sign writing workshops, or are self-taught. There are evidently aesthetic differences in the works of artists who receive training at academic institutions and those who go through apprenticeship at sign writing workshops. These differences are not necessarily qualitative but rather stylistic alternatives made by the artists as a result of the opportunities and circumstances they encounter, a conclusion that may displease two schools of thought - firstly, those who believe that College education absolutely yields art of the highest caliber, and secondly those who deride formal training as adulteration and derivative of Western ideas, hence inauthentic. I am compelled to state that artists whose works are often described derogatory as naïve, folk, derivative, grotesque, universal, or academic, and therefore inauthentic may actually be making tremendous inroads and breaking the barriers of the status quo beyond reason, and tradition. After all what do artists need, but an irresistible amount of tenacity beyond hurdles. Influence, either conscious or subliminal is a powerful experience that grips thirsty minds. The concept of borrowing aesthetic ideas from other cultures has been instrumental in the development of art in various societies. Roman artists borrowed ideas from Greek art. European cubists` fascination with and adaptation of the treatment of form in traditional African sculpture is credible and commendable. It is with the same curiosity and empathy that some contemporary Ghanaian visual artists embrace African and Western art forms.
Symbolism and tradition
A distinguishable group of Ghanaian independent artists are those who are conceptually inspired by African symbols and traditional forms such as adinkra motifs, traditional stools, sculptures, and also ideas about African identity. Oku Ampofo and Vincent Kofi are earlier Ghanaian sculptors who borrowed extensively from traditional African concepts of stylization, emphasis, distortion and symbolism. Public commissions of relief panel murals and busts and monuments of Saka Acquaye, resonate the traditional African practice of the artist`s duty to State. Owusu Ankomah uses in his prints and paintings colossal male figures superimposed on ideograms and symbols. Through an acute reductive system of visual selection Ankomah attains profundity with suspended shapes that defy gravity and attain a metaphysical significance. Martin Dartey, greatly influenced by traditional African art, uses his knowledge in African history as leverage to deliver sociopolitical themes in his paintings.
Figuration
Artists under this group create work by perceiving and interpreting forms, structures and activities within their immediate environment. The human figure, groups and crowd scenes become the central themes with the figurative artists. Generally the figures, draped in traditional costumes, are in action and either idealized, stylized and/or abstracted. These artists do work that celebrates the everyday realities of Ghanaians such as scenes at the congested open markets, crowded beaches, dancers, musicians, horse riders, lorry stations, bustling beaches and all the paraphernalia that comes with crowd scenes. The pioneer of figuration in Ghana who worked before and around the 1950s and 60s was the late Kofi Antobam. Antobam`s work features natural proportions of humans in complex compositions with content set on royalty, and scenes from the everyday lives of Ghanaians. Since independence forty-five years ago, great transformations in the Art of Ghana have taken place. Several artists have developed alongside one another, with mutual, overlapping influence and juxtaposed parallelisms. Veteran artists within the figurative group are sculptors like Oku Ampofo, Saka Acquaye, Vincent Kofi. and painters like Ablade Glover, Ato Delaquis and Amon Kotei. Color orchestration appears in the work of Amon Kotei through the use of the female model going through her daily chores. Whereas Ablade Glover`s impasto surfaces metaphorically exhume the elegance within the female form, Ato Delaquis creates detailed, color-modulated panoramic scenes of Ashanti warriors and vehicular scenes. Abstracted and condensed color fields act as a delicate veil in Wiz Kudowor`s pointillist figuration of idealized forms. Robert Aryeetey uses subtle colors and creative lines to evoke figures poetically. Evidently there is the rarity of politically fuelled work being done in Ghana. However Kofi Setordji defies the clichés within the everyday festive subject matter and engages the viewer with his succinct socio-politically charged themes. In addition Godfried Donkor`s bold and graphic references to Slavery, the Diaspora, and the plight of minorities encroaches on an avoided content. Donkor is based in London and works in digital and painting media.
Transcendence
The transcendental artists create work that eludes direct representation because these works are symbolically encased within intangible percepts and constructs. In other words what you see on the surface is color and form yet underneath is immense meaning that can only be hinted at either by the title or in dialogue with the artist. The transcendental artists distance their selves from direct communication of meaning and rely deeply on the subliminal, masking and camouflage. In essence the quality of their work is gold foiled in dust. An exponent of this group of Ghanaian artists is Atta Kwami who through his paintings and installations makes intellectual references to familiar Ghanaian local structures such as kiosks, stalls, and suburbs. Kwami creates the transformation of the familiar and often ignored subject matter into an elevated aesthetic, through concise color and shapes. Nanart J.D. Agyeman interprets Ghanaian proverbs in detailed and colorful linear shapes at once mystical and visually organic.
Vocational Designers
In the last two decades some creative Vocational designers such as carpenters, seamstresses, tailors, and hairdressers have attracted the attention of Western historians. A notable achiever within this group of designers is Samuel Kane Kwei and his custom- made coffins that replicate in sculpture recognizable forms such as cars and boats. Caroline Monda Dartey, wife of the Painter Martin Dartey designs African beads and bags from an intellectual perspective. Hopefully her example will inspire female artists in Ghana to pursue professional careers in art.
This recognition of Ghanaian artisans and designers as fine artists has widened the parameters of what is art, and poses the question - who determines the fine art of a people, and upon what qualitative criteria is the measure of fine art based upon? The most crucial question to pose however at this juncture is whether the functional intent of the designers disqualifies them as fine artists? It is however reasonable to state that if most fine artists, who create art for its intrinsic value are seeking recognition in the mainstream, so too some may argue designers would not disallow the respect of galleries, and museums, should the opportunity arise. If the idea of art as a universal language still holds, then it is not harmful to allow all art to be tested and to undergo study and scrutiny, within relative knowledge, empathy and expertise of connoisseurs without recourse to suspicion. The above may seem almost impossible because of the magnitude of art produced by humans all over the world. The closest one can get to this ideal of an open exposure will still require a clear distinction of quality in terms of differences between excellence and mediocrity, between formative and mature and between kitsch and the classic.
Works of art emerge from diverse sources with varied intent and therefore it is wiser to keep an open mind, slow to judgment. If art can thrive on convergent and divergent ideas, of influence and tradition, of the rejection of conventions, and by borrowing from unprecedented sources across board, then the idea of a pure art devoid of influence does not exist and cannot be used as a measure to qualify the authentic in art. Thanks to primitivism, postmodernism, modernism, tradition and academism. Above all thanks to the freedom of expression. This is not a blind wholesale concert that allows every piper to horn along. Rather it is an epiphany of reality that within various times and settings there happens to be multiple alternatives and applications of various qualities of Art. Within these diverse settings is the bitter hierarchy of what is acceptable and unacceptable, a phenomena instituted by those in authority, by society, by institutions, by trends, factions, artists and finally by posterity. In the end Art is the victor.
--
Postscript:
George Hughes is a painter and a poet. He was born in Ghana and works and lives in the U.S.
Hughes has taught at Bowling Green State University and the University of Toledo. Now he is working as an assistant professor at the Art Faculty of the University of Oklahoma. An active exhibitor, Hughes regularly shows his work in England, Germany, the Netherlands, the U.S. and Ghana. His paintings are mostly executed in mixed media: acrylics, oils, spray paint, polyurethane enamels, fabric paint, oil pastels and found objects.
Previous Critiques on Contemporary African Art
Image: Jimoh Buraimoh | Drummers ReturnPrevious Critiques on Contemporary African Art
Dates: 1960 - 2003
Sureys and Critiques
http://www.sil.si.edu/SILPublications/ModernAfricanArt/maa-start.htm
Source: Compiled by Janet L. Stanley
National Museum of African Art Library
Smithsonian Institution Libraries
__________________
GENERAL
Surveys and Critiques
1966 Brown, Evelyn S. Africa`s contemporary art and artists: a review of creative activities in painting, sculpture, ceramics and crafts of over 300 artists working in the modern industrialized societies of some of the countries of subSaharan Africa. New York: Division of Social Research and Experimentation, Harmon Foundation, 1966. 136pp. illus. N7397.S3B87 AFA. OCLC 1063546.
The Harmon Foundation promoted artists from Africa and sponsored exhibitions in the United States as early as the 1950s. The first attempt of the Harmon Foundation to compile a directory of African artists was in 1961 Evelyn Brown`s 1966 directory was the second, considerably more substantial effort. For many years it stood as the sole directory of African artists, and now stands as an historical marker of the mid-1960s. The archival files generated by this compilation are now in the Library of Congress other records of the now-defunct Harmon Foundation are in the National Archives in Washington, DC.
April 1966 McEwen, Frank. Modern African painting and sculpture, pp. 427-437. In: Colloquium: function and significance of African Negro art in the life of the people and for the people, March 30-April 8, 1966 organized by the Society of African Culture S.A.C. with the co-operation of UNESCO, under the patronage of the Senegalese Government. Paris: Presence africaine, 1968. At head of title: 1st World Festival of Negro Arts, Dakar, April 1-24, 1966. NX587.C714 1966 volume 1 AFA. OCLC 1874183.
McEwen`s defense of the workshop approach to nurture creative artists in Africa is forceful, fearless, and unapologetic: personal inducement of inborn talent is the way to go. He lashes out at Western-style art schools in Africa as producers of mediocrity and killers of talent, headed by bemedalled academic nonentities. With traditional African art dead or dying, Africa`s creative energies are all too often channeled into the demeaning production of airport art -- the disparaging epithet which McEwen is credited with coining.
In the workshop scenario, many are called but few are chosen, in what McEwen calls a metaphoric anthill, where the supreme emerge on the corpses of many. The success of McEwen`s Workshop School at the National Gallery of then Rhodesia is a case in point. He argues that although there is no African tradition from which these works of stone sculpture spring not as yet any corrupting influence from European art, they are clearly African in character. The explosive talent in Africa, its potential unrealized, faces a real threat from becoming stultifyingly bland and boringly imitative by exposure to the aridity of international art. How long can it remain African?
The year is 1966. It would be many years before McEwen`s paternalistic, if well-intentioned, views about modern African art were challenged.
Sept-Oct 1966 Art nègre, Vivante afrique Namur, Belgium no. 246: 1-53, septembre-octobre 1966. illus. BV3500.A3G75 AFA.
Vivante afrique , a Belgian Catholic missionary journal, devoted a special issue to the emerging African art forms evident at the time of the 1966 World Festival of Negro Arts in Dakar. It is interesting as an historical document of the period in recognizing that African art was indeed becoming something new and that the role of the African artist was changing. Among the several artists whose works are illustrated are Christian Lattier Côte d`Ivoire, Ignace Bamba Congo Democratic Republic, Benjamin Mensah Ghana, Paul Ayi Togo, Kitsiba Congo, and Ibou Diouf Senegal.
Partial contents: Un laboratorie de formes neuves pp. 14-22 L`artiste moderne en divorce avec son peuple, pp. 25-31 Que sera l`art africain de demain? pp. 32-42 Art nègre: utopie ou vocation, pp. 43-52.
Image: Twins Seven Seven | The King's Cock1968 Beier, Ulli. Contemporary art in Africa. London: Pall Mall Press New York: Frederick Praeger, 1968. xiv, 173pp. illus. pt. color. N7380.B42a AFA/N7380.B42 AFA. OCLC 463332/OCLC 1234759.
An important early survey of contemporary African art focusing on the new artists, that is, those working in non-traditional modes and settings. Covers all the new schools of art with particular emphasis on Beier`s own experience with the Oshogbo artists.
Reviewed by E. Okechukwu Odita in Africa Report New York January 1970, pp. 39-40.
1973 Mount, Marshall Ward. African art: the years since 1920. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1973. 236pp. illus. pt. color., bibliog. N7391.65.M68 1973X AFA. OCLC 861736.
Mount`s survey of modern African art is much read and often quoted in part because so little was published on the subject, but also because it is a fair-minded and broadly based survey of the state of contemporary African art in the early 1970s. The survey looks at the various art school and workshop traditions e.g., English-speaking countries, French-speaking countries and at thematic topics, such as mission-inspired art or souvenir art. As a text it has stood the test of time reasonably well, but must today be viewed as an historical survey.
1973 Mount, Marshall Ward. African art: the years since 1920. New York: Da Capo Press, [1989], c1973. xviii, 236pp. illus., bibliog. Reprint of the 1973 edition with new introduction. N7391.65.M68 1989X AFA. OCLC 19887831.
This is a reprint of Mount`s 1973 text see preceding entry presented without change apart from the removal of three color plates that appeared in the original edition. Mount does, however, provide a new six-page introduction to update and correct some of the earlier information, following the chapter outline of his original work, e.g. mission-inspired art, souvenir art, etc. Still, the intervening years from 1973 to 1989 have witnessed so many developments and new artists on the modern art scene in Africa, which cannot be dealt with in six pages, that this book remains an historical look at the subject.
1974Oledzki, Jacek. The contemporary African art, some remarks on new trends in the development of sculpture, Africana bulletin Warsaw no. 21: 9-35, 1974. illus. VF -- Artists - General.
New forms of artistic expression abound in Africa, but remain overshadowed by traditional genres or ignored by scholars. New sculptural forms have emerged more slowly than painting see Oledzki`s article Les peintures de l`Afrique noire -- next entry and have been more greatly influenced by market tastes. Commemorative sculptures, inspired by Christianity or by syncretic churches, comprise an inventive and original stream of creativity arising from local concerns and needs. Sepulchral monuments, vaults, and cemetery statuary in cement and clay are widespread in West Africa. Oledzki illustrates several examples from Cameroon and southern Nigeria.
In the popular arts, sculptural equivalents of barbershop signs occur in sculpted, painted wood mannikin heads. Other examples of sculptures as advertisement can readily be cited. Sculptural innovation also occurs within traditional contexts, e.g., reliefs on Bamileke meeting houses. Makonde sculpture, however, arises as a purely commerical venture.
Oledzki, Jacek. Les peintures de l`Afrique noire, Africana bulletin Warsaw no. 20: 9-46, 1974. illus. VF -- Commerical Art.
One of the livelier forms of popular arts in Africa are the barbershop signs, which are found in cities and towns across West, Central and East Africa. Painted vehicles of public transport are another exhuberant popular art expression in Africa. Bar painting is yet a third common public art form, equally imaginative and colorful. One muralist working in a different vein is a Kano artist, named Suly, who has distinguished himself by the paintings he executes on outside walls of private residences and compounds. Less well known are rural homes for example, in Cameroon, Central African Republic and Congo Democratic Republic with whitewashed exterior walls painted with figurative murals. Church murals are also found in these same regions, both fairly recent phenomena. The popular arts in Africa today are not ethnically based, as older art forms were. They differ, too, from paintings of elite artists. These paintings described by Oledzki are created by and for the people.
1975 Delaquis, H. Ato. Dilemma of the contemporary African artist, Transition Accra 9 50: 16-30, October 1975-March 1976. illus. qDT433.2.T772 AFA.
The dilemma for the African artist is where to position himself between a cultural heritage not fully lived or experienced and an artistic neo-colonialism that insists on cultural referents in anything called modern African art. What is needed is a neo-African cultural response to present day realities in Africa.
Why is it that realism is regarded as taboo for contemporary African artists? Possibly because too many attempts to achieve it were and still are unconvincing. Tradition-inspired art which emerged in the 1940s and 1950s has in most cases been equally unconvincing. Some educated artists have self-consciously sought to retrieve a romanticized past, but much of this experimentation has proved arid. In fact, both realism and tradition-inspired art are legitimate avenues for the African artist to explore. The modern artist, however, must recognize that his spiritual connectedness to tradition is quite different from that of the village artist, and the resulting art works must necessarily be different. Creating an art for art`s sake poses new sorts of intellectual challenges. The modern artist needs to reconnect with his present-day society, a vastly different reality.
Accusations of derivation and imitation are particularly acute and sensitive ones for the intellectual African artist. Criticized on the one hand for being derivative of Western art forms and, on the other, for losing one`s roots, he cannot win.
The concluding portion of Delaquis` essay on The Modern International Outlook was to have been published in the next issue of Transition volume 9, no. 51. But the journal folded, and it was never published.
1976 Ethnic and tourists arts: cultural expressions from the fourth world / edited by Nelson H. H. Graburn. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976. xv, 412pp., [4] leaves of plates. illus. pt. color, bibliog. N5311.E73X AFA. OCLC 2762615.
Graburn`s introductory essay constitutes a pivotal statement on the nature of fourth world arts. In it he sets up categories of creative production: extinction traditional or functional fine arts commercial fine arts souvenirs reintegrated arts assimilated fine arts popular arts. There are four essays out of twenty relating directly to Africa: Changing African art, by William Bascom `A la recherche du temps perdu`: on being an ebony-carver in Benin, by Paula Ben-Amos The decline of Lega sculptural art, by Daniel P. Biebuyck Functional and tourist art along the Okavango River, by B. H. Sandelowsky.
1978Moderne konst i Afrika Modern art in Africa / text by C. O. Hultén [and others]. Lund, Sweden: Kalejdoskop, 1978. 136pp. illus. pt. color, bibliog. Text in Swedish with English summaries. N7380.M68 AFA. OCLC 6110928.
The Swedish art publication Kalejdoskop spent about three years pulling together a special issue devoted to modern art south of the Sahara under the guidance of artist C. O. Hultén. In a series of essays, he and other writers survey some of the new developments and art movements that define modern African art: Mbari, Poto Poto, and Thèis. Also covered are short synopses on individual artists, including among others, Malangatana, Skunder Boghossian, Baby Joachim Daman-M`Bemba, Vincent Kofi, Amadou Seck, Asiru Olatunde, and Jimoh Buraimoh. There is an essay on monumental public art and another on the cultural politics of FESTAC.
1980 Leyten, Harrie M. and Paul Faber. Moderne kunst in Afrika. Amsterdam: Tropenmuseum Zutphen: Terra, [1980]. 94pp. illus. pt. color, map, bibliog. Text in Dutch. N7391.65.L49X AFA. OCLC 08194607.
The 1980 exhibition of modern African art at the Tropenmuseum in Amsterdam followed close on the heels of the Berlin Festival Horizon `79 and featured much of the same work and themes: self-taught and commercial artists, workshop artists, and academic artists. In their essay, Leyten and Faber place these widely scattered new art movements into a context of evolution and change in Africa.
1984 Jules-Rosette, Bennetta. The messages of tourist art: an African semiotic system in comparative perspective. New York: Plenum Press, 1984. xviii, 266pp. illus., bibliog. N7399.65.J85 1984X AFA. OCLC 10778364.
This book examines tourist art as a system of symbolic and economic exchange. Drawing upon seven years of fieldwork in Zambia, Kenya and the Ivory Coast -- plus information collected in the United States on the consumer response to African tourist artwork, Jules-Rosette integrates a theoretical approach to the sociology of culture with firsthand ethnographic evidence of the production and exchange of tourist artwork in an international context. She rejects the assumption that tourist art is mass produced and challenges the view that tourist art is inferior to, or even separate from, high or traditional art. She shows that although the economic motive in tourist art production alters both the creative process and the artistic display, it does not determine the final product. In-depth interviews with grass-roots painters, potters, woodworkers, tinsmiths, and ivory carvers -- along with forty-nine illustrations of the artists and their work -- provide graphic documentation of how the messages of tourist art shape and reflect culture. -- from the book`s dust cover.
Reviewed by Simon Battestini in African studies review Atlanta 30 2: 104-105, June 1987.
1986Jules-Rosette, Bennetta. Aesthetics and market demand: the structure of the tourist art market in three African settings, African studies review Los Angeles 29 1: 41-59, 1986. bibliog.
Rejecting the notion of ethnoaesthetics, Jules-Rosette defines tourist art as a media of communjuleication between the new art producers and their audience she analyses aesthetics in village markets as exemplified by Korhogo carvers or Lele raffia makers and in popular art markets as exemplified by Lusaka commercial painters or Kamba carvers she goes into the history of Kamba carving tradition which dates to the early years of the 20th century and derives from Makonde work.
1986Fosu, Kojo. 20th century art of Africa. Zaria: Gaskiya Corporation, 1986. vii, 241pp. illus. pt. color, portraits, bibliog. N7380.5.F758 1986 AFA. OCLC 14259840.
A conscientious but not wholly successful attempt to survey contemporary art in Africa organized roughly thematically by school or workshop, e.g., Polly Street Art Center, Zaria Rebels, Makerere Direction, Coptic Infusion and so forth. The focus is on black African artists with primary emphasis on the decades of the 1960s and 1970s.
1986 Fosu, Kojo. 20th century art of Africa. Zaria: Gaskiya Corporation, 1986. vii, 241pp. illus. pt. color, portraits, bibliog. N7380.5.F758 1986 AFA. OCLC 14259840.
A conscientious but not wholly successful attempt to survey contemporary art in Africa organized roughly thematically by school or workshop, e.g., Polly Street Art Center, Zaria Rebels, Makerere Direction, Coptic Infusion and so forth. The focus is on black African artists with primary emphasis on the decades of the 1960s and 1970s.
1987 Airport art: das exotische Souvenir . Stuttgart: Institut für Auslandsbeziehungen, 1987. 118pp. illus. color. N8217.E88A29 1987 AFA. OCLC 17466554.
On tourist art worldwide, including several Africa-related contributions. Hermann Pollig, in his essay entitled Airport art, provides an overview of airport, or tourist art, worldwide, discussing themes, market responses to demands, copies and trivializations, new materials and new forms. Ronald Ruprecht Airport Art in Nigeria argues that Nigeria, lacking a mass tourist market as found in East Africa, has not developed the same kind of souvenir art. Here one sees copies and spin-offs of genuine objets d`art. The Benin ivory mask, symbol of FESTAC, inspired a whole host of souvenir pieces big and small. Benin heads and Yoruba twin figures ibeji are also recreated in a variety of sizes and materials ceramic ibeji!.
Dieter Göltenboth Cottage industries -- die Definition des afrikanischen Kunsthandwerks durch europaische und merikanische Designer maintains that the ways in which foreign consumers and foreign design have shaped and driven craft production in East Africa is reflected in both tourist art and recycling of goods. New objects for the tourist trade e.g., wooden animal puzzles, old objects from new materials e.g., Kamba baskets woven in plastic, and new objects from old materials recycled rubber tires and inner tubes all respond to new demand and/or availability of raw materials. In a second essay Makondeschnitzer in Ostafrika, Göltenboth discusses modern Makonde carving, which is probably the African tourist art most widely known it has become a major industry in Tanzania and Kenya today, both as a production and a marketing enterprise. Its initial impetus came from mission and colonial influences and encouragement. Lastly, Göltenboth explains Masai, die Vermarktung des `edlen Wilden` that the marketing of the Maasai for the tourist trade goes beyond airport art. The Maasai also market themselves in photo opportunities and staged dances. But it is the Kamba carvers who are cashing in on the trade with woodcarvings of Maasai masks and figures depicting Maasai warriors.
Heidwig Hadidi-Feuerherdt Aus dem Land der Pharaonen confirms that pharaonic kitsch for the tourist market is nothing new. Its most enduring and popular images and themes are pyramids, the Obelisk, the Sphinx, Nefertiti, Tutankhamen, scarabs and the Horus eagle.
1987Jules-Rosette, Bennetta. Rethinking the popular arts in Africa: problems of interpretation, African studies review Atlanta 30 3: 91-97, September 1987.
One of four commentaries on Karin Barber`s paper on popular arts in Africa see Barber above. Setting forth the matrix used by Barber for the production and consumption of popular arts, Jules-Rosette finds it rigid and misleading with respect to understanding the role of the artist in the process of negotiating between producers and consumers culture brokers.
She takes issue with the pidginization thesis of tourist art advanced by Ben-Amos and invoked by Barber, because it ignores the communicative and symbolic dimensions of art. She proposes a model of her own which diagrams a hypothetical communication system between artists, middlemen and consumers of popular arts.
Barber agrees that much more needs to be understood about relations between producers and consumers of popular arts, but she rejects the communication model proposed by Jules-Rosette which implies that popular arts are exclusively commercial -- which they are not because it ignores the emergent quality of popular arts and denies their fluidity and diversity.
1987 Arnoldi, Mary Jo. Rethinking definitions of African traditional and popular arts, African studies review Atlanta 30 3: 79-83, September 1987.
One of four commentaries on Karin Barber`s paper on popular arts in Africa see Barber below. While agreeing that popular arts in Africa reflect change in the urban setting, Arnoldi cautions that the historical dimension of artistic production and the rural-based popular arts should not be missed. Using her own research among the Bamana, she finds unofficial arts exemplified in puppet theater. Syncretism domesticating the foreign is also characteristic of older traditional art forms. In her response, Barber acknowledges that there are elements of the popular in traditional art, but maintains that popular arts of the colonial and post-colonial periods are qualitatively different.
1987 Barber, Karin. Popular arts in Africa, [and] Response, African studies review Atlanta 30 3: 1-78 [and] 105-111, September 1987. notes, bibliog. pp. 113-132.
A major overview paper commissioned by the Joint Committee on African Studies of the ACLS/SSRC in which Karin Barber grapples with defining what are popular arts in Africa. She explores the sociological popular and the aesthetic arts aspects of popular arts -- here including not only visual arts but also music, dance, theater and literature. She considers the often used triadic classification Traditional/Popular/Elite, but finds it unsatisfactory to conclude that popular arts are what is left in the middle after traditional and elite, which are easier to define, are set aside. Barber sees the unofficial character of popular arts as the source of its extraordinary vitality. They are novel, syncretic and urban-oriented. She analyzes the limitations and the virtues of this triadic classification, emphasizing the extreme fluidity and relativity of the boundaries between them.
Who produces and who consumes popular art? These form the economic and political matrix of Barber`s analysis of popular arts and what they tell us about a society, how they communicate to their audience, and how to discern the sub-texts in their message. She draws in her analysis from the work of Fabian and Szombati-Fabian on Shaba paintings and Jules-Rosette on Zambian popular paintings.
In her response Barber sets out again what for her is the crucial question: What do popular arts communicate? The content of the message is more important than the process of communicating. What are people thinking about, aspiring to, fearful of? -- these are the insights that popular arts can provide.
See critiques by Arnoldi, Cosentino, Cooper and Jules-Rosette.
1987Brett, Guy. No condition is permanent, chapter 3, pp. 82-111. In the author`s Through our own eyes: popular art and modern history. Philadelphia: New Society Publishers, 1987. illus. pt. color, bibl. refs. N8210.B84 1987 AFA. OCLC 15065445.
Draws on the work of Szombati-Fabian and Fabian on Shaba painters to describe Congolese collective memory genres and Mamba Muntu mermaid images. Turning to Ghana, Nigeria, and Côte d`Ivoire, Brett looks at popular art of mammy wagons, sign paintings, mbari houses and children`s toys. This is a very useful synthesis of some of the popular arts in contemporary Africa.
1987 Cooper, Frederick. Who is the populist? African studies review Atlanta 30 3: 99-103, September 1987.
One of four commentaries on Karin Barber`s paper on popular arts in Africa see Barber above. Cooper seeks to probe more deeply than Barber did the relationships between popular art forms and the shifting urban audiences consumers and ultimately what those dynamics can tell us about a particular setting in modern Africa, not about the masses or the populace as an abstract category. Barber, in her response, is in full accord with Cooper`s plea for greater historical specificity in examining popular arts, rather than merely looking at them against a generalized backdrop of colonialism or post-colonialism.
1987 Cosentino, Donald. Omnes Cultura Tres Partes Divisa Est? African studies review Atlanta 30 3: 85-90, September 1987.
One of four commentaries on Karin Barber`s paper on popular arts in Africa see Barber above. The triadic classification Traditional/Popular/Elite, which Barber invokes, wrestles with, but never fully rejects, Cosentino rejects outright. Instead, he sees a unitary seamless web quality to contemporary African culture. The role of the marketplace both international and local as motive and inspiration for artistic creation and the process of re-contextualization are crucial to our understanding of contemporary African arts.
Though it is initially tempting to buy this argument, Barber, in her response, takes issue with Cosentino`s using commercialization as an all-purpose explanation for the production of popular arts in Africa today. This art for profit approach tells us nothing of the historical specificity of the production and dissemination of art or of the popular consciousness which it addresses.
1988Kunstreise nach Afrika: Tradition und Moderne . Bayreuth: Iwalewa-Haus, Universität, 1988. 128pp. illus. 48 figs. on 32 plates pt. color, bibliogs. N7380.K965 1988 AFA. OCLC 18689509.
In his forward to this collection of essays, Ronald Ruprecht dispels the idea that art in Africa is in decline. Indeed, he makes the case that the vitality and ingenuity of artists today is remarkable and worthy of serious attention and of celebration, which this volume sets out to accomplish. There are eight separate individual contributions: Friedrich Axt on Senegalese art, Ulli Beier and Georgina Beier on Alaraba cloth, Helke Kammerer-Grothaus on painters from Congo Democratic Republic and Congo Gunther Péus on Shona sculpture, Ronald Ruprecht on art in Nigeria since 1950, Winfried Schmidt on the Nsukka school of modern art in Nigeria, and Josef Thiel on the representation of man in African art.
1988 Oloidi, Ola. Who is the new African artist? Aspects of African spirit / special issue of: Chrysalis New York: Swedenborg Foundation 3 l: 4-13, 1988. illus., bibl. refs. DT14.A83 1988 AFA. OCLC 18129862.
The new generation of modern African artists by which Oloidi means those who came of age post-independence seeks to differentiate itself from the earlier generation, who were products of colonial art institutions or foreign education -- artists such as Ibrahim el Salahi, Bruce Onobrakpeya, Vincent Kofi or Herbert Owiti. The hallmarks of this modern African artist are his creative independence, his re-interpretation of traditional heritage, whether expressed abstractly or naturalistically, and his moral and humanitarian standards. Oloidi illustrates works of five Nigerian artists: Boniface Okafor, Dele Jegede, Clary Nelson-Cole, Tayo Adenaike, Obiora Udechukwu, and Ghanaian El Anatsui.
1988-89 Faber, Paul. Kunst uit een andere wereld Art from another world, pp. 9-30. [introduction to] Kunst uit een andere wereld Art from another world [exhibiton, Museum of Ethnology, Rotterdam, November 4, 1988-February 13, 1989]. Rotterdam: Snoeck-Ducaju & Zoon, 1988. illus. pt. color, bibliog. pp. 133-134. N72.S6K96 1988 AFA. OCLC 20254165.
The complacent division of the world between Western and non-Western art, between objects found in art museums and in ethnographic museums set in the nineteenth century, no longer holds. It collapses under a more fully understood anthropology of art -- a concept of art developed by anthropologists who began to study aesthetics, style, creativity, innovation within so-called traditional societies. One can no longer continue to historicize art beyond Europe, while retaining modernity and the avant-garde as preserves of contemporary European art.
Faber discusses manifestations of what he calls tradition on the move, such as the use of new materials and techniques for old art forms, or the impact of commercialization. The place of an art tradition or practice in a larger society may very well determine its survival: traditions belonging to the dominating culture are more likely to survive than those of political or cultural minorities.
Popular urban arts, such as painted lorries or commercial street art, may not even be thought of as art, but as individual expression, now more frequently signed. Faber coins the term art to be looked at what art isn`t? by which he means an art for art`s sake. Tourist art the ultimate cliche is one obvious manifestation of this new productivity stimulated by a new market, but the creativity of artists propelled by some kind of European intervention e.g., the Oshogbo artists is also an art to be looked at.
The intellectual approach to art, which may be said to have begun in the late nineteenth century in Europe, is not confined to European art but in Africa it has been slow to take hold, and Faber gives cogent reasons why this is so. One is the artistic conservativism of the academic art schools in Africa and its perpetuation through the second generation of African teaching staff.
Faber concludes that art in these societies is not a clear-cut concept and that these four different art circuits exist simultaneously and side-by-side: tradition on the move, a new commercial popular art, art to be looked at, and academic art.
1989Agthe, Johanna. Die Sammlung zeitgenössischer afrikanischer Kunst in Frankfurter Museum für Völkerkunde, pp. 28-34. In: Afrikaforschung in Frankfurt: Begleitheft zur Ausstellung analässlich des 75 Jährigen Bestehens den Frankfurter Unviersität: 8 November bis 16, Dezember 1989. Frankfurt am Main: Die Bibliothek: Das Institut, [1989]. illus. DT19.95.U543A38 1989X AFA.
OCLC 21411904.
The Museum für Völkerkunde in Frankfurt is committed to collecting and documenting art from outside Europe. The rationale for this policy is that contemporary art is part of recent culture and is therefore a legitimate form of cultural expression for a museum of ethnography to collect. The curator Johanna Agthe is careful to point out that theirs is not an art museum and that they collect broadly the work of academic artists and self-taught artists, tourist art, posters, advertisements, cartoons and book illustrations. The acquisitions are made in Africa, preferably from the artist directly, so that documenting the artwork goes hand in hand with gathering information about the artist and the circumstances of production.
At present the collection of contemporary Africa art in Frankfurt comes from six areas: Nigeria, East Africa, Senegal, South Africa, Congo Democratic Republic and Zimbabwe.
1989 Bender, Wolfgang. Modern art to the ethnographic museum! pp. 182-196. In: Die verborgene Wirklichkeit: drei athiopische Maler der Gegenwart The hidden reality: three contemporary Ethiopian artists: Zerihun Yetmgeta, Girmay Hiwet, Worku Goshu / by Elisabeth Biasio. Zürich: Völkerkundemuseum der Universität, 1989. illus., notes pp. 203-206. N7386.B57 1989 AFA. OCLC 20878295.
Art museums and galleries in Europe reject modern African art as being derivative and imitative, yet not modern enough, while ethnographic museums are at best ambivalent about accepting it into their collections. Those few that have done so, tentatively and hesitantly, seem to be sifting out that which is deemed too modern. They are looking for modern art which seems to relate to traditional art from the area in question. Artists themselves are tired of being relegated, if dealt with at all, to the categories of ethnic arts and shown only in ethnographic museums.
Bender argues that ethnographic museums ultimately do a disservice to their own mission if they continue to ignore contemporary expressive arts of the cultures they purport to represent. Curatorial timidity and inexperience with modern art can and should be overcome. Unlike art museums and galleries, which are compelled to show only trendy art, ethnographic museums can freely and comfortably collect and display a wide range of contemporary art -- academic, popular, tourist. Moreover, ethnographic museums have a responsibility to more fully document this art, just as they would for any object in their collections, with contextual and historical information.
1990 Jules-Rosette, Bennetta. The aesthetics of communication and the reproduction of cultural forms: the case of tourist art, [with particular reference to artists in Lusaka, Nairobi and Kinshasa]. pp. 41-61. In: Aesthetic illusion: theoretical and historical approaches / edited by F. Burweick and W. Pape. Berlin: De Gruyter, 1990. diagrams, bibl. refs. VF -- Artists - General. OCLC 22274024.
Jules-Rosette challenges the conventional view of aesthetics based on evaluation and judgmental responses to artworks. She proposes instead a communicative model of aesthetics with reference to tourist art, which explains the complex relationship between the production and reception of tourist art page 42. The tourist art system posited by Jules-Rosette is an interactive one between art producers, art objects and audiences through which aesthetic standards are negotiated. Marketing strategies are further negotiated by middlemen as seen, for example, with the Kanyama painters of Lusaka.
Image-creators are those who innovate and are imitated by image-producers. Three such image-creators are profiled: Jonathan Kimetu Kioko, master Kamba carver at the Mombasa cooperative Safari Mbai, a Nairobi-based master carver and Diouf Kabamba, an academically trained Congolese painter who works in Lusaka.
1991McEvilley, Thomas. The selfhood of the other: reflections of a Westerner on the occasion of an exhibition of contemporary art from Africa, pp. 266-275. In: Africa explores: 20th century African art. New York: Center for African Art Munich: Prestel-Verlag, 1991. illus. pt. color, notes. qN7391.65.V63 1991X AFA. OCLC 22909235.
As twentieth-century Modernism dissolves into Post-modernism, the essential cultural relationships and assumptions on which it is built shift dramatically. Ideas about center-periphery, Western progress, nature-culture, cultural-mixing, and ethnic purity are all challenged by the deconstructionist attitudes of Post-modernism. The dialogue of objects between cultures, whereby ideas and material goods are exchanged and revalued, is just beginning to reach the realm of contemporary African art. Ways of seeing and of representing the Post-modernist world are relativist and non-absolute the center is unanchored and set adrift. The search for the Other becomes a search for self.
1991 LaDuke, Betty. Africa through the eyes of women artists. Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press, 1991. 148pp. illus., bibl. refs. N7380.L15 1991 AFA. OCLC 24281599.
American artist Betty LaDuke sought sisterhood in Africa through women artists: her unique introduction to a complex continent. She sees in their work perhaps, was looking for a common thread: the representation of positive feminine role models. From this personal odyssey emerged the profiles of nine African artists and three from the Diaspora: Elizabeth Olowo Nigeria, Nike Davies Nigeria, Susanne Wenger Nigeria, Pama Sinatoa Mali, Anta Germaine Gaye Senegal, Theresa Musoke Uganda, Chaibia Morocco, Inji Efflatoun Egypt, Sue Williamson South Africa, Lois Mailou Jones USA, Edna Manley Jamaica and June Beer Nicaragua. One chapter is devoted to each, and an introductory chapter pays tribute to traditional women artists, especially the potters.
Reviewed by Lisa Aronson in African arts Los Angeles 26 1: 99-100, January 1993 by Teresa Unseld in Journal of multicultural and cross-cultural research in art education Madison, WI 12: 98-101, fall 1994 by Bennete Armah Hanson, Projecting women`s image, West Africa London no. 3899: 992, June 8-14, 1992 by D. J. Johnson in Choice Middletown, CT 30 3: 455-456, November 1992.
1992 Guez, Nicole. L`art africain contemporain Contemporary African art. Edition 1992/94. Paris: Association Dialogue entre les Cultures, 1992. xvii, 293pp. illus. pt. color. Text in French and English. N7380.5.G93 1992 AFA. OCLC 26984935.
A pocket-size directory of African visual artists living and working in Africa and overseas. Arranged by country. Also included are names and addresses of galleries, museums and key individuals in the field of modern African art.
1992 Duganne, Erina. The presentation of twentieth-century African art in the west. B.A. thesis, Reed College, 1992. [7], 111, [18] leaves. illus., bibliog. [unpublished]. N7428.2.D86 1992 AFA. OCLC 30087275.
This thesis examines Western presentation of twentieth-century African art. Duganne shows how attitudes toward African art have evolved through a chronological investigation of four exhibitions of Third World art: Primitivism in 20th Century Art: Affinity of the Tribal and the Modern, Magiciens de la Terre, Contemporary African Artists: Changing Traditions, and Africa Explores: 20th Century African Art. Duganne examines the methods of presentation employed by Western museums and how these procedures interpret the displayed objects. Three twentieth-century African art forms -- international , popular, and tourist -- are examined in more depth. This exploration leads to some general reflections on the nature of museum settings and how future exhibitions might go about finding alternative approaches for the display of African art. Included in this final section are the author`s own proposals for exhibitions as well as her concerns for incorporating African collaboration in the development of future exhibitions of African art in the West. -- adapted from original abstract.
1992 De receptie van Afrikaanse kunst . Amsterdam: Stichting Kunstlicht, 1992. 64pp. illus. Kunstlicht jaarg. 13, nr. 3-4. N7380.R28 1992 AFA. OCLC 32254626.
This special issue devoted to the reception of African art in Europe and in the Netherlands, in particular includes articles on Africa explores, and on Kenyan and South African artists.
1992 Kennedy, Jean. New currents, ancient rivers: contemporary African artists in generation of change. Washington: Smithsonian Institutiton Press, 1992. 204pp. illus. pt. color, bibliog. N7391.65.K46 1991X AFA. OCLC 22389510.
Jean Kennedy`s book is the summation of thirty years of personal and professional involvement with artists of Africa, which is both a survey and a celebration of some of Africa`s finest. Her odyssey begins in Nigeria, which she knew best, and continues in West Africa with a separate chapter on Senegalese artists. Other chapters cover Sudan, Ethiopia, Zimbabwe and South Africa, plus artists from other countries as well. Although sub-Saharan Africa is too vast to be encompassed in one volume, Kennedy has selected around 150 artists to demonstrate what she felt represented the vitality and originality of contemporary creativity from the continent. There are many illustrations, but few in color.
Indexed separately are chapters on modern art in Nigeria, Senegal, Sudan, Ethiopia, East and Central Africa, Zimbabwe, and South Africa.
Reviewed by Dele Jegede in African arts Los Angeles 29 1: 21, 96, winter 1996 by Elsbeth Court in Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies London 56 2: 428-429, 1993 by Monni Adams in International journal of African historical studies Boston 26 1: 444-446, 1993 by Aaron Segal, Africa`s creative energy, Africa today Denver 41 2: 106, 2nd quarter 1994 by Dennis Duerden, Contemporary African art West Africa London no. 4020: 1809, October 17-23, 1994 by Christopher D. Roy in Choice Middletown, CT 30 4: 610, December 1992.
1993 Gaudibert, Pierre. L`art africain contemporain. Paris: Éditions Cercle d`Art, 1991. 175pp. illus. pt. color, bibliog. N7380.G26 1991 AFA. OCLC 26593361.
Contemporary African art has found an enthusiastic publicist in Pierre Gaudibert, who documents its emergence from tentative beginnings in the mid-decades of this century to its assured multi-faceted expressions evident by the beginning of the 1990s. His geographic focus is sub-Saharan Africa his approach is one of sweeping survey and inventory of names: the big picture, no in-depth analysis of particular art movements, schools or trends. Within this broad brush stoke, he includes academic artists, workshop artists, self-taught artists, elite arts and popular arts. Gaudibert takes into account the international dimension, that is, African artists living and working outside of Africa. Beware the inordinate number of spelling errors in names of artists the editing, if there was any, is extremely sloppy. No index.
Reviewed by Giovanni Joppolo, Art africain contemporain, Opus international Paris 131: 60, spring-summer 1993.
1993 Fosu, Kojo. 20th century art of Africa. Revised edition. Accra: Artists Alliance, 1993. 245pp. illus., portraits, bibliog.
The revised edition contains very little new material apart from the inclusion of five additional Ghanaian artists and slightly expanded entries on three other Ghanaians. Basically, the text is silent on developments over the last decade in the field of modern African art, nor does it update information on artists represented. It remains focused on the 1960s and 1970s. Unfortunately, the weaknesses of the original Zaria edition are unaddressed. The illustrations are of even poorer quality, and none are dated.
1993 Cultural diversity in the arts: art, art policies and the facelift of Europe / edited by Ria Lavrijsen. Amsterdam: Royal Tropical Institute, 1993. 119pp. bibliog. NX180.S6C96 1993 AFA. OCLC 29789693.
The European art establishment is beginning to face the tough questions of how to open up and respond to newness of art in their increasingly diverse, pluralistic societies. In a complex multicultural environment, how does one define quality in the arts? How do art institutions move away from parochial vision to a more global view of art? Is there any intermediate space between the rigidity of binary opposites -- Western/non-Western, Black/White, South/North, power/powerless -- and a neutral, apolitical approach which discounts the social and historical context of art? These issues were aired at a 1993 conference on Cultural Diversity in the Arts held in Amsterdam. The essays, reports and recommendations in this volume arise from that gathering.
1993Binet, Jacques. Thèmes and sujets de la painture africaine, pp. 125-130. In: Creer en Afrique / 2e colloque européen sur les arts d`Afrique noire, Paris, les 23-24 octobre 1993 au Musée national des arts d`Afrique and d`Océanie. Arnouville: Arts d`Afrique noire, 1993. N7380.C714 1993 AFA. OCLC 30387506.
What are African painters painting? Landscapes do not inspire the intellectual artists, but naïf painters like rustic scenes. Portraits are popular among the so-called popular painters, but intellectuals are not interested. Historical genres also appeal to the popular painters. Engaged painting on metaphysical or political themes does appeal to some intellectuals. The nude is not a subject for the intellectuals, though the watistes flock to Mami Wata as a perennially favorite subject.
Pure abstraction, as a style, is rare among African painters. Figurative baroque might be a more accurate designation. Ornamental motifs are sometimes used in symbolic ways, rather than as the purely decorative. In fact, there seems to be a great affinity between artists and traditional motifs, reworked and re-interpreted. One thinks of uli, Hausa embroidery, Dogon graphic signs, Akan symbols, or bogolanfini.
In sum, African painters are drawn to metaphysical or political themes and reject hedonistic ones. Painters avoid exposing individuality and are preoccupied with the urgency of transmitting a message, often wrapped in nationalistic or ethnic colors.
1993 McEvilley, Thomas. Fusion: hot or cold? pp. 9-23. In: Fusion: West African artists at the Venice Biennale. New York: Museum for African Art Munich: Prestel, 1993. bibl. refs. N7398.M14 1993 AFA. OCLC 29513040.
The identity crisis that beset African artists in the colonial-Modernist period -- manifest initially in assimilation and later in cultural resistance -- now seems a struggle of the past. At least for younger generations of African artists, whose cultural heritage is a hybridization. This thirty-something or twenty-something generation is in the postcolonial phase, that is, one in which artists self-consciously accept hybridization and make their work reflect various forces that have formed them as individuals pp. 12-13.
There is a kind of balance in these artists in the impulses between sameness and difference, which represents a postcolonial reversal. The 1993 Venice Biennale itself represents a kind of cultural nomadism, or global intermingling. Although the African artists in Venice may not regard themselves as post-Modernist, their presence in Venice is a distinctly post-Modern event. Autonomy and individuality are paramount values to the African artist, whatever his perceived or actual relationship with his culture may be.
McEvilley interviews four of the five West African artists in the 1993 Venice Biennale the fifth, Senegalese Mor Faye, is deceased. The four are sculptor Moustapha Dimé Senegal, painter Tamessir Dia Senegal-Mali, painter Ouattara Côte d`Ivoire, and painter Gerard Santoni Côte d`Ivoire.
1993Hassan, Salah M. Creative impulses/modern expressions: African art today, pp. 1-14. In: Creative impulses/modern expressions: four African artists: Skunder Boghossin, Rashid Diab, Mohammed Omer Khalil, Amir Nour. Ithaca: African Studies and Research Center, Institute for African Development, Council for the Creative and Performing Arts, Cornell University, 1993. notes, bibliog. N7380.C912 1992 AFA. OCLC 28319148.
African art scholarship urgently needs a new framework and fresh paradigms for assessing and analyzing contemporary African art. It is not being well-served by existing ones. Of the several attempts at definition so far advanced, one element always present is the artists` search for a new identity. Why is this so important? It is true that a central intellectual concern for academic artists, coming from whatever part of the continent, is the quest for African-ness in their work.
Hassan calls into question the facile dichotomy traditional and contemporary -- and a parallel concept: authenticity -- as no longer useful or valid. We need to see the artist as a whole, complete individual, a product of all his experiences and personal history, and as a player within the creative process, which also includes his audiences and patrons and the social milieu within which he works. Art is essentially a communicative process and must be analyzed as such. Hassan suggests a dialogic relationship between artist and audience. The pernicious tendency to continually categorize the product, the artwork elite, traditional, popular, tourist must be resisted.
1993 Art, anthropology and the modes of re-presentation: museums and contemporary non-Western art / edited by Harrie Leyten and B. Damen. Amsterdam: KIT Press, Koninklijk Instituut voor de Tropen, 1993. 80pp. N430.A78 1993 AFA. OCLC 29465456.
Exhibitions of non-Western art are no longer a rarity in Europe and the USA. The Tropenmuseum in Amsterdam is one of the Dutch anthropological museums that has followed an active policy of exhibiting non-Western modern art. This book focuses on questions of how to display non-Western art, as well as the different approaches of anthropological museums and museums of modern art to these complex and fascinating issues. Among the contributors are David Elliott Museum of Modern Art, Oxford, Paul Faber Museum of Ethnology, Rotterdam, Harrie Leyten Tropenmuseum, Amsterdam. -- from the publisher`s catalog.
1993Picton, John. In vogue, or the flavour of the month: the new way to wear black, Third text: Third World perspectives on contemporary art & culture London 23: 89-98, summer 1993. illus., bibl. refs. NX1.T445 AFA.
The propensity to categorize African artists and their art production perversely and willfully fails to reckon with the artists themselves and their personal histories and environments. This was true with Susan Vogel`s Africa Explores exhibition and catalog it was true with Nelson Graeburn`s paradigms of Fourth World art it is true in the fatuous presumptuousness of collector Jean-Christophe Pigozzi`s search for untrained African artists. Contemporary African art is still being looked at in broad, sweeping, generalizing terms and placed into similarly restrictive boxes. Particular art histories are ignored or, in most cases, are lacking. Yet it is to these more specific levels -- nation, regional, local, individual -- that the multiple histories of modern African art must begin.
1994 Global visions: towards a new internationalism in the visual arts / edited by Jean Fisher. London: Kala Press in association with The Institute of International Visual Arts, 1994. 175pp. illus., bibliogs.
This anthology gathers papers presented at a symposium on the New Internationalism in the Visual Arts, held in London in April 1994. Contributions by: Rasheed Aareen, Hal Foster, Guillermo Santamarina, Sarat Maharj, Geets Kapur, Olu Oguibe, Judith Wilson, Hou Hanru, Everlyn Nicodemus, Gilane Tawadros, Jimmie Durham, Gordon Bennett, Gerardo Mosquera, Raiji Kuroda, Fred Wilson, and Elisabeth Sussman.
1994 Enwezor, Okwui. Redrawing the boundaries: towards a new African art discourse, NKA: journal of contemporary African art Brooklyn, NY no. 1: 3-7, fall-winter 1994. bibl. refs. NX1.N737 AFA.
Post-modernist critiques, which appear to profess solidarity with outsider artists and with cultural practice of the decolonized world, is but another form of appropriation. It may be less transparently patronizing than the Primitivism in Modern Art phenomenon, which begrudgingly allows the spotlight to fall briefly on tribal art. But it is just as effective in maintaining a very unequal relationship. Within official boundaries of Eurocentric circles, the silence -- and silencing -- of African artists continues. How, then, are African artists to open their own discourse, to renarrate the multifaceted, variagated histories of modern African art? Where do we situate the cultural nomads? When do we begin to recognize the diversity and resilience of artistic expression on the continent, a continent clearly beset with its own eruptions -- political, social, cultural? The journal Nka seeks to be one such forum where one can unite and engage the different spectrums of African viewpoints on 20th century cultural practices.
1994Lucie-Smith, Edward. Modern Africa and Asia, chapter 10, pp. 186-204. In the author`s Race, sex, and gender: in contemporary art. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1994. illus. color. N7429.4.L83 1994X AFA. OCLC 28889101.
Modern African art does not know quite where to situate itself in the post-Classical period. It is political only in the sense of being acutely aware of the tremendous political and social upheavals of twentieth century Africa. To wit: John Muafangejo. The tourist trade has also had and continues to exert a pervasive influence in modern African art. Commerce not spirituality are at its roots -- whether with the narrative and sign painters, such as Chéri Samba, the Mammy Watists, Makonde surrealists, or originals, such as Kane Kwei, coffin-maker. The African artists who fit most comfortably within a western frame of reference are those living and working outside Africa, e.g., Uzo Egonu or Ibrahim El Salahi.
1995Catalogue de la collection d`oeuvres d`artistes contemporains d`Afrique et d`Océanie acquises ou conservées par l`ADEIAO / introduction by Lucette Albaret and Paul Balta. Paris: ADEIAO, 1995. [164]pp. chiefly illus. color. Cover title: Art contemporain d`Afrique et d`Océanie N7380.5.A229 AFA. OCLC 32346384.
The collection of ADEIAO [Association pour le Dévelopment des Echanges Interculturels au Musée National des Arts d`Afrique et d`Océanie] was begun in 1984 by a few spirited individuals who felt that the museum needed a more contemporary focus in its exhibitions and collections. From a series of temporary exhibitions organized from 1985, the museum acquired selected works by purchase or donation from the artist. The present illustrated catalog reproduces 116 paintings, prints, and a few sculptures, representing artists from mainly franco-phone African countries.
1996 Guez, Nicole. L`art africain contemporain Contemporary African art. Edition 1996. Paris: Association Afrique en Création, 1996. xiii, 421pp. illus. pt. color. Text in French and English. N7380.5.G93 1992 AFA. OCLC 26984935.
Considerably expanded, this directory of African visual artists living and working in Africa and overseas gives addresses, telephone, fax numbers and indicates the artists` media e.g., painter, wood sculptor. Arranged by country. Also included are names and addresses of galleries, museums and key individuals in the field of modern African art. This second edition adds a very useful name index.
1996/97 Contemporary art of Africa / edited by André Magnin with Jacques Soulillou. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1996. 192pp. illus. pt. color, bibliog. pp. 185-186. qN7391.65.C66 1996X AFA. OCLC 31607382.
The peripatetic curators of this gallery of sixty African artists, André Magnin and Jacques Soulillou, criss-crossed the continent to seek out those creative individuals who seemed to demonstrate a faithfulness to a strength or a capacity to give substance to an insight italics theirs. Let us be quite clear on this point: the choices are Magnin`s and Soulillou`s and Jean Pogozzi`s. No more, no less. Their taste runs strongly toward the unschooled, self-taught, and visionary artists, untainted by Western influences. Never mind whether such unadulteration is possible in the later twentieth century.
In their introduction, the author-curators elaborate their views on contemporary art practice in sub-Saharan Africa, which reinforce their disdain for formal art-schooled artists. They develop a new triadic taxonomy labeled Territory, Frontier and World, which requires complicated elucidation. In effect, it carries the goals and spirits of the 1989 Magiciens de la Terre exhibition to another level. What is not stated, but is evident from the credits is that the majority of the art works are in the collection of Jean Pigozzi, who is clearly the Wizard of Oz behind this book enterprise.
For each of the sixty artists presented, there is a mini-essay, illustrations of one to several works, and a portrait of the artists. An appendix lists additional artists whose work the authors value but which did not quite make the cut for inclusion. For those artists represented this is undeniably an attractive showcase, the first time the big art publisher, Harry N. Abrams has ventured into the world of modern art.
Reviewed by Dele Jegede on H-AfrArts, August 20, 1997` by Bill Wright in Nka: journal of contemporary African art Brooklyn, NY no. 5: 70, fall 1996.
Reviewed by Elsbeth Court in Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies London 3, 1997, pp. 607-608.
1987 LaDuke, Betty. Africa: women`s art, women`s lives. Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press, 1997. xix, 187pp. illus.
Based on LaDuke`s odysseys to Africa over the last several years to meet women artists, this volume covers: wall painters in Burkina Faso, textile artists in Mali, women potters in Cameroon, Mali and Togo, bead sculptors in Cameroon, Zimbabwean stone sculptors, women of the Weya cooperative in Zimbabwe, and Eritrean painters.
1998Art criticism and Africa / edited by Katy Deepwell. London: Saffron Books Eastern Art Publishing, 1998. 128pp. illus. 40 b and w.illus. & 16 color. N7485.A35A78 1998 AFA. OCLC 39533826.
This book arises from the AICA conference on Art Criticism & Africa, held at the Courtauld Institute in November 1996. It was sponsored by Arts Council of England, AICA, Islamic Arts and Eastern Art Report.
Contents: Katy Deepwell, Introduction -- Olabisi Silva, Africa 95: cultural colonialism or cultural celebration -- John Picton, Yesterday`s cold mashed potatoes -- Everlyn Nicodemus, The art critic as advocate -- Ola Oloidi, Art criticism in Nigeria 1920-1996: the development of professionalism in the media and the academy -- Murray McCartney, The art critic as advocate: a Zimbabwean perspective -- Barbara Murray, Art criticism for whom?: the experience of Gallery magazine in Zimbabwe -- Tony Mhonda, The art critic as advocate -- David Koloane, Art criticism for whom? -- Colin Richards, Peripheral vision: speculations on art criticism in South Africa -- Chike Okeke, Beyond either/or: towards an art criticism of accommodation -- Fatma Ismail Afifi, The Kom Gohrab project in Cairo -- Olu Oguibe, Thoughts towards a new century -- George Shire, Art criticism of Africa outside of Africa: a reply to Olu Oguibe -- A selected bibliography Tributes to Stephen Williams and Jock Whittet.
1999 Kasfir, Sidney Littlefield. Contemporary African art. London: Thames and Hudson, 1999. 224pp. illus. pt. color, bibliog. pp. 214-217. World of Art. OCLC 42039553.
Kasfir chose a thematic approach to tell the history of art in African from the 1950s to the 1990s. She describes the major transformation that occurred within African artistic practice as a result of the colonial incursions page 9. This postcolonial perspective recognizes that modern art practice in Africa is built upon differing traditional practices, socio-political circumstances and interventions. The major themes are popular culture and new emerging urban art, art workshops, patronage and culture brokers, art as commodity, artists` identity, art schools and national cultural identity, artists in exile and on the international circuit. North Africa is completely excluded from the discussion, but most of the well known and some lesser known art movements, art schools and workshops, and artist luminaries from sub-Saharan Africa are woven into Kasfir`s narrative. Packaged in Thames & Hudson`s World of Art series, Contemporary African art is intended primarily as classroom text.
2000 Busca, Joëlle. L`art contemporain africain: du colonialisme au postcolonialisme. Paris: Harmattan, 2000. 237pp. bibliog. pp. 223-233. N7380.B87 2000X AFA. OCLC 47978936.
The emergence of contemporary African art onto the world art scene in the last quarter of the twentieth century is a clear and direct manifestation of globalization. African artists gained higher visibility and greater acceptance in mainstream cultural venues, according to Busca, a French art critic and independent curator. A quick review of the major exhibitions beginning with Magiciens de la Terre in 1989 reveals the proliferation of biennales and other well publicized events which featured African artists. The art establishment in France also re-organized its museum venues for African art during this period. The art market, too, woke up to the new interest of high rolling collectors in contemporary African art, such as Saatchi and Pigozzi. In retrospect, African art has come a long way from its primitivism aura of the first decade of the twentieth century to the global reach of today`s practicing artists from Africa and the diaspora.
2000 Busca, Joëlle. Perspectives sur l`art contemporain africain. Paris: L`Harmattan, 2000. 145pp. illus. color, bibliog. pp. 141-145. N7380.B873 2000 AFA. OCLC 46683096.
The companion volume to Busca`s study see preceding entry showcases fifteen of these high visibility artists. They are: Kwesi Owusu-Ankomah Ghana Esther Mahlangu South Africa Théodore et Calixte Dakpogan Bénin Willie Bester South Africa Toma Muteba Lutumbue Democratic Republic of Congo Frédéric Bruly Bouabré Côte d`Ivoire Chéri Samba Democratic Republic of Congo Pascale Marthine Tayou Cameroon Georges Adéagbo Bénin Ouattara Côte d`Ivoire Abdoulaye Konaté Mali Romuald Hazoumé Bénin Sokari Douglas Cmap Nigeria Bili Bidjocka Cameroon and William Kentridge South Africa.
2002 An anthology of African art: the twentieth century / edited by N`Goné Fall and Jean Loup Pivin. New York: D.A.P./Distributed Art Publishers Paris: Revue Noire Editions, African Contemporary Art, 2002. 407pp. illus. color, bibliog. pp. 402-404. qN7391.65.A5713 2002X AFA. OCLC 49942843.
Revue noire, which has been showcasing contemporary African art since 1991, now summarizes the state-of-the-art at the end of the twentieth century. This weighty tome is not really an anthology, despite the title, for it is not mere a collection of previously published Revue noire articles. Many of the artists are familiar from the pages of Revue noire, but many different artists and new perspectives are also presented. Fifty short essays covering the entire continent except North Africa are offered in a roughly chronological sequence from Territory of forms the classical canon to Migrations and Convergences the postmodern hybridity. Lavishly illustrated. A companion volume to Revue noire`s Anthology of African and Indian Ocean photography 1999.
2003Reading the Contemporary: by Okwui Enwezor and Olu Oguibe In the past decade contemporary African art has been featured in major exhibtions in museums, galleries, international biennials, and other forums. African cinema has established itself on the stage of world cinema, culminating in the Ouagadougou Film Festival. While African art and visual culture have become an integral part of the art history and cultural studies curricula in universities worldwide, critical readings and interpretations have remained difficult to obtain. This pioneering anthology collects twenty key essays in which major critical thinkers, scholars, and artists explore contemporary African visual culture, locating it within current cultural debates and within the context of the continent`s history. The sections of the book are Theory and Cultural Transaction, History, Location and Practice, and Negotiated Identities. Copublished with the Institute of International Visual Arts inIVA, London
Art, Artists and Art Criticism
Image: Emmanuel Jegede | The SacrificeArt, Artists and Art Criticism
Situational Report in Nigeria from 1950 – 2004
Introduction
This article is focused on some issues concerning contemporary art and its practitioners and art critics as it relates to Nigeria from 1950 to date. In any way the article may not be able to discuss in minute detail due to space constraint. At the same time the theoretical framework of the paper will be historical and also analytical in order to be able to state the author’s views on some issues raised here.
The history of contemporary art in Nigeria cannot be complete without referring to the instrumental figures who through their solo efforts brought Nigerian modern art into the world art history. The history started with Aina Onabolu 1881-1963 as a leading figure who did not only start the art of drawing and painting but also fought single handedly to put art in the school curriculum in 1927. Onabolu consciously went into art of figure drawing and painting to prove and disabuse the minds of the then Europeans who thought no African can dabble into the art of figure drawing and painting. With the help of some European art teachers such as Kenneth Murray who came in 1927, H.E Duckwork and Dennis Duerden who later joined, they later discovered of other talented indigenous artists who did not only continue from Onabolu, they equally made their distinct landmark in the propagation of visual art. Such notable artists include Akinola Lasekan 1921-1972, Justus Akeredolu1915-, Ben Enwonwu 1921 – 1994, Etsu Ngbodaga and others.
These notable Nigerian academically trained, or partially trained or self trained artists started what was later christened Natural Synthesis by the “Zarianist”. For example, Enwonwu’s paintings and sculptures reflect naturalistic and stylized forms which he called “African Style”. As it is argued, Enwonwu’s spirit of synthesis later became the compass upon which the Zarianists members of Zaria Art Society based their popular theory of “Natural Synthesis”. Ademuleya,2003.
The events starting from 1950 have been very topical and have also dictated the trends in contemporary Art in Nigeria. Also events since then have been properly classified by some scholars who wrote on contemporary Nigerian art. These scholars include Dele Jegede 1983, Adepegba 1995, Akatakpo, 1995 Kunle Filani 1998.
Late 1950s and early 1960s witnessed in Nigeria art history the beginning of radical revolution in visual art. The periods consciously witnessed the change of art style from ancient traditions and also jettisoning of western – style realistic approach to execution of artwork. The new consciousness ushered in what was referred to by Filani as “New African” concept which simply means an admixture of traditions and modernism, the philosophy which was later developed as “Natural Synthesis”. This philosophy in the first formal Art School in Nigeria. That is, the college of Art, Science and Technology, Zaria which was later renamed Ahmadu Bello University ABU Zaria. The key actors of this great African philosophy in visual art, who started as students and later spread into various art schools after their graduation are Yusuf Grillo, Uche Okeke, Bruce Onobrakpeya, Demas Nwoko, Emmanuel Odita, Jimoh Akolo, Solomon Wangboje and a host of others. They formed what was known as Zaria Art Society. .
The artists mentioned above influencee other followers and students who have some common and unique characteristics which reflect in their individual works. For decades they dictated the trends in Nigerian contemporary art. Their ideologies according to Filani were carried to other formal schools or workshops to create vibrant artistic revolution Filani 1998:35. Some of these pioneer artists are still in contention in the country.
Another generation of Artists who were later discovered after the 1950s and 1960s progenitors are 1970s graduates of mostly the Zaria Art School. Among them are Shina Yusuf – painter now dead, Joshua Akande – painter, Nelson Cole – painter now dead, Dele Jegede – painter, cartoonist and critic, David Dale – painter and mosacist, Kolade Oshinowo – painter and Gani Odutokun- painter now dead. Their works have been described as characterized by elongation of forms, with elegant northern architecture, and human figures while some depict northern grassland in their landscapes. Most of these artists’ works are in the collection of National Gallery of Modern Art. It is worth mentioning that artist like Late Professor Adepegba 1941 – 2002 who graduated in 1971 with 1st class degree in sculpture consciously went into art history and criticism. He made his mark as one of the distinguished, outstanding and foremost Africanist Art Historians/Critic the Continent has ever produced.
Most contemporary Nigerian artists are classified along the school in which they graduated from. There are also cases of few artists having other distinct styles or deviating from the usual school styles.
Of large number of contemporary artists in the practice today are the 1980s graduates of various formal art schools in Nigeria. The term “school” is also used to describe the philosophy, styles, themes and forms that are peculiarly distinguishing of these schools. The schools that have distinguished themselves with some unique characteristics include Zaria School, Yaba School, Nsukka School, Ife School and Auchi School
The distinguishing characteristics of each school will be briefly mentioned as well as some of their outstanding products or artists. The name of the school represents the location of each art school or may some time bear the name of the founder.
Some Agents of Contemporary art in Nigeria
Zaria Art School
The works of the school are characterized by elongation of forms, with elegant northern architecture and human figures. Their landscapes, most times reflect the grassland and savannah vegetation of the North. Other later graduates of the Zaria School who have made their marks from 1950s till date as artists, teachers and historians include Prof. Yomi Adetoro, Dr. Tunde Akinwumi, Jerry Buhari, Jacob Jari, Tonie Okpe, Rukeme Noserime, Nse-Abasi Inyang, Tunde Balogun, Tunde Oniyide, Tony Emordi, Victoria Ukpera, Chinwe Abara, Abraham Uyobusere, Akeem Balogun, Wunmi Busuyi, Betty Bassey, Duke Asidere, Emmanuel Irokanumo, Ade Odun, Taiwo Oyejide0 and Abiola Idowu among others. Their contributions have been in the sustenance of the art tempo which the pioneers started through their constant practice. While some of the listed artists are household names among the art historians, critic, collectors and the art audience, some talents are just emerging.
Yaba School
The Yaba School employs realistic art form that are done in narrative, and descriptive style mostly done in accurate photo-graphic-realism. The initial notable artists who graduated in the 50s and 60s and went for higher studies in Europe include Agbo Folarin, Isiaka Osunde, and Abayomi Barber. The later artists of the School, who were taught by the former graduates of the Zaria School, belong to the 1980s generation. These include Mike Omoighe, Biodun Olaku, Phemi Adeniran, Lara Ige, Felix Osieme, Edosa Oguigo , Joe Amenechi, Ato Arinze, Sam Ebohan among others.
Nsukka School
The calligraphic nature of ‘Uli’ art body painting/decoration influenced the products’, works. The philosophy of application of Uli art form as espoused by Uche Okeke and later supported by Chuka Amefuna, Chike Aniakor and El-Anasui was to intensify the search for Igbo–identity, thereby using the Uli linear forms to depict radical socio-political and cultural subject matters. Their linearity of drawing and modeling according to Filani, became the hall mark of Nsukka’s contribution to modern Nigerian art. The graduates are conceptually rich and fecund in imagination thereby making their themes to penetrate into the social situations of the people. Filani, 1998:36. Notable of late 1970s and 1980s artists of the school include Tayo Adenaike, Olu Oguibe, Ndidi Dike, Chijioke Onuora, Ernest Okoli etc. Of 1990s graduates are Chika Okeke, Krydz Ikwuemesi, Ozioma Onuzulike among others.
Ife School
The school is noted with intellectualization of its works with vigorous emphasis on theoretical content in art form. Noted with cultural inspiration drawn from the Ife location, the school explores a rather diversity of creative exploration in the use of local materials, symbols and images which later developed into the exploration of Yoruba traditional symbols, motifs, structure and concepts termed Ona by some of the 1980s graduates. The lecturers of the Ife School who are not graduates of the school include Babatunde Lawal, J.R.O Ojo, Abiodun Rowland, Ige Ibigbami, Agbo Folarin and PSO Aremu among others.
The late1970s and 1980s graduate artists of the school who have made their marks in art practice, writing and teaching include Moyo Ogundipe, Nkiru Uwechi-Nzegwu, Moyo Okediji, Don Akatakpo, Sherinat Fafunwa-Ndibe, Kunle Filani, Idowu Otun, CSA Akran, Osi-Audu, Tola Wewe, Eben Sheba among others. The emerging 1990s graduates of the school include Segun Ajiboye, Stephen Folaranmi, Mufu Onifade, Ademola Ogunajo, among others. These artists exhibit often and some also participate in the yearly exhibition of the school graduates tagged “The Best of Ife” which started in 1993.
Auchi School and Its Artists
Auchi Art School is noted with expressionistic naturalism. The use of vibrant and sweet colours are attributed to the graduates of the school. Some of the outstanding artists of the school who have made their impact on the audience and collectors include Ben Osaghae, Sam Ovraiti, Olu Ajayi, Pita Ohiweri, Edwin Debebs, Alex Nwokolo, Toni Oshiame and Olu Amoda metal sculptor among others.
The Informal Schools and Their Artists
These are art locations where artists are informally trained without following rigid rules of formal art syllabus. The training is acquired through apprenticeship system or workshop experience. Within the informal school, some of them do not obey the rules of accurate proportion, and perspective.
Mbari Mbayo–Osogbo and Ori-Olokun-Ife schools explored the workshop system. Notable artists that emerged from the Osogbo School include Twin Seven Seven, Jimoh Buraimoh, Muraina Oyelami, Tijani Mayakiri, Rufus Ogundele, Ademola Onibonokuta, Asiru Olatunde, Nike Davies. Their contributions to art history in Nigeria is their deviation from the known western–style realistic form. These artists’ forms are original, spontaneous and naively created with utter disregard for the depth, space or any expected relationship of motif. Their themes are most times derived from folktales, myths and religious stories. The characteristics of which was classified as “Naive Vision encouraged and fossilized” Adepegba, 1995. They hardly follow the cannon of verisimilitude which is common with Western Art. Ori Olokun workshop is seen as an extension of the Osogbo but the style of execution tilts greatly towards naturalism. Prominent artists of Ori-Olokun experiment include Wale Olajide, Rufus Orisayomi, Fela Odaranile, Adeniji Adeyemi, and Ademola Williams. Other important informal school is “Abayomi Barber School” which started in 1973 by Abayomi Barber . Although the founder was formally trained, the trainees of the school are informally trained. There is no curriculum to operate as in formal art school and no specific entry requirements. Emphasis was always placed on importance of drawing as the basis of it all, also the need to see correctly, measure accurately and observe very keenly, the rules that are borrowed from formal school system. Its prominent artists include Muri Adejimi, Olu Spencer, Busari Agbolade, Toyin Alade, Kent Ideh, Bunmi Lasaki, and Bayo Akinwole among others. Their works are widely collected in Nigeria and abroad and have also been documented by researchers in art history Azeez 2002. Many of them have been in active practice from 1980s till date.
Aka Group
Aka Group based in Enugu and Nsukka in the Eastern part of Nigeria, formed in 1989 as a circle of exhibiting artists. It has close affinity to Nsukka School. As reported by Filani, the Aka group and Uli artists are philosophically inclined in thematic choice with clairvoyance in social vision Filani,1998:41. The founding members of Aka include Obiora Udechukwu, Tayo Adenaike, El-Anatsui, Nsikak Essien, Samson Uchendu and Chris Echeta among others.
Eye Society
The Eye society is based in Zaria Ahmadu Bello University. It was formed in 1992. The membership comprises mainly some artist staff of the Department of Fine Arts of the University who also graduated from the Department. Some of the founding members include Gani Odutokun died in 1994, Jerry Buhari, Jacob Jari, Matt Ehizele and Tonie Okpe. The group’s contributions have been in the areas of propagation of visual arts as an instrument of development of the society, publishing of journal called “The Eye”, mounting of exhibitions, organizing workshops conferences and symposia etc.
Uli Movement
It is Nsukka-based. The membership is for an artist who believes in the philosophy of Uli Art as a stylistic expression using its linear and spiral motifs in terms of forms and using themes that have socio-cultural content and advantage. The members of the movement who are both Igbo and non-Igbo include Obiora Udechukwu, Tayo Adenaike, Chris Afuba, Chris Echeta, El-Anasui the famous and prolific Ghana born artist, working in Nsukka University. Chijoke Onuwa, Chika Okeke, Olu Oguibe, Victor Ecoma, Ndidi Dike, Krydz Ikwuemesi, Ozioma Onuzulike and others.
Ona Movement
This was formed in 1990 by the five graduates of “Ife Art School”. The five pioneering founding members include Kunle Filani, Moyo Okediji, Tola Wewe, Bolaji Campbell and Tunde Nasiru. The movement explores the decorative motifs, ornaments, patterns and design peculiar to the rich artistic culture of the Yoruba Filani 1998. One advantage of Ona approach to artistic expression according to Filani is the rich visual grammar it affords the artist to employ, resulting to melody of tones, forms and structure and also enriching the aesthetic sensibilities of the viewers Filani 1997. Some of the other exponents of Ona philosophy as an art include Don Akatakpo, C.S.A Akran, Ojo Bankole, Akin Onipede, Ademola Azeez, Sehinde Ademuleya, Rasheed Amodu, Mufu Onifade ,Kunle Adeyemi and others. One of the major contributions of Ona movement to contemporary art is its enriching the visual aesthetic and appreciation of Art.
Pan-African Circle of Artists PACA
It is an artists’ organisation formed in 1995. Its focus is to provide fora or avenues for African artists within and outside the Continent. It also works “at engineering an indigenous voice for the propagation of African Art”. Ikwuemesi, 2000. Its founding members include Krydz Ikwuemesi, Ayo Adewumi, Nnaemeka Egwuibe, Jerry Buhari etc. One other contribution to art history in Nigeria and African continent is its regular publications that border on African and global issues. Its headquarters is located in Enugu, Nigeria.
Culture and Creative Art Forum CCAF
This organisation was formed in July, 2001. Its objectives among others include intervening and promoting the creative and artistic education of Africans through cultural means in order to encourage their economic and creative independence. It is also to maintain and sustain the rich cultural heritage of Africa and her people. Its headquarters is located in Lagos, Nigeria. Its founding members include Dr. Kunle Filani, Ademola Azeez, Dr Ademuleya Sehinde, Akin Onipede, Mike Omoighe, and Austin Emifoniye. It has organised two National Conferences with the themes “Culture and Creativity” in 2002 and Contemporary Challenges in Nigerian Arts” in 2003 . CCAF has published two major books.
Artistic Trends in Nigeria
The artistic trends in the country are still being dictated most times by the mode of training and styles adopted by each school discussed earlier. The artistic trends are as varied as number of art schools formal and informal movements we have. For instance, some artists of formal school orientation still engage in naturalistic art form with the synthesis of tradition and modernity to express their concepts. One other current artistic trend that is prevalent among the workshop trained artists especially of Osogbo and Ife Ori-Olokun is the depiction of their forms in the traditional culture, folklore and myths in a figurative and narrative way. Another artistic trend is the expressionistic expression that is prevalent among the Auchi School graduates.
Exponents of Ulism those who adopt Uli art forms of expression mostly graduates of Nsukka School and Onaists those who adopt Ona art form and concept as found in Yoruba decorative pattern, design and ornament to express their messages also constitute a strong trend in contemporary Nigerian art. The “surrealist-naturalists” of the Abayomi Barber School is equally an artistic trend. The common thing to most of these artists is their thematic expression depicting socio-religious beliefs, socio-economic conditions and social lives of the people.
The Front liners of the Artistic Scene
The frontliners of the artistic scenes today in Nigeria include established artists pf 1950s those referred to as “Zarianists”, such as Bruce Onobrakpeya, Yussuf Grillo, established artists of the 1970s, 1980s of formal school and some of the 1990s. The graduates of Informal School system discussed earlier are still in active practice and these are Osogbo and Ori-Olokun artists, and products of Abayomi Barber School the surrealists. Most of these artists’ works are still being collected and exhibited. They are classified as front liners because they exhibit from time to time and not only that, some of them exhibit yearly in solo exhibitions.
Representing 1950s graduates is Bruce Onobrakpeya who exhibits regularly with new works produced in the exhibiting year on display. Of the 1970s graduates is Kolade Oshinowo who apart from exhibiting regularly, also showcases new works. He is arguably the most prolific artist of his generation. Notable among the 1980s graduates who are front liners are Kunle Filani, Tola Wewe Ife School, Mike Omoighe, Olu Amoda, Abiodun Olaku Yaba School, Ndidi Dike female painter Nsukka School, Ben Osaghae, Olu Ajayi, Sam Ovraiti, Alex Nwokolo Auchi School, Duke Asidere Zaria School, Muri Adejimi and Olu Spencer, Informal school. Most of them have been listed in “Who is who” in Nigerian Art. The remarkable thing about these artists’ works is that each artist style of painting or sculpting or modeling is very unique and experimental and their artistic developmental stages can easily be traced by critics.
Art Writing and Criticism
Very few writers are engaged in critical writing on art. Among the few are visual artists and artist academic intellectuals. Their writings can be categorized into articles in art journals, newspaper art reviews , and reviews in exhibition brochures Critics of the 1970s include Ayo Ajayi, Ben Enwonwu, Cyprian Ewensi, Okpu Eze, Uche Okeke and Demas Nwoko and Obiora Udechukwu late70s. Art journalists/writers/critics of the 1980s include Ben Tomoloju, Tam Fiofori, Elsy Obasi, Taiwo Ogundipe and Toyin Akinosho, Jahman Anikulapo, Shola Balogun, Lanre Idowu, Wale Aina and Gbile Oshadipe and Dili Ezughan among others. Oloidi, 1996. The academic intellectuals who went into art writing and criticism from the early 1980s-1990s include Adepegba, C.O., Dele Jegede, Ola Oloidi, Olu Oguibe, Sylvester Ogbechie, Kunle Filani, Mike Omoighe, Chika Okeke and Krydz Ikwuemesi.
The art writers/critics who stand at the front line of the artistic scene today include Kunle Filani , Toyin Akinosho, and Jahman Anikulapo,and Krydz Ikwuemesi Their writings are remarkable due to the issues their critical writings generate. These issues range from art policy, art administration, status of the artists in Nigeria and Africa, art practice and theory to collection and appreciation of art among other topical issues. There are also up coming and promising art critics not mentioned here. The front liners listed here have contributed a lot of reviews in exhibition brochures, newspaper articles and reviews, academic art journals and even comments on socio-cultural issues in the country. Some have even curated national exhibitions. The limitation of their writings especially on artists’ works is their inaccessibility to the stages and processes involved in artists’ works before the final exhibition.
National Collection of Contemporary Art
There are collections of contemporary works by both government’s culture institutions and private collectors. The institution charged with the national collection of contemporary art is the National Gallery of Art NGA. It has the largest collection of artists’ works among the other culture institutions created. Its collection was first documented in 1981 in a publication titled “The Nucleus”. There are also private galleries and collectors who have in their keeps works of prominent contemporary artists. Among the private galleries in Lagos are Signature gallery, Treasure House, Nimbus gallery, Mydrim gallery, Galleria Romania, Nike Okundaye gallery, Quintessence and others. Private collectors are few Nigerians and foreigners mostly Europeans and Americans who have in their collections works of most artists mentioned in this article. Of special note among the Nigerian collectors, is Engineer Yemisi Shyllon, an avid art collector who arguably has the largest private collections of contemporary artists’ works both Nigerian and non-Nigerian artists.
Conclusion
It is the view of this writer that art and culture matters such as status of the artist, consistent implementation of art policy, administration of art and artists, production and practice of art, criticism and writing on art have not been given the adequate attention they deserve by the Government. There are many problems confronting contemporary art and artists in Nigeria some of which the artists themselves have attempted to solve but due to financial constraint and lack of political powers, those problems are still there. As individual artists and writers, they have tried to draw attention to some of the topical issues either through their art works or writings. There are a lot of benefits Nigerian Government can derive from artists and other culture activists if they are genuinely involved in the administration and implementation of art and culture matters that directly affect artists and citizens at large. Nigeria as the most populous Black African nation in the world can utilize the capabilities and potentials of her artists and culture activists if the artists are also allowed to put their ideas and skills into fruition as stated in the Cultural Policy for Nigeria. Nigerian artists are looking forward to a day when an established and a seasoned visual artist/administrator would be appointed to head for example, “The National Gallery of Art”. One believes that if this is done critical discourses of issues on art and culture could be widened and more articulated. On a final note, this article does not pretend to discuss and raise all issues on contemporary art and artists due to space constraint. The issues and artists cannot be exhausted in just one article.
References
Adepegba, C.O. 1995: Nigerian Art: Its Traditions and Modern Tendencies, Jodad Publishers, Ibadan. p.96
Azeez, W.A. 2002: “The Works and Artists of Abayomi Barber School in the Development of Contemporary Nigerian Art” PhD Proposal submitted to the Institute of African Studies, University of Ibadan
Filani, E. O. 1998: “Form and Content as a Basis for the Classification of Contemporary Nigerian Art” in USO: Journal of Art, National Gallery of Art, Lagos, pp. 33 – 44.
Filani, E.O. 2001: “Trends in Contemporary Yoruba Art: A Delineation by History and Styles” in A Discursive Bazaar : Writing on African art, culture and literature Ikwuemesi, K. C. and Adewumi, A.Eds.. PACA, Enugu Pp.127-140
Filani, E.O. 2003: “Zaria Art Society and the Imperative of Historical Articulation” in Triumph of a Vision: an Anthology on Uche Okeke and Modern Art in Nigeria, Ikwuemesi, K. C. Ed.Pp.133-143
Ikwuemesi, K.C. 2000: “Preface” in Crossroads: Africa in the Twilight, Aniakor,C.C and Ikwuemesi K.C. Eds., National Gallery of Art, Nigeria. p. v
Oloidi, Ola 1996: “Art Criticism in Nigeria, 1920-1996: the Development of Professionalism in the Media and the Academy”, in Art Criticism in Africa, Deepwell Katy Ed. P.p. 41-47
Osa Egonwa 2001: “The Evolution of the Concept of Natural Synthesis” in Uso-Nigeria Journal of Art Vol. 3 1 & 2 pp 52-60 as cited by Ademuleya, B.A. 2003: in “Synthesis: Between Onabolu, Enwonwu and the Zarianists” in Triumph of a Vision: an Anthology on Uche Okeke and Modern Art in Nigeria, Ikwuemesi, K. C. Ed. Pp. 145-153
THE AFRICAN VIEW OF ART AND SOME PROBLEMS FACING THE AFRICAN ARTIST

1968 - First Printed in Paris
Paris: Editions Presence Africaine
THE AFRICAN VIEW OF ART AND SOME PROBLEMS FACING THE AFRICAN ARTIST
Author Ben Enwonwu
The role of Art in Negro-African society is an important one for all who are concerned with the advancement of African Culture, African Thought and The African Personality. It should also concern the present generation of Africans whether they are interested in Art for art`s sake or not. In fact, no emergent African State today, can afford to ignore the urgent role of Art as we march towards renaissance. The Art of Africa is no longer looked upon as fetish, as it had been during the early days of European exploration of the Continent. It is no longer treated with the patronising attitude that was the case when the first missionaries, anthropologists, and travellers collected old pieces of objets d`art and mixed them up with what was genuine nor does African Art only enjoy the reputation of its influence as a result of its historic impact upon modern art. The terms African Negro Art, African Traditional Art, Primitive Art, Tribal Art, and all such aesthetic cliches which have become the currency of aesthetic evaluation of works of African Art must now be reconsidered in the light of the present African view. These cliches, together with the influences they exert on the critical mind, should now be regarded as part and parcel of the evangelical, educational, social, economic, and even the political chapters of the Colonial past. Art in present day Africa is seeking a new role, and this role that must be given to it by Africans themselves, will determine the form that it should take as the mirror of the aspirations of Independent African peoples.
Art is not static. Like Culture, Art changes its form with the times. It is setting the clock back, to expect that the art form of Africa today, must resemble that of yesterday otherwise, the former will not reflect the African Image. African Art has always even long before western influence, continued to evolve through change and adaptation to new circumstances. And in like manner, the African view of Art has followed the trends of cultural change up to the modern times. But it now appears that the young African painter and sculptor distorts his work deliberately so as to achieve Africaness, or else, that if he does not do so, his work will be imitative of European art. The craftsman-cum-artist on the other hand struggles between reality only with what he possesses of the old technique. This situation represents the psychological effects of Colonialism. It has no African Directive.
In the passing African social context, the African view of his Art was a view which was identified with other aspects of the African life. It was not an objective or an analytical view of Art. The realities of life were expressed in the symbolic structure of the work of art, Image, being the link. Artistic view did not spring from Art itself but from the totality of religio-social significance of the art functioning in the group-mind. For this reason, the African view of Art was an inner knowledge, and a spiritual participation rather than a result of a critical or analytical attitude. One is inter-related with Art, while the other is detached from it. A Western art critic writes of Art, of which he may not be a participant in the creative process of representational Image but the African is an observer as well as a participant or even the creator of his Image for the group. What we accept as Art in the western sense is not the same as what Art is in the African sense.
As a result of Western contact, those most keen as well as most influenced by the works of African Art adapted their own view and centred it mainly on the features of African traditional sculpture particularly, the images of ancestral gods, and went on to press and exploit the Image-Form which has become an enviable revitalising primitiveness sought after by the highly developed civilisations.
It seems absurd that present-day African painters and sculptors should support and sustain this psycho- logy of the Western view by imitating an attitude derived from the influence of African art works upon the Western aesthetic tradition.
Many books have been written about the type-form of African Art as acceptable to the West. Although this view has the highest respect for African Sculpture it is also in itself the central focus of Western aesthetics of African Art and, furthermore, has remained unchallenged in spite of the rapid developments in Africa today. In the most part, such books together with articles, journals, magazines and illustrations, have followed more or less the trend of thought engendered through the memoirs and the reports by some explorers, travellers, and missionaries, in thus stabilising an aesthetic cannon for Art in Africa which is alien to the realities of African Culture. Except for the more erudite and scholarly writings of such men as Leo Frobenius and some protest African writers of today, it might have been very difficult to challenge even the writings by such men as Levi Bruhl who treated the subject of the African Mind as though it was a strange question of homo sapiens. While others like Burton carried the colonialist theory that never the twain shall meet much too far. The rest were blind to the unique differences that do exist. I believe in the difference between Black and White, but it should be complimentary and not opposed to each other.
No books to my knowledge have appeared on great issues about the Art of Africa by Africans. The reason may be due to the problem of thought translation of such an abstract subject as Art, from one language to another. Or else, that the question of writing on the subject of African Art by Africans is a subject of writing about Creative Imagery. African Art is so identified with socio- religious concept that it spontaneously exercises the fullest measure of its viewpoint through recreative activities. Even story telling in a family group was socio-educational. It was handed down orally rather than written. But until the necessity for the African to write fully about his Art made itself felt, it would amount to forcing an analytical approach in a cultural milieu that does not require it. But to speak about the Art of Africa today automatically means The Traditional The Ancient The Tribal and The Primitive as characterized by the Western view of African Art. This must not be the African view today.
The first time that we Africans received the word ART as applied to the Creative Imagery of our Ancestors, was at the beginning of European colonisation of the African Continent. Through the teaching of the English language by the British, the word ART was adopted, as were indeed many thousands of other English words, by use of the language. The word ART has its limitations when defined, to mean the same sense as for instance, the Ibo word NKA. Art is defined in the English Dictionary as human skill as opposed to nature skilful execution of an object in itself skill applied to imitation and design as in painting etc. thing in which skill may be exercised certain branches of learning serving as intellectual instruments for more advanced studies as Bachelor, Master of Arts, one who has obtained a standard of proficiency in these black magic practical application of any sciences industrial pursuit, craft, guild company of craftsmen Fine - s. those in which the mind and imagination are chiefly concerned knack cunning stratagem. Art so defined, provides divergent meanings none of which is the same thing as the world NKA.
NKA may be understood to mean making of which doing the making of doing of a particular kind the object of which is specifically artistic and making is personified i.e., the professional of NKA and so particularised the object of NKA is specific, and so does not refer to any other kind of making, or doing it is strictly art, only by professional competence again. NKA bears a traditional significance as an art handed down from generation to generation - thus it is inheritable of family or even village groups such as in the known case of Benin NKA does not mean human skill as opposed to nature, but does imply identification with the nature of doing, or of Image. Art is subjective and therefore infinite. NKA is an objectification of Image more through the senses than through cunning of hand. Such definitions of Art as the art of running, swimming, black magic, of photography, stratagem, or as the art of doing anything do not refer to NKA.
The prefix OME further explains the identification of a second person i.e., OME-NKA – he is the maker of Nka. Both the maker of, and the art of what is being made. NKA, strictly speaking, has traditional and religious associations. Thus the field of so-called African Art is really the realm of the Ancestral world of Images so confined as it were to creativity in a spiritual sense. In terms of reference then, African Art is not really Art in the Western context, but an invocation of ancestral spirits through giving concrete form or body to them before they can enter into the human world. An illustration of this idea can be summarised in a short story, but which may be taken from the end of it. Juwa took away the spiritual body of his dead father with which the father performs the traditional act of transforming his spiritual body into the human body and vice versa. When his father returned on his way to go back to the spiritual world in which he dwelt, he could not find his spiritual body. Then he sang a song - Juwa Juwa Oh, Nyem Ofo Mo, Ofo`n ji eje Uwa, Onye eji mia elu Mmuo, Uwa dede! - his father calling Juwa, to give him his spiritual body, the body with which he comes into the human world because he who has not got it, cannot return, to the spiritual world.
The word ART is therefore only a classic term. When we Africans speak of Art, therefore, we are thinking of its manifestations from the Western view. We are not thinking of NKA, and what it includes. NKA, which is an Ibo word, satisfies the African meaning and the purpose of ART.
The problem of translating the term ART into a neo-African concept is primarily a linguistic one. So that some research and study are necessary into the diverse African languages and dialects to collect from every region or tribe the words that can mean the same thing as NKA with the prefix, OME. Depending of course on the tribal groupings, and the possibility of unification, we can begin to translate Art into an African term as signifying more, or less the same thing. Since those of us who have come under British rule have become accustomed to the use of the word ART, so have those of us who have come under France, Belgium, Germany and other European countries, become accustomed to their equivalent term for Art. So, at least, we can begin by laying the foundation upon common regional linguistic translations. However, this is mainly a problem for the students in languages to tackle first.
It is necessary therefore that the creative art of Africa today, should be practised with well defined means and aims so as to reflect, not the spurious effects of the very vital qualities of the old vision and cunning of hand of our OME-NKA but the trends of African changing situations as a result of our assimilation of Western culture. This means that more than a synthesis of old and new is to be achieved if a new concept is to follow.
It is to be regretted that the African painter and sculptor today are not facing the realities of the African situation in their artistic expressions. While they must derive inspiration from the old art or NKA, they must also make use of the inner knowledge so as to arrive at the meeting point between inspiration and ideas. They should neither imitate western Art, nor copy their old Art.
The opinions expressed by European anthropologists, collectors of old African sculptures, and the critics may be valid aesthetic considerations. But the concept and philosophy of these opinions are so remote from the African concept that they can no longer serve as the aesthetic cannons or judgement of what Art is, or should or should not be, in the present African situation. Nor can much of European interpretation of African Art today be valid anymore. The colonial status imposed such authority as civic or educational, which are conditions for the existence of art in any country. The Independence of African countries should now remove such conditions even by exercising political power.
Self-appointed art critics whether they are Europeans or Africans by either political or civic authority can influence the trend of artistic change in African countries. Their opinions matter, and can encourage or discourage artistic output, and even artistic thought, that may depend for its growth upon Government generosity. The press serves as a medium of publicising the works of the present-day African painter and sculptor as oppose to the communal use of the masks and figures of ancestors in the dance and the shrines of the old society. This borrowing of Western media of publicity can be highly effective as a means of communicating as well as disseminating artistic thought and appreciation of the functions of art in contemporary African society, but at the same time, it can, and has been misused to play politics Art. Where artistic opinions are fallacious or prejudiced, this medium of the press can only do great harm. Dennis Duerden, an English art critic of African modern art, who was once Art Master in Norther Nigeria, writes a great deal about the current trends of aesthetic manifestations in the art works of Africa today. In the Times Literary Supplement of September 13th. 1965, Mr. Duerden described Art in Africa Today as Art That Does Not Conform. He did not explain further as to what the art does not conform with. Mr. Duerden writes from London without keeping in close touch with the rapid social, economic, educational, and even religious changes that have been taking place in the African countries since he left Nigeria. Valid artistic criticisms must be based on philosophical ideas. For this to be feasible, speculative methods of approach must precede what contentions an art critic may hold, upon the appearance of works of any kind in Art since the appearance of art works must serve as what the eve can see, the perception of which depends on many social, economic and other cultural forces. The critic must know the mind of the artist whose works he writes about. If we should take such art critics as Mr. Duerden to task, we would first be reminded of Levi Bruhl`s contention, when he wrote that the Mind of the Primitive -- meaning the African Mind -- was incapable of logic. That it was pre-logical, meaning that the African mind works in a different orbit from that of the European by arriving at conclusions illogically. Research in the science of biological evolution has since proved that, the races of mankind are basically the same. The African Philosophy of Negritude, with due deference to President Senghor and Aimé Césaire, has defined the kind of knowledge that characterized the African spirit and mind. It is a capacity to identify self with object which has advantage in the -- preservation of the mystique, or the vital force in the creative exercise of Art -- especially in NKA. This has nothing to do with Mind in so far as the human mind is free to exercise action by receiving and giving its attributes in the process of analysis of matter and objects, or of identification with these. The integration of many aspects of the African life made co- existence of mind and matter possible, in the preservation of the vital force of the inner mind or the Inner Klang. That does not mean that the human mind, of any particular race of man is so characterized to be capable of doing only one kind of exercise on matter, but incapable of extending into other things outside its orbit. Analysis of matter depends on objectivity or a detached outlook, and time is one of the means of effecting change, in the human outlook whether in the early stages of the human existence or now. Once the human mind is involved in emotional problems of expression, whether in sorrow, grief, or joy, the reaction is spontaneous. Spontaneity carries with it the spiritual force with which man is endowed by the divine power. Change can only affect the human mind, and at all times, whenever objectivity is a necessity for self-preservation, the preservation of history, of Art, or of any matter as a result of the manifestation of the human Mind on things of the outer world.
The identification of persons with inanimate objects particularly in the creative exercise of Art or NKA gives to the art works the mystique and vital force otherwise known as Magic. Such great African scholars as President Senghor have explored the subject of African Negro Inspiration, Religion, and Ontology that this subject must be left to particular fields of studies in African Culture.
What concerns the African artist today who is facing the dual responsibility of his needs, is to find a new aesthetic creed or philosophy as a guide to his revolutionary ideas. Artistic revolutions do not occur merely by the capacity to adapt one form of art to another, but through revolutionary ideas. First, there must be a protest period, when the artists of a generation reject an aesthetic principle as a guide to their creative exercise. Then speculations and arguments. A revolution must be an intellectual rather than a practical solution. The well sought after synthesis between the old and the new, between the indigenous and the effects of western civilization in African Art today must depend for its realisation, not upon imitating works of any kind that come to the mind of the artist, but through discussions of ideas. In this way, a new school which will allow for individualism can emerge. At the present stage of change in African Art, it is a common experience to find that all so-called progressive African artists are expressing, not a concept of the African advancement and situation, but a concept of the European school of thought which resulted from ideas as well as the influence derived from the old African works of art. Practically every progressive African artist today has a tendency towards abstractionism. And this looks more like modern European expression both in ideas and technique. It is not African.
African art of today does not have to conform to non-representation in order to maintain the name African. It should, in fact, become a startling realism since the problems of the African locale today are realistic and are faced from the most logical and realistic manner. Political meetings in African countries reflect the state of the African mind. They show a balance of thought and a maturity that are typical of an old people. When African countries are described as young, it can only mean in the sense that science and technology have just begun to find their way into the schemes for rehabilitation and advancement along modern lines. This does not mean that what had existed in Africa had not reached stages of advanced sophistication it would also be wrong to condemn African aristocracy because it does not resemble that of Europe. Alien concepts must be sorted out and analysed before they can be acceptable in our new societies. The African must find a solution to the economic problems facing his present- day art, for that has a tremendous influence on the process of change. If art is not used, it cannot go on. The educated or the intellectual African today must equate the financial value of art to the monetary system of the West. To say that a work of art is too expensive is not only to give a higher value to mass products of Western science, such as motor cars having more importance than Art, but also to negate the very intellectual assessment of art of which he is either convinced, or else dabbling in, so as to appear highly educated. If the comparison of money and art presents a difficult problem to the African intellectual, then his convictions are no realistic or honest. Here the importance of the economic aspect of African art today must also be considered along the civic importance of art. African Independent Governments must seek the proper place for artistic manifestations, not merely by the use of art or the teaching of it in Colleges, but by realising the connection between political Independence and Cultural Freedom. Political Freedom in Africa particularly must clothe itself with the colours of culture so as to present the true Culture of the African peoples in pagentry, buildings, and other means by which the prestige of Government makes itself felt.
Apart from the problems of the African artist today being primarily connected with artistic matters and their dependence on outside forces, which means that he must first retain some of the ideas of the old art namely, the sub-realism of Image, Rhythm and Form - African Governments must see African Art as part of the political matters which concern them. To do nothing about imitating Western or colonial pageantry inherited by the African Independent Governments is to perpetuate Colonialism. Since no African Government apes Western democratic systems, it should now be possible for them all to carve out a place of honour for the African Art of today so that it will mirror our political, social, civic, educational, religious, and cultural aspirations and in this way serve the artists of Africa with some of their greatest needs for the solution of these problems in independent African countries.
First published 1968

1956 - First Published in Paris
Paris: Editions Presence Africaine
PROBLEMS OF THE AFRICAN ARTIST TODAY
Author Ben Enwonwu
The problems which face the African artist of our generation are many and difficult. They may be classified as political, cultural, educational and social, and even emotional problems. I should, however, like to introduce a few thoughts on some aspects of these problems that may throw light on the inevitable causes, in the hope that some solution can be found.
Perhaps, the most pressing among these problems and therefore one which I feel personally, should be given first attention is the political. The cause of the political aspect of these problems can be envisaged and considered by the extent to which Art has been accorded its proper place in the political life of the African peoples.
It is a common assumption that Art has nothing to do with politics. That this human activity, is not a biological necessity and therefore, it is an isolated phenomenon which has no political context or mission. This common attitude to Art is an under-estimation of its useful and practical purpose, as well as of the basis for its existence. For, it is not even so much what Art has to do with politics, that has created such difficult problems today, as how political situations affect Art and the artist.
In fact, every true artist is bound by the nature of the traditional artistic state of his country, to express, even unconsciously, the political aspirations of his time. And for expressions to be true, they must be an embodiment of the struggle of self-preservation.
The epochs of high artistic achievements of any country, have been those of comparative political stability, and of great national pride. It is in such a period in the life of a country that Art assumes its role of great national importance. Then the artist is able to devote his energy freely, to the creation of national art such as memorials, and monuments, to the glory of his country. The political function of Art can therefore be determined by the subject matter of Art which can be differentiated from its aesthetic beauty.
Benin is known throughout the world today for its Art. Certain types of the art of Benin can be characterized as essentially civic, by the descriptive motifs and patterns of the sculpture. The bronze plaques that depicted scenes of each succeeding Oba and the grades of chiefs of the old Kingdom the decorated maces the carved staffs of office by which the order in the hierarchy of chiefs were graded the armour and embellished weapons, these works of art were almost essentially inspired by political ideals. It was to the political function of the State that they were directed.
Unlike the old days when the African artist did not have to face problems of political nature, the transition period that we are passing through therefore presents new artistic problems. The present political situation in Africa affects the artist, and has tended to divide artistic productivity into lesser and greater kinds, by the conditions which it has created for the artists.
We now have artists who live in villages, and because their mode of life is not unaffected, they continue to maintain the old vision and traditional craftsmanship. They still carve masks in old style, which are used in the dance they still carve ancestral figures for the sanctuary of our fathers, and their fathers` fathers. In fact, they are struggling under new social, religious, and political systems, to maintain the lamp of continuity of our spiritual values and indigenous culture. The art they create is a living art, and their appreciation of art generally is genuine, simple, direct, and sincere. Their emotional reaction to all kinds of art works is vital, and therefore important to note.
We also have artists who are moving into big towns from the villages, and who are the makers of tourist art whose objets d`art are sought after by most European visitors and settlers in Africa. These artists are nonetheless interested in what they produce, but it is of equally great importance to them to find a market for their art pieces. The economic necessity is caused by political situation which is beyond their control. They have to live, and their art affords an economic solution to their means of living.
Then we are now having artists among the young people who have been to school, as well as those who are educated. These artists are using western techniques to express themselves as individual artists. I think that the problems of this group are the greatest and most difficult of the others, because they bear the burden of having to bridge the gap, between the ancien and the modern in art. Besides this fact, it is they who have to evolve a contemporary art that will, for political reasons, prove to the world that African Art can be preserved and can be continued. In my opinion, the preservation and continuity of the characteristic quality of African Art, depends largely, on how modern African artists can borrow the techniques of the west without copying European Art.
It would not have been necessary for the African artist of today, to prove to the world that he can create objects of great beauty, had the political problems that he has had to face, not affected him so deeply, and his art as well. I need not mention the problems that Africans face both at home and abroad, as we know what they are, and there are experts who deal with such sociological, educational, and economic problems, and soon, I would group these problems within the political heading.
An artist can create while in a state of mental worries or when he suffers. Sometimes, his suffering can bring out the genius within him through emotional strife to externalize his burning desire, or say, as many people say, that an artist does his greatest work when he is suffering. This may be true, but it depends or what kinds of sufferings, and the causes of the suffering. But I know that when a country is suppressed by another politically, the native traditions of the art of the suppressed begin to die out. Then the artists also begin to lose their individual and the values of their own artistic idiom. Art, under this situation is doomed what follows is an artistic vacuum that may be prolonged for even a century. By this of course, I do not mean that no more art can be created by the artists, but much of what they could, and did do in the past, can be denied them and those who follow them.
The present generation of African artists therefore has to face their political problems, and try to look at Art through politics the kind of picture that the political aspect of African Art shows is one of intense strife and pity.
One, it is a pity that while the historic influence of African Art on European aesthetic traditions and Art has created a healthy revitalization of decadent art-form and traditions of Europe and America, the influence of western ideas and technological system, as well as that of education has, politically speaking, not proved, and can never prove, the best means of keeping alive the native genius of the African peoples. And while Europe can be proud to possess some of the very best sculptures from Africa among museums and private collectors, Africa can only be given the poorest examples of English Art particularly, and the second-rate of other works of art from Europe.
The preservation of the old art in certain regions of Africa is, of course being carried out particularly in Nigeria. But it is strange - strange because I would like to put this point to you – that those in supreme authority for the preservation of what is left of African Art, as well as what can be bought or brought back home, are not the Africans whose ancestors created the sculptures but Europeans, whose predecessors were responsible for the disappearance of numberless African art works from their country of origin. I would admit though that this disappearance, also had its good results. It has resulted in the world-wide admiration and an aesthetic evaluation of African Art. It has also won a place of honour for African Art in the aesthetic traditions of the west. Yet, the African himself seems to have so little to do with these either through his own lack of interest in his past, or through not being given the opportunity to participate in the development of his native art.
The African intelligentsia considers this aspect of the problem an academic one, for which he claims that few Africans except himself, were qualified to examine scientifically. The science of anthropology has therefore, and for a long time, been used to create an intellectual barrier which makes it extremely difficult for most Africans to be considered qualified to play an important part in the development and preservation of their native art. Even those intellectuals who know very little or nothing about art, and African Art, are the authorities in whose hands lie the future of African Art. In the educational and social activities that have political support, the African artist of today is subordinated to instructions of persons whose opinions are biased uninformed, and fallacious.
In some parts of Africa, the problems of the modern artist, are more politically involved, and therefore more difficult, than others. In more advanced parts where political consciousness had culminated in the desire for political independence or self- government with all this implies, the artist`s function and duty to his country as an interpreter of the group-political ideology, have not yet been fully realized, even by those Africans in political power. At least, they have not realized that art should develop simultaneously with political growth and freedom.
It is, in fact, in these regions that African Art has not only come under the pressure of modern industrialism and the machine age, but it is also in danger of being forgotten. The artists are not being fully used either by the government in power, or by the public. Nor is any serious attempt being made to see that the African artist is given priority when commissions for works of art of national importance are being given. For instance, in Nigeria, postage stamps commission was offered to a free-lance European artist without any Nigerian artist being considered. In Benin, the city of ancient art, stands a bronze figure of EMOTAN. No Nigerian artist was considered for the commission. Perhaps, the Benins themselves wanted a sculpture made or manufactured in England.
Intelligent Africans and Europeans who have failed to look at the problem essentially from the political aspect of its involvement, but who are not themselves artists, have argued that since art is international, it is justified to give commissions for art works that will live in Africa for all time, to whoever that is qualified to undertake them. The assessment of the right person and his qualifications having been based entirely on western standards is decided, not by Africans but by Europeans.
I am not saying that the European authority whoever he may be, is not sometimes kind enough to offer a commission to an African artist, but the fact is that the African artist must be humble enough to apply for, or receive from the benevolent European something that belongs to the African. The emotional strife involved under such conditions can be a hindrance to free creative energy being directed into its right channel.
This regrettable factor has thrown the field of African Art open to the monopoly of the powers that be, and sometimes to the philistines, as well as to fallacious standardisation on foreign basis an art that is best known and understood by the people who create it. While Europeans are the best judges of their own art, and no one argues about this fact, the African does not even have a chance to play an equally important part in judging his art, let alone his justifiable claim if he chooses to make one, that he is the best judge of his own art.
Another instance that I would like to give in reference to this is that in Nigeria Annual Festival of Arts are held in all regions, namely, the three regions, the east, north, and the west and also, in the colony of Lagos. The sole judges of the Arts Festival are Europeans. They organize the show, run and judge the works of art. Of course, I was not welcomed as a member, because of my criticisms of the way in which they are run, and who run them. But I attend the Festivals and give lectures and exhibitions when I am invited to do so.
I have stated some of the political problems which the African artist faces in his own country, but outside of his own country today, he faces the humiliation of having to listen to lecturers on African Art in foreign art galleries and museums. He visits foreign museums in order to see a collection of the art of his own country and very often European curators show him round the museum.
This aspect of the problems is cultural, emotional, a political and there are many other problems in which politics and culture as well as education enter into the life of the African artist`s life and his dilemma.
I have only mentioned the political aspect so far, although the other aspects are important, I would prefer to leave them to an open discussion.
Introduction to African Contemporary Art

INTRODUCTION TO AFRICAN CONTEMPORARY ART
Simon Njami
Cameroon | Switzerland
Simon Njami
Revue Noire
8, rue Cels
F - 75014 Paris
Fax: 00331-43 22 92 60
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. The future of a Metaphor
The debate on African contemporary art has only just begun. And failing reliable tools and established references, everyone chips in their personal little speech and contributions. This domain has gradually turned into a huge strategic absurd battle field where all kinds of mercenaries and adventurers rage. It's as though, for want of deeper reflection, everyone believed that all you needed to do to possess the truth was be the first, like in the days of the first discoveries. Whereas there is no absolute truth, neither here nor in any other creative field. There is only subjective truth, a vision that has to reach a certain degree of freedom to be able to express itself with new ideas, sending back to t he garrets of exoticism all those things that should never have come out of them in the first place. There is no history of art in Africa, we're told. But what is meant by this concept? This notion assumes a history, an evolution, a localisation that signifies something precise for a specific region of the world. The notion of History of Art does not bear a single universal vocation. And when we talk of history which history are we referring to? Art from the Ming dynasty, the statues on Easter Island, Dogon masks or the Sistine Chapel?
This exhibition was conceived to feed this debate and confirm the existence of innovative African creation, continuing the experience started in Spain with Otro Pais - the other country. The Other Journey is a journey of the senses, emotions and aesthetics. The continually moving story of a world in perpetual mutation and artists whose only guarantee of belonging to our century is their work. The artists selected come from the Caribbean, Africa, the United States. They are united by a communal history and memory. But beyond this perhaps artificial link we notice how much they have each forged their own personal language, that has either been elaborated in the land of their origins or else thousands of miles from the country of their ancestors, as if to say that the issue of being born here or there is not the real problem any more. This other journey was built on the ruins of a history that is nothing more than a metaphor, a lyrical illusion.
The notion of African contemporary art is a decoy. No-one today knows how to define what it really covers. Yet we talk about it constantly. In order to conjure up the demons of History and to let it have a real foundation and benefit from real autonomy. But the fight, for it is indeed a fight, promises to be tough. You can't cover several centuries of History in just a few lines. Even if we can all be hazily aware of the fact that in order to exist, twenty-first century art will have to manage to become metaphor. A metaphor that would encompass the whole of humanity. Notions of borders and nationalities would thus be definitively abolished.
The approach towards African art, be it today's or yesterday's, is and always has been of the same ilk as the anthropometric approach of the first explorers on the continent. A kind of typology of race and kind. The first important symposiums organised with the open ambition of exploding the myths and exploring a new approach were initiated in the 1990's. I will only mention two, for the record, that took place in 1991. Africa Explores the Twentieth Century in New York and the Kunstsammlung Nordrhein-Westfalen in Dusseldorf, initiated by Nadja Taskov-Köhler and Elisabeth Luchesi. The American symposium tried to pose the numerous questions that are raised as soon as one deals with African contemporary art, while Dusseldorf was more specifically interested in Nigeria. These meetings showed that the way African creation is approached in the West is tainted with a lack of comprehension that sometimes verges on malevolence. In fact, both in New York and in Dusseldorf, the people in charge of reading out their communications all had the same background: academics, scientists, ethnological museum curators - plus a critic and a gallery owner in Dusseldorf - and they implied that specific grids of interpretation correspond to African art, albeit from this declining twentieth century. According to them, only an in depth study of the civilisation, history and setting can give this creation any meaning. There were even speakers in Germany who confirmed that African contemporary art's place is in ethnological museums. Thankfully, some artists could also express themselves with their own language both in New York and Dusseldorf.
So why does this specific vision, or more precisely non-vision, still persist today, when the only criteria for judgement are based on emotion and sensitivity? - But, Jan Hoet, then director of the Kassel Documenta would reply, Africa does not have a sufficiently elaborated history or theory of art for us to lean on and what's more, he would add, the European stance that has been developed since the end of the Renaissance is so intrinsically linked to a specific context it would be useless to try and apply it to Africa. Well then? Does it all come down to a question of semantics? Are the references linked to Africa confined to terms like post-colonial, arts and crafts, urban or utilitarian art? I refuse to go along with that. Before art, wherever it comes from, can be considered first for what it is - and not in relation to prejudices which mean that both the art market and contemporary art museums, already overwhelmed by their chronic incapacity to put emotion and true freedom of choice behind prospering classifications - the legitimacy of our position must be reaffirmed over and over again. I won't go as far as the indignation of Nigerian artist Emmanuel Taiwo Jegede who was opposed in Dusseldorf to the idea that funeral sculptures could have been presented as being contemporary African art. "Who, he said, would think of going into a western cemetery in order to find the essence of a country's contemporary artistic expression?"
The way I see it, the inanity of these debates in fact reflects the limits reached by those who up to now have made themselves the major representatives, specialists and promoters of this art. For they suffer from an objectivity problem. They are incapable of envisaging an African work of art without the tics and references that their training and past have condemned them to. The oncoming era, with its reams of new complexities, has nothing to satisfy them, nothing they can cling on to. The world has moved too fast to let decrepit certainties still serve as any kind of reference. We should no longer look at an artist, albeit an African artist, while only taking the criterion of his native village into account. Besides, apart from the artist himself, who can still be interested in this village protected by the ravages of time, in the highly complex and secretive process of creation? Note that we are still a long way away from that notion of metaphor rising up above all ideas of belonging and origins to encompass the world that I mentioned earlier. Which just goes to show that it's future is far from being settled. And perhaps that is the reason why it has become urgent to throw light onto the mechanisms that have led to the situation we know today, so that African contemporary art can avoid falling back into a prosaism that would condemn it, in the short run, from emerging free of all superfluous and prejudicial considerations.
2. The Exception and the Rule
Like all markets, the international art market is governed by rules. You can contest their justification all you like, the fact is they exist and are a law unto themselves. The only problem and reservations that can be emitted concern the application of these rules, for as soon as you leave the West the principle of exception applies. Europe is the rule, the rest of the world is the exception. The prejudiced complex hanging over African contemporary art is the perfect illustration. Whether you admit it or not, its origins lose themselves in the long night of slavery. One does not dare believe that there is nothing less than a eurocentrist strategy hidden behind this attitude, in order to maintain an age-old status quo about contemporary African creation. The market and the critic - the power - would thus stay on the same side, without division.
To justify slavery the church decided that the black man, deprived of a soul, was not a human being in his own right. Following the same kind of logic, the absence of Africa and its diaspora in the international art ring was justified by decreeing that Africa had no artists. The first manoeuvre was the ethnologisation of African creation in the 15th century. An exterior, anthropometric gaze was posed on the sculptures. Africa was the land of curiosity and exoticism. Africa represented an elsewhere. The advantage of elsewhere is that a distance is created between the watcher and the watched. The border is set up right from the start. The other is shut away into a straight-jacket of principles and analysis, condemned never to resemble "us". Once you define its specificity, you can kill it. Hitler did no differentlyÉ
Intellectual talk in the colonial years was built on the same argumentation. Right up to the present day, when the same counter truths are still current. No matter that in the 30's men like the German Frobenius tried to make a different voice heard (1). The dominant theory remained unshakeable. No matter that the Fauvists, Cubists and Surrealists looked upon African sculptures with aesthetic emotions. Africa did not exist. The norms that defined western art history were individuality, the artist as a solitary character and desanctified art celebrating the death of God. As though the West's sole art had not been religious at one point, right up to the Renaissance when art became something else. And didn't the Renaissance artists themselves work in studios where various apprentices were in charge of making the colours, backgrounds and numerous other little jobs? In what way does this form of collective art differ from that practised by African sculptors of centuries past?
No matter. Despite the storms of cultural alienation, the Africans have held fast and made it through the century. A certain path has today been covered, with the natural exception of some revisionists who will always be around. A very small path. For the old demons in the art world remain, demons who want African art to be an art from elsewhere. The humanity that makes us all fellow creatures who look at others in the same way we look at ourselves is still denied. The specificity of vision is the only specificity.
We will never assert Africa's place in the development of worldwide culture enough, today more so than ever. There are no lack of examples and I won't list them here. The artists are there to prove paralytic minds wrong through their work. Ousmane Sow's, Bili Bidjocka's, Ouattara's and Willy Bester's are there to tell us about their humanity and how they belong. To tell us with their own voices and experiences, like Raushenberg, Clemente or Barcelo, who they are and why their work concerns us all.
3. Anthropometric visions.
Through what is commonly known in the western word as History of Art, Europe granted itself with a monopoly over good taste and the infallibility of judgement. We should nonetheless add ethnology to this. In regions like the Caribbean or Africa it is no stranger to the present situation. This speciality revealed a whole group of mechanisms of human history. The Europeans, turning up in foreign lands in the 15th century with their weapons, their crosses and their appetite, needed justification for the largest genocide ever perpetrated in history. Between the 15th and the 19th centuries, over 100 million Africans were deported or killed in the slave trade. How could they admit that this black gold had any kind of human quality and thence human rights? Their so-called science and superiority needed to be established through a scientific truth. In my opinion ethnology - and it should be noted at this point that new currents which have risen up against colonial theories have been around for a few years now, exploring other approaches and trying to give Human sciences new directions - was merely a way of maintaining intellectual and moral domination over the colonies. From then on, the works they "discovered" among these primitive peoples became study objects that had nothing to do with art, but were supposed to help understand a civilisation. In this way, all artistic production was seen as a primitive ritual element until relatively recently and was deprived of its artistic qualities right from the start. Seeing as the so-called primitive peoples were incapable of creating objects that were neither functional nor religious (thus bearing witness to the contradictory principle of exclusion, which means the same causes do not produce the same effects according to which part of the world you're looking at), in other words incapable of producing art, according to the new European standards.
The system of thought produced by the dialectic of domination was just a tool at the service of another will for domination, if we refer to the language system used for Africa starting from the first major journeys, later called the colonial expeditions. This language still prevails today. The most interesting word in this exotic dictionary is the word savage, whose evolution betrays how words can be imprisoned once they are diverted from their primary signification. Roland Barthes described the social codes inherent to all language systems. According to him, language is a system of recognition linked to common references. Consequently, the words we use in a given context, with given groups, do not cover the same meaning. This code will only serve to determine your belonging to one or other group and give information about your past and your education. Through these language micro-systems the world is always looked at and analysed according to a unique point of view to which a universal value will be attributed, even if this point of view is only shared by a minority. "Language is a legislation, idiom is the code. We do not see the power that is in idiom, because we forget that all idiom is a classification and that all classifications are oppressive"(2). It is one of the tools that serves to establish distinction codes (3). Because of its nature, this value refuses to take into account references that are not its own. It only functions uni-dimensionally. A dimension that can be called ethnocentrism. In 1948, Jean-Paul Sartre was already noting this appropriation inherent to the western system of thought: "For the white man has enjoyed the privilege of seeing without being seen for three thousand years; his vision was pure, the light from his eyes dragged all things from the shadow of birth, the whiteness of his skin, it was another vision, condensed light. The white man, white because he was man, white like the day, white like truth, white like virtue, lit up creation like a torch, disclosed the secret white essence of human beings." (4)
We can therefore see that the roles were handed out right from the start. The savages - the ancient Greeks similarly called all those who weren't Greek barbarian - are all those who are not European. The words have changed, of course, but their meaning remains the same. And if, as Hegel says, we think through words, western countries have kept prejudices that are so deeply rooted within they certainly aren't ready to get away from them. For example, the distinction between written and oral: when the Europeans landed on African soil for the first time and found this oral civilisation (that they wouldn't even have called civilisation) they had the feeling they were entering an inferior world. A world that they could bring the light of their age-old knowledge to. Nothing existed outside of the printed word. This void was so taken for granted that even a mind as brilliant as Hegel himself asserted: " Africa is not a historical part of the world. It has no movements or developments to show, no historical movements within. It's northern stretch belongs to the European or Asian world; what we specifically mean by Africa is the anti-historical spirit, the undeveloped spirit, still subjected to natural conditions and which should only be presented here as being the threshold of History."(5)
Nevertheless it eventually became necessary to find a substitute for the term savage. So the word primitive arrived which, despite its scientific connotation, boiled down to the same meaning. From then on, in the hypocrisy of having an easy conscience, the decision is made to educate the savages even if, as the French philosopher Lucien Lévy-Bruhl said in 1923: "The mental functioning of primitive peoples is basically different to that of Europeans, and these differences are hereditary and unchangeable."(6)
The photographs taken by European anthropologists to measure natives like monkeys inspired me with the term "Anthropometric Vision". It took me a long time to realise - no doubt because the parallel seemed so outrageous - that anthropometric photography was also used to study lunatics and criminals: a whole section of the population made up of asocial people, in relation to a certain culture. As if to better define the specificity of the "other". Once African skulls had been measured and Africans had been studied and classified as a speciesÉ then even the vision a young person could have of Africa could no longer be a vision entirely exempt of these stereotypes that remain in our minds. The African remains identified with this anthropometric image that we can gauge. How then to admit that there is no need to enter a culture in order to understand and feel an emotion when faced with a work of art, that emotion is the primary vector of understanding? I believe in the existence of a transcendental aesthetic vision of the world: Kant said that everything that appeals universally and without concept is "beautiful"; he said it somewhat briefly.
The thesis of the universality of taste strikes me as being of questionable pertinence. Nonetheless, Kant implies that reason cannot be the unique vector of taste and on this point I willingly agree. Because our human side means that we can communicate with anyone, any other human being. Points of view that show up differences are mere details. One of the problems of criticism when it comes to talking about African art is to categorise everything. It is important to break down these mechanisms and make the vision prevail. Without this approach, without this untouched vision, there will never be exhibitions of African artists like there are exhibitions of Picasso or any other western artist at the MOMA or the Pompidou Centre. But let's get one thing clear. Being exhibited at the MOMA or the Pompidou Centre is not the ultimate goal. Large institutions are merely the symbols of the paralysis of the so-called "international" art world which takes refuge in its certitude without ever daring to venture further afield. It is obvious that the adventure of the future will be played on different ground. And the Africans will have to be ready for it.
4. The Invisible Man
I think it would be useful to remember that the situation of black artists - for let's not get it wrong, this is who we are talking about - is the same all over the world. Whether they live in London, New York, Bamako or Port au Prince, black artists are plagued by invisibility, in the sense of Ralph Ellison's words (7). Social invisibility, of course, but also - and possibly even more trying - artistic invisibility. And this possibly constitutes the sole reason why African artists must fully take part in this international concert. Above all else, African contemporary art is duty bound to be visible, with its similarities, its differences and its specificity. Without this it will carry on being the poor relation of a history that hasn't been written for it. This obviously does not mean that only the African must be perceptible through the work. The artist is a whole, with indissociable experiences. In a recent interview in the New York Times Outtara himself says that his most recent work is linked to the initiation he received in the Ivory Coast where his roots are found. Up to today one stuck to this indication of origin, to the expense of all else. This is where the anthropometric vision comes in.
The Magicians of the Earth exhibition that was so talked about was simply an extra representation of alterity in its most caricatural form, no matter what the good intentions at the root of the project were. But I think the curators of the exhibition gave in to exoticism. Or else, and this is even more dire, the works they presented actually corresponded to the idea they have of modern African creation. Failing lying and falling into that specificity I was talking about, I don't think you can show a Boltanski next to a man who makes coffins. He is a craftsman, regardless of the quality of his work. We don't have the right to tell the visitor who thinks he is going to discover so-called African contemporary art for the first time: "here's what they do in the West and now here's what they do in Africa", because the approach is slanted from the outset. The principle of putting a certain African creation out of context is particularly 'in' at the moment. The museum acts as a telluric centre, an extra-territorial sacred place, all references are abandoned to create an environment that will make this or that peasant "conceptual". The work or its author no longer have a role at all. They simply intervene as an instrument of a superior will: the omnipotent God curator. Yet an artist is someone who thinks up his creation, who knows why he is an artist and whose continual research can be seen through his work. Some "specialist" or other hasn't turned up with his prejudices and his truths, as a kind of deus ex machina to decree what his art was made of in his place and on his behalf. And yet this is the way the West always approaches African creation. Working on the mistaken assumption that the notion of History of Art is absent from the black continent, it reinvents it from one day to the next, according to its own interests. Interests which are often a far cry from what it says.
Other more recent exhibitions cowered behind political or historical arguments. But there again aesthetics and creation as such were pushed aside. These exhibitions gave rise to a whole anthology of classifications, the most lasting being Suzanne Vogel's (8) and Pierre Gaudibert's in the book he devoted to contemporary African art (9) the same year. Vogel and Gaudibert tried to establish if not a hierarchy then at least a distinction between the different forms of art from Africa. The section that directly concerns us was called International Art by Vogel and Knowing Art by Gaudibert. This classification encompassed artists that can be seen exhibited in western galleries for the former and those who had received academic learning in fine Arts schools for the latter. But this merely complicated a debate that was already particularly tortuous, by creating a reactive will for a return to nature and authenticity. The artists that lived with their century found themselves banished from these circles, on the pretext that their work was merely a copy of what could already be seen in the West.
We only accept exchange with a person we consider to be our equal. Exchange with those we consider inferior is impossible. Quite a few of us were moved by the way Nam June Paik treated the work of Ghanaian Samuel Kane Kwei during his New York exhibition from November 1994 to January 1995 (10). One-way exchange is unfortunately still just as frequent today. Yet we are living in the age of information highways and universalization. Let's not confuse universalization and uniformization. What is universalism, if not a melting pot where Nouba, Fan and Bamiléké art is found just as easily as cubism, arte povera, constructivism, conceptual art etc. It has become our shared collective memory. And yet the African is still refused this notion of creative appropriation. We want him to stay in his natural state. The critics - very few of whom are really interested in African art - are on a hopeless quest for a certain purity that dismisses the African artist from the art market. The myth of the good savage lingers on. At best they will say that he has gone back on what he has done, that he is alienated.
But this attitude is possibly inspired by the opposition between communal life and individualism. He who fears change is he who doubts his own existence. Without wanting to generalise, I think we are reaching a stage where Europe and the North are increasingly fragile; fear of the other dominates, both politically and intellectually. The fear of being diluted into the "other" is at the root of the rise in protectionism and nationalism. This self-enclosure is perhaps one of the deeper reasons behind the art crisis in the West. Africa brings a breath of fresh air, in the very real sense of the term, an earthly, cosmic side proposes a new cosmogony. Significant art is art that comes from somewhere. You cannot create an ex-nihilo art. Artistic creation is governed by an imperative necessity. It is work of asceticism and meditation. Lavoisier said "nothing creates itself, nothing loses itself, everything transforms itself". Creation is a process of re-creation, destroying in order to reconstruct, but always starting off with the same paste. And you can feel this paste, from the conceptual work of an African to the more figurative work of someone else, you can sense the origin. That is what makes this art's strength and durability, and perhaps that is what scares people. It carries a strength of soul within. Everything is not pure reason! Malraux said it in his day and he was right. Doing things full of spirit that have a meaning now only exists in Africa and more broadly speaking in the Third World.
Symbol of the separation between Church and State, the West has burned its old icons. The African artist does not feel the need to kill God. God is multiple. He comes in many shapes. He is wind and water. This gives creation a rousing strength. The Westerner is attracted to this strength, even if he only notices the outer shell. He sees the signs and is fascinated. The problem is that a sign which does not talk grows weaker. Like Pierre Verger reminded us (11), the great healers had set up the theory of the effective wordÉ "I give you this plant. If you swallow it down like any old pill, it won't have an effect on you. But if you take it while saying the right words in relation to your illness and your psychological profile, the plant will have an effectÉ". An empty art is a dead art. The art of the 80's was an empty art. Only wind will remain, "a black hole in the memories of us all."(12)
Parallel to the relative decline of western creation we witness the rapid development of African artists that sends us back to the Hegelian master-and-slave paradox. In this upturned dialectic it appears quite clearly that the slave needs the master in order to be a slave less than the master needs the slave in order to be master. Who is the real master? The master or the slave? We are crossing the era where the idol and the myths collapse one by one. If we could stick purely to a notion of exchange, the misunderstandings would be swept away. The scientific, artistic and intellectual studies of the other are acceptable if you agree to invert the situation. We are at the dawn of an extremely interesting period. People do not know who they are any more and we all have to reposition ourselves in relation to world movements. Otherwise there will be an explosion. This is valid for South Africa, Yugoslavia and the rest of the world. We have to rethink our relationship with the "other". If we don't then it's all over. This is all the more true in art, for art is the illustration of all human passions. Everything we do in art is what we do elsewhere, in love, in warÉ with gunsÉ Those guys aren't like us, so we eliminate them.
The Invisible Man Ralph Ellison spoke of is no longer entirely invisible. Today he can give back as good as he got. His capacity to react calls everything into question. The West is completely lost, but so is Africa. It incarnates what Fanon called The Damned of the Earth, all those excluded from the G-7! What is interesting about the situation is that the opponents prepare for combat, each one ignoring the other's strength! Despite their apparent emancipation, a kind of "colonial emancipation" persists with Africans, but an inverted one, where they say "well, he is the master". It is just as trying for the slave to discover that the master is merely another slave as it is for the master to discover that the slave is another master. It is a latency period that favours the updating of old reactionary theories. Those who have run out of munitions throw their shoes. To some extent, art reflects politics. Not so long ago people said that African art didn't exist. Today it does. Even if the old suspicions still linger on. Even if it is picked on by "specialists" as soon as it wanders from the beaten track of conventional images. It has gained a certain recognition. It is a step forward. And in order to make this first step forward probing, and not quickly transformed into two steps back, it is up to us to try and draw up the contours which, no matter how random they may be, will nonetheless be tools for the future.
6. The Invention of Memory
"It was the between-the-two-wars years, a few dozen African students woke up among other youngsters - West Indians - stripped, naked and black like them. For years they had recited their "Ancestors the Gauls" and declined "amo, amas, amatÉ" along with the white-hearts. And now they were being reproached for it and learning they had no heritage, that they would only ever know how to build imitation sand houses, like children on the beach. The foundations of the West were shaken up, vigorous thinkers were waging war against Reason and surrealist snipers, infiltrated behind enemy lines, were attacking the command posts of Logic with "miraculous weapons" from Asia and Africa. Actually, orientalists and ethnologists had piled them up in museums and libraries since the end of the 19th century. They were our masters, who saved us from despair by revealing our own riches to us. No!, we went off looking for our true masters in the heart of Africa, in the court of princes and in family wakes, even into the Wise Men's furthest retreats. They were the wandering singers and the sorcerers, those that are called "masters-of-the-head" over there, or better still, "clairvoyants". (13)
Right from the end of the 30's, Senghor and Césaire tackled the question of autonomous singular black creation. A creation that would get rid of colonialist supervision on the one hand and bring about the synthesis of its history on the other. Edouard Glissant wondered (14) about this problematic that is common to all colonised peoples. How to sort through the complex heritage that clutters up memories? How to make allowances? Many years earlier, Césaire had already answered these questions by asserting that "as long as the West Indians don't accept the reality of history, which assumes accepting slavery, they will be incapable of existing"(15). During the post-war years the Blacks fought to follow that path. After 1945, studios run by European painters flourished in Africa and in the Caribbean. They had decided to preach the good word of art to people that had been scorned up till then. Against their will, they nonetheless brought with them techniques and references whose adaptation on black soil was very risky. A new revolution was needed in the 70's for artists to become massively aware that the Greek model was null and void and obviously obsolete everywhere else, and therein decide to construct a language that would be their very own.
Thence comes a problem of definition: what reality can cover the term African contemporary art? At first we are tempted to reply: all productions from Africa or original artists from the continent. This initial point of view obviously limits the field of investigation and reduces the spheres of influence by confining this domain to Africa alone, forbidding interest in artists whose histories may be less obvious but are no less rooted in the black continent. The political and ideological evolution of these regions actually contains many similarities which make any attempt at differentiation futile. Now is not the time for arbitrary fragmentation and sterile distributions. A time for unity is upon us - not political unity, looking for a utopian African nationality, but a historical and intellectual reconciliation.
It rapidly became clear that these different sensitivities were gathered round one idea - the notion of memory. An inalienable, unshakeable memory. As though, having followed diverging paths, these sources of inspiration found a common meeting ground. The stories told through African or Caribbean works are intimately connected together, like different fruit on the same tree. All you have to do is dig down a little to find the spot where memory becomes an aesthetic research that leads to different results, or even opposing ones. Creators who have shared the same cradle have to confront the same problems in their respective countries. The way I see it, they represent the only possible modernity. Brought up here or there, living somewhere else, they had to assimilate the other's thought and language and make it their own. They had to look and understand. And the translation of this virtually initiatory progression results, for most finished works, in a modern cosmogony where nothing is excluded. A cosmogony they were forced to dream up in the ruins of a country, a continent, a history that is theirs yet also someone else's. The question of self-assertion that underlay all the demands of negritude has been abolished by the quest for a real synthesis, a harmonious symbiosis which would not try to separate the contributions in some kind of schizophrenic exercise. To refuse history; in a word, to refuse life. And if it is true that you can never rewrite history, at least they still have the hope of writing new pages, here and now.
Translated by Gail de Courcy-Ireland
Articles about African Art since 1949
1949 - First Published
West African Pilot, May 1949
THE EVOLUTION, HISTORY AND DEFINITION OF FINE ART
Author: Ben Enwonwu
I should ask the gods of my ancestors to tell me what art is and for what purpose it exists. It is easy to talk about painting and sculpture, or architecture, music and other forms of art but it is not so easy to discuss fully what constitute their natures and qualities. The question What is Art? has been widely discussed by artists, philosophers, and art critics but many aspects of it have merely been explained away. It is also a question for which no cut-and-dry definition has yet been offered, nor would any if offered, be adequate. Through aesthetic experiences and constant application of thought to art, writers on art have been able to offer different aspects of the answers which may serve as an adequate definition of art.
LANGUAGE OF ART
But very often the language of art employed is misunderstood, or else, taken for granted. One of the reasons for that misconception of written documents memoirs on art being of course that the eloquence of a work of art is beyond verbal interpretation. The most effective language of a work of art is its quality, which speaks for itself. Some people can react to the effect of the quality of a work of art, others cannot but this is a matter of sensitivity and education to an appreciation of the work of the human hand.
People with good taste are apt to wonder why it is that what they admire in works of art are not easy for others to grasp. A man of good taste may like certain qualities in a work of art for certain reasons, no matter whether those qualities recall to his memory what he had experienced in life or not. He likes those qualities simply because they appeal to him.
To be able to admire certain qualities in a work of art in this way, is to begin to discover for oneself, what art really is.
ART CONNOISSEURS
But, of course, some men of taste take art objects for granted as historical and fashionable documents. Usually, a class of aristocratic or bourgeoisie art connoisseurs spring up in a society, who are themselves genuine and ardent admirers of the beautiful. They would be classified as people who understand art. There is no question that they do, when it comes to the fact that they are the precursors of what society is to acclaim and emulate. But quite often, these art enthusiasts have no independent judgement and criticism of art based on justifiable aesthetic concepts. Art has suffered under the patronage of aristocracy which is the least criterion for assessing artistic merits and demerits. It is equally true that such patronage has promoted artistic creativity, but only materially. This is a matter of history.
ELEGANT TASTE
Does the criterion for artistic judgement therefore depend on standards set by aristocracy and elegant taste, or does it depend on the nature and types of human races, who have so produced, as it were, not one art but many? Are beautiful paintings, beautiful buildings and beautiful sculptures necessarily art? Are works produced merely for purposes of the representation of things in nature and for decorum? Has man`s whole spirit and soul been wrapped up with the idea of building monumental copies of natural phenomena, and of creating great artistic impressibilities as a result of his reaction to impulse? If not, what is art, and for what purpose does it exist? Is what prompts artistic creativity art? Or, is what transforms a piece of wood or canvas, or even sounds into that, what has given life and concrete meaning, art?
I should now begin to seek answers to all these questions, and then try to explore the nature and types of human arts for upon the answers to such questions would depend what I would contend to be, a clear definition of art.
COPY NATURE
Art is not the human activity which aims at the creation of beautiful things. By this, I do not exclude elements of beauty, or beauty itself, from the qualities which a work of art must embody but such a hypothesis bridges the gap between art, as a reality, which is not visible nor tangible, and art as a human activity, the product of which we know as a work of art.
When critics of art discuss the subjects of art, they generally do not talk how clever the artist is, how he has copied nature or imitated her, nor even how nearer to nature the colours in a painting are. They, the critics of art, talk about artistic qualities which do not necessarily recall to mind what had been seen before that is, those eternal qualities which know neither time nor space.
TOLSTOY SPEAKS
To value a work of art, says Tolstoy, by the degree of realism or by the accuracy of the details is as strange as to judge of the nutritive quality of food by its external appearance. When we appraise a work of art according to its realism, we only show that we are talking, not of art, but of its counterfeit.
Most people admire what recalls things of sentimental value, or expect to find such things in a work of art and when such things do not exist in a work of art, they think that the work of art is either crude or not even art at all.
Others expect to find in a work of art and the function it performs, records of history and great deeds. It is in fact, one of the functions of art to record history: to tell the story of man`s intellectual and mental development in time and space, but such stories which a work of art does tell, are but its descriptive qualities, which must be subjected to greater qualities that are aesthetic in essence. Eugene Delacroix once said to Baudelaire:
The visible world is only a shop full of images and signs to which imagination gives relative value and place. It is a kind of pasture – land which imagination should order and transform. All the faculties of human soul should be subordinated to the imagination which uses them simultaneously.
A genius creates his own method he has no other a true artist is born to pick and choose, and group with intelligence, elements in nature, so that the result may be as beautiful as the musicians gathers his notes and forms his chords, until he brings forth from chaos, glorious harmony. To know what art is, one must know the human mind.
ART LOVERS
Most art lovers do not like to feel that beauty is not automatically implied when the word ART is mentioned. So that to them, it would seem quite aesthetically incoherent to call what seem an ugly object of art, beautiful. Unlike the Hellenic standards up to, and after the Renaissance, the classic theory of beauty conformed to realism and photographic verisimilitude. It is the meaning of art, and the purpose for which it exists, that justifies shapes, colours, or designs in a work of art.
Unless the meaning of a thing is understood, it is difficult to appreciate that thing in any reasonable sense. It is easy to misunderstand it, or take it for granted. One of the qualities which a work of art has, is its power to attract attention and to make an appeal. By this means, what the artist has communicated or had expressed, and the significance of his interpretations, become part and parcel of his medium or material, which is merely a means by which ART is born.
ACTIVITY OF MAN
Art is therefore not a quality of things, but an activity of man. Beautiful lines in a drawing, or beautiful colours in painting or beautiful shapes in a piece of sculpture, are not at all ART. Art does not imply good colours, lines and shapes, not do these make up Art.
DEFINITIONS
Thinkers, philosophers, and artists, have offered varied definitions of art, its manifestations and its functions. Apart from the fact that art gives pleasure, it also fulfils other functions which are as important as living itself.
Art elevates the human mind, sublimates his base emotions, and cultivates his sense to be more sensitive to the finer things of life. Art gives peace and vitality to the human mind and soul and as children are to women of whom they are born, so is art to its creator, the artistic genius. To cultivate ones mind so that art may speak, is to raise oneself above the level of the animal kingdom it is to give freedom to man`s spirit which is the real joy of life.
VERNON`S VIEW
But I am limiting art to painting and sculpture in the sense as Vernon would contend, that art is essentially the expression of emotion. Great music cannot exist if it does not express emotion. And in painting, it does not matter if colours are not rich and harmonious. Degas, the impressionist and Cezanne, both painted in entirely different styles. Degas` colours were rich and characteristic of the impressionist school whereas, Cezanne sometimes, and quite often used dirty muddy colours but the unity, and vitality which his work conveys, are what critics call art in its entirety. Thus a work of art is complete, and nothing is left out, if even the absence of luscious colours predominate.
HUMAN EMOTION
Tolstoy`s definition of art emphasises the transmission of the human emotion as the essence of art. Here, there is justification for the interpretations and the ideas which artists like Mark Ernst, Paul Klee, Duchamp, and others of the DADAIST group show in their works. Although the platonic theories of art, as the Imitative and the Representational, or the Aristotelian speculations on the mimetic impulse have prevailed, other theories like Schiller or Karl Groos whose views are equally acceptable, have added to man`s aesthetic discoveries. While Plato and Aristotle upheld the view that art must represent what the eyes have seen, and this idea prevailed throughout the immense period of art history, and was used to a very great extent by the Greeks and the Europeans, Schiller`s play theory of art has explored other aspects of art, which had never occurred to philosophers of his time and before.
FREE EMOTION
The imagination of man, says Schiller, like his corporeal organs has also its free emotion and its material play, in which it merely enjoys its native power and liberty without reference to shape or colour. This play of the imagination consists in a free, unconstrained flow of images, which, because of the absence of form, is not yet aesthetic. But from this free play of ideas, the imagination makes, at length, a leap to aesthetic play. An entirely new power comes here into requisition for the directing spirit at first interfering in the operations of blind instinct, subjects the arbitrary process of the imagination to its immutable eternal quality. Art, in other words, is born when taste, asserting itself, imposes upon the products of the free play of man`s imagination.
Schiller`s analogy of the manifestations of art in the human imagination pre- supposes an answer to the question What is Art? From this point, the essential features of art begin to show themselves in positive terms. At this, I should contend that art, in the broadcast sense of the terms, is the human activity which is consciously so controlled as to produce a result satisfying some specified condition. I use the term specified in the sense that the artist/s free play of imagination helps, or does not hinder the ultimate creation of a desired effect which is the aim of Art be that effect one of fear, or joy, of the mysterious, or even of death and horrors – so long as the artist had been impulsed to infuse an effect into his image-making propensity.
In this sense, also, it would be reasonable to state that the germ of artistic creativity is that which differentiates man`s artistic expressions from the dim adumbrations of animal art. It follows, as the trend of art history has shown, that in its entirety, Art has been produced by man from the pre-historic times to the present and that there can be no logical argument denying the fact that what man had produced when he lived under primitive conditions, inspired by fear or imbued with taboo and superstition, is still great, if it was acknowledged so to be when compared with Art which he now produces as a civilized or cultivated man.
ARTISTIC CREATION
The capacity for artistic creation of the early man whose environment differs from ours is no less inducive to the production of great art as that of the man of the middle ages, or man of the Renaissance, and even modern man. It is only the treatment of the material which the artist employs as an agent, that is different itself, a product of science or industry or of nature, but not of Art – is a matter of studies and experience. The telic activities which I have stated can be classified in such positive terms so as to state quite categorically the extent to which the effect a world of Art has is a direct result of the manifestation of Art in the human imagination and vice versa.
SPECIES OF ART
I should divide Art into two species – the Ectotelic and the Endotelic. Ectotelic art may be defined as utilitarian or skilled work and Endotelic Art which is skilled self-objectifictation is the one with which I am essentially concerned. What the positive end of endotelic Art seeks is objectification of the artist`s beliefs, his feelings, meanings or significances, and volitions. The Art which is endotelic consists in conscious or subconscious, critically controlled, objectification of self or equivalently, in consciously objective self-expression.
OBJECTIFICATION
It does not imply that the feeling, meaning, or significance and volition, which may be expressed in a material that the artist uses, or call it his medium which renders observation and admiration by the artist and others possible, is meant when objectification is addressed to artistic creativity. Objectification is usually mentioned in personal stuff but it plays its role in Art in distinct image-stuff that is to say, the interplay of both material and thought, is the result of a conscious creative activity of the artist. In this sense, self-objectification remains private to the artist. It is easy to see that the image stuff has a limit, where it meets with the realm of perpetual-stuff. The latter is what objectification denotes. However, the image-stuff as a medium of artistic creativity or expression, remains empirical.
IMAGE-STUFF
Theoretically, image-stuff is possible stuff for self-objectification in so far as it does not encroach upon perceptual objectivity. Let me be more explicit – the expression in a work of Art which is a quality, is creative of something i.e. capable of being contemplated by the artist and others as well. But this is not the meaning of self-objectification.
The expression, as objective is such that in contemplation of some quality in a world of Art, it yields back to the artist`s feeling, meaning, or significance and volition, of which it was the attempted expression. Thus, an artist paints a picture or carves a figure and in desolation or dissatisfaction, destroys the work he has done because he knows that he has failed to express what he wanted. He would say, on contemplating his work, Yes, that is what I meant, or sometimes, No, that is not what I meant, if on the contrary, according as the extent to which self- objectification has manifested itself in terms of expression.
The artist may get rid of the impulse to express something, but that something may not rid him of it by objectifying it. Unsuccessful attempts at objective self-expression can only be noted, by contemplating the products – the works of Art. By obtaining back to the observer of the work, or by the artist, of what has been attempted to express, is the only proof as to the meaning of self- objectification. Objectification is a means and not an end but it is also the meaning of a work of Art, otherwise creative Art would be essentially not endotelic but ectotelic.
SELF-EXPRESSION
Artistic creativity is the act of self-expression. The act of self-expression is blind to accuracy or definite form unless it has been tutored – that is to say, the expression which the work thus produced possesses, is bound to be native, whenever expression is something original or new unless the technique is good enough. This does not deny the fact of its power or its vitality. The point I am trying to make is that when a child draws something, self-objectification remains a matter of guesswork, and in most cases, never occurs. Until he has learnt the Art and the craft, he cannot develop a sense of critical analysis. So it is with a clever draughtsman on the other hand, whose technique is superior to his capacity for self-expression, and self-objectification. Such blind acts never pass objectivity in the sense of that term, for the work produced would have no purpose except that which is purely biological or utilitarian.
DYNAMIC FORCES
Art is not merely self-expression but objective self-expression in the act of which it must be a conscious effort, only permissible of un-self consciousness in cases of primeval Art when self-objectification has been canalised into some definite purpose, categorized in various, though interrelated mechanisms as part and parcel of other dynamic forces that exist in the human society. I speak of the so-called primitive Art of which some critics of Art have described as unconscious self- objectification. Primitive Art is self-conscious, because the artist, either before or during the act of its creation, was conscious of certain elements which were to play a role in the artist`s creations he was aware of being aware, that certain elements were playing a part the question of the time when such elements became a part of the work produced is irrelevant.
Every artist, no matter what race, country, or epoch has been endowed with gifts such as capacity for artistic contemplation in word, that thing which he creates yields back to his feeling, meaning or significance and volition of which the work was the attempted expression.
PASSING THE TEST
Art is not only capable of passing the test of conscious objectivity but must have passed it before successful work is done. This means that a work of art is finished before it begun. The artist must have conceived an image of a thing before actually making it a concrete thing – a work of art. Consciousness of the act is gained by contemplation of the product, i.e. judgment as to whether or not the work truly mirrors back what Wassily Kandisky calls the inner klang.
The conscious objectification of the artist`s feeling belongs to the realm of aesthetics. Here the reason for calling Art Fine Art which is an ambiguous term crops up. The implication which the term Fine Art carries has implied, on many occasions, that Art so referred to, is an activity essentially concerned with the production of something beautiful. This, of course, is false and a wrong view of the nature of Art, as has already been pointed out in the earlier part of this article. Any activity of which the deliberate and ultimate aim is to produce something beautiful is Ectotelic Art i.e. skilled work, crafts. A craft work may be beautiful or lovely but that is its ultimate aim it does not reveal the maker`s imagination to question. As long as the eye beholds is as something attractive and `fine` or beautiful, it has performed its function.
ENDOTELIC ART
The definition of Endotelic Art or Aesthetic Art is wholly independent of the notion of the beautiful. This does not mean that its product must or must not lack beautiful lines, and beautiful colours, and beautiful forms. It only means that Art the products of which are things pre-conceived, is true to the precepts of the images thus created in concrete form.
The word aesthetic is used at random and is applied even to the emotion which an American saloon can evoke on the mind – the steam lines! Sometimes the workd is used in its etymological sense – meaning perceptible. When the etymological sense of the word is conjoined with ethnography, the word is used to standardize works produced by man living under primitive conditions or else the work of the pre-historic man.
PURE REASON
Kant`s first part of his Critique of Pure Reason dealt with aesthetics as if it has only to do with perception. Thus the word as I have stated above has been used to make all sorts of distinct enquiries such as the philosophy of beauty and empirical investigations of the characters and qualities which objects of art should possess, and then judged by standards established by society, based on beautiful things or persons, correct angles or rectangles, and anatomical proportions and so on.
Some Art critics have not resisted the temptation to judge some works of Art on such basis. But great critics of Art like John Ruskin, Herbert Read, Morris Collis and Eric Newton, would judge Art from a wider angle according as Art has satisfied all aesthetic canons. Any object may be called beautiful when, or in so far as, the feelings which one obtained in the aesthetic contemplation of it are pleasurable feelings. A beautiful object therefore may be, but need not be, a work of Art and a work of art may be, but need not be, beautiful. Beauty, being purely a matter of the sort of feeling that an object gives us in contemplation, remains wholly independent of the manner whether artificial or natural in which the object itself came into existence. On the other hand, a work of Aesthetic Art, being simply the consciously achieved objectification of a feeling, will not be beautiful unless the feeling objectified in it and reflected by it in contemplation, is a pleasurable feeling.
A mask can be a work of art if it is a successful attempt to imprison an idea or express an idea in terms of wood, and if it reflects such ideals or ideas by the effect of its shape, be they repellent or pleasurable to the onlooker. If the mask represents a goddess it could be a model of beauty in so far as the same ideal and the ideas that made the perpetual stuff possible of achievement, is triumphant. A realistic painting could be beautiful, but not a work of Art. The masks created by our ancestors are not only beautiful, but are highly sophisticated masterpieces.
The essay continues by discussing the nature of Negro African Art.
West African Pilot, May 1949
THE EVOLUTION, HISTORY AND DEFINITION OF FINE ART
Author: Ben Enwonwu
I should ask the gods of my ancestors to tell me what art is and for what purpose it exists. It is easy to talk about painting and sculpture, or architecture, music and other forms of art but it is not so easy to discuss fully what constitute their natures and qualities. The question What is Art? has been widely discussed by artists, philosophers, and art critics but many aspects of it have merely been explained away. It is also a question for which no cut-and-dry definition has yet been offered, nor would any if offered, be adequate. Through aesthetic experiences and constant application of thought to art, writers on art have been able to offer different aspects of the answers which may serve as an adequate definition of art.
LANGUAGE OF ART
But very often the language of art employed is misunderstood, or else, taken for granted. One of the reasons for that misconception of written documents memoirs on art being of course that the eloquence of a work of art is beyond verbal interpretation. The most effective language of a work of art is its quality, which speaks for itself. Some people can react to the effect of the quality of a work of art, others cannot but this is a matter of sensitivity and education to an appreciation of the work of the human hand.
People with good taste are apt to wonder why it is that what they admire in works of art are not easy for others to grasp. A man of good taste may like certain qualities in a work of art for certain reasons, no matter whether those qualities recall to his memory what he had experienced in life or not. He likes those qualities simply because they appeal to him.
To be able to admire certain qualities in a work of art in this way, is to begin to discover for oneself, what art really is.
ART CONNOISSEURS
But, of course, some men of taste take art objects for granted as historical and fashionable documents. Usually, a class of aristocratic or bourgeoisie art connoisseurs spring up in a society, who are themselves genuine and ardent admirers of the beautiful. They would be classified as people who understand art. There is no question that they do, when it comes to the fact that they are the precursors of what society is to acclaim and emulate. But quite often, these art enthusiasts have no independent judgement and criticism of art based on justifiable aesthetic concepts. Art has suffered under the patronage of aristocracy which is the least criterion for assessing artistic merits and demerits. It is equally true that such patronage has promoted artistic creativity, but only materially. This is a matter of history.
ELEGANT TASTE
Does the criterion for artistic judgement therefore depend on standards set by aristocracy and elegant taste, or does it depend on the nature and types of human races, who have so produced, as it were, not one art but many? Are beautiful paintings, beautiful buildings and beautiful sculptures necessarily art? Are works produced merely for purposes of the representation of things in nature and for decorum? Has man`s whole spirit and soul been wrapped up with the idea of building monumental copies of natural phenomena, and of creating great artistic impressibilities as a result of his reaction to impulse? If not, what is art, and for what purpose does it exist? Is what prompts artistic creativity art? Or, is what transforms a piece of wood or canvas, or even sounds into that, what has given life and concrete meaning, art?
I should now begin to seek answers to all these questions, and then try to explore the nature and types of human arts for upon the answers to such questions would depend what I would contend to be, a clear definition of art.
COPY NATURE
Art is not the human activity which aims at the creation of beautiful things. By this, I do not exclude elements of beauty, or beauty itself, from the qualities which a work of art must embody but such a hypothesis bridges the gap between art, as a reality, which is not visible nor tangible, and art as a human activity, the product of which we know as a work of art.
When critics of art discuss the subjects of art, they generally do not talk how clever the artist is, how he has copied nature or imitated her, nor even how nearer to nature the colours in a painting are. They, the critics of art, talk about artistic qualities which do not necessarily recall to mind what had been seen before that is, those eternal qualities which know neither time nor space.
TOLSTOY SPEAKS
To value a work of art, says Tolstoy, by the degree of realism or by the accuracy of the details is as strange as to judge of the nutritive quality of food by its external appearance. When we appraise a work of art according to its realism, we only show that we are talking, not of art, but of its counterfeit.
Most people admire what recalls things of sentimental value, or expect to find such things in a work of art and when such things do not exist in a work of art, they think that the work of art is either crude or not even art at all.
Others expect to find in a work of art and the function it performs, records of history and great deeds. It is in fact, one of the functions of art to record history: to tell the story of man`s intellectual and mental development in time and space, but such stories which a work of art does tell, are but its descriptive qualities, which must be subjected to greater qualities that are aesthetic in essence. Eugene Delacroix once said to Baudelaire:
The visible world is only a shop full of images and signs to which imagination gives relative value and place. It is a kind of pasture – land which imagination should order and transform. All the faculties of human soul should be subordinated to the imagination which uses them simultaneously.
A genius creates his own method he has no other a true artist is born to pick and choose, and group with intelligence, elements in nature, so that the result may be as beautiful as the musicians gathers his notes and forms his chords, until he brings forth from chaos, glorious harmony. To know what art is, one must know the human mind.
ART LOVERS
Most art lovers do not like to feel that beauty is not automatically implied when the word ART is mentioned. So that to them, it would seem quite aesthetically incoherent to call what seem an ugly object of art, beautiful. Unlike the Hellenic standards up to, and after the Renaissance, the classic theory of beauty conformed to realism and photographic verisimilitude. It is the meaning of art, and the purpose for which it exists, that justifies shapes, colours, or designs in a work of art.
Unless the meaning of a thing is understood, it is difficult to appreciate that thing in any reasonable sense. It is easy to misunderstand it, or take it for granted. One of the qualities which a work of art has, is its power to attract attention and to make an appeal. By this means, what the artist has communicated or had expressed, and the significance of his interpretations, become part and parcel of his medium or material, which is merely a means by which ART is born.
ACTIVITY OF MAN
Art is therefore not a quality of things, but an activity of man. Beautiful lines in a drawing, or beautiful colours in painting or beautiful shapes in a piece of sculpture, are not at all ART. Art does not imply good colours, lines and shapes, not do these make up Art.
DEFINITIONS
Thinkers, philosophers, and artists, have offered varied definitions of art, its manifestations and its functions. Apart from the fact that art gives pleasure, it also fulfils other functions which are as important as living itself.
Art elevates the human mind, sublimates his base emotions, and cultivates his sense to be more sensitive to the finer things of life. Art gives peace and vitality to the human mind and soul and as children are to women of whom they are born, so is art to its creator, the artistic genius. To cultivate ones mind so that art may speak, is to raise oneself above the level of the animal kingdom it is to give freedom to man`s spirit which is the real joy of life.
VERNON`S VIEW
But I am limiting art to painting and sculpture in the sense as Vernon would contend, that art is essentially the expression of emotion. Great music cannot exist if it does not express emotion. And in painting, it does not matter if colours are not rich and harmonious. Degas, the impressionist and Cezanne, both painted in entirely different styles. Degas` colours were rich and characteristic of the impressionist school whereas, Cezanne sometimes, and quite often used dirty muddy colours but the unity, and vitality which his work conveys, are what critics call art in its entirety. Thus a work of art is complete, and nothing is left out, if even the absence of luscious colours predominate.
HUMAN EMOTION
Tolstoy`s definition of art emphasises the transmission of the human emotion as the essence of art. Here, there is justification for the interpretations and the ideas which artists like Mark Ernst, Paul Klee, Duchamp, and others of the DADAIST group show in their works. Although the platonic theories of art, as the Imitative and the Representational, or the Aristotelian speculations on the mimetic impulse have prevailed, other theories like Schiller or Karl Groos whose views are equally acceptable, have added to man`s aesthetic discoveries. While Plato and Aristotle upheld the view that art must represent what the eyes have seen, and this idea prevailed throughout the immense period of art history, and was used to a very great extent by the Greeks and the Europeans, Schiller`s play theory of art has explored other aspects of art, which had never occurred to philosophers of his time and before.
FREE EMOTION
The imagination of man, says Schiller, like his corporeal organs has also its free emotion and its material play, in which it merely enjoys its native power and liberty without reference to shape or colour. This play of the imagination consists in a free, unconstrained flow of images, which, because of the absence of form, is not yet aesthetic. But from this free play of ideas, the imagination makes, at length, a leap to aesthetic play. An entirely new power comes here into requisition for the directing spirit at first interfering in the operations of blind instinct, subjects the arbitrary process of the imagination to its immutable eternal quality. Art, in other words, is born when taste, asserting itself, imposes upon the products of the free play of man`s imagination.
Schiller`s analogy of the manifestations of art in the human imagination pre- supposes an answer to the question What is Art? From this point, the essential features of art begin to show themselves in positive terms. At this, I should contend that art, in the broadcast sense of the terms, is the human activity which is consciously so controlled as to produce a result satisfying some specified condition. I use the term specified in the sense that the artist/s free play of imagination helps, or does not hinder the ultimate creation of a desired effect which is the aim of Art be that effect one of fear, or joy, of the mysterious, or even of death and horrors – so long as the artist had been impulsed to infuse an effect into his image-making propensity.
In this sense, also, it would be reasonable to state that the germ of artistic creativity is that which differentiates man`s artistic expressions from the dim adumbrations of animal art. It follows, as the trend of art history has shown, that in its entirety, Art has been produced by man from the pre-historic times to the present and that there can be no logical argument denying the fact that what man had produced when he lived under primitive conditions, inspired by fear or imbued with taboo and superstition, is still great, if it was acknowledged so to be when compared with Art which he now produces as a civilized or cultivated man.
ARTISTIC CREATION
The capacity for artistic creation of the early man whose environment differs from ours is no less inducive to the production of great art as that of the man of the middle ages, or man of the Renaissance, and even modern man. It is only the treatment of the material which the artist employs as an agent, that is different itself, a product of science or industry or of nature, but not of Art – is a matter of studies and experience. The telic activities which I have stated can be classified in such positive terms so as to state quite categorically the extent to which the effect a world of Art has is a direct result of the manifestation of Art in the human imagination and vice versa.
SPECIES OF ART
I should divide Art into two species – the Ectotelic and the Endotelic. Ectotelic art may be defined as utilitarian or skilled work and Endotelic Art which is skilled self-objectifictation is the one with which I am essentially concerned. What the positive end of endotelic Art seeks is objectification of the artist`s beliefs, his feelings, meanings or significances, and volitions. The Art which is endotelic consists in conscious or subconscious, critically controlled, objectification of self or equivalently, in consciously objective self-expression.
OBJECTIFICATION
It does not imply that the feeling, meaning, or significance and volition, which may be expressed in a material that the artist uses, or call it his medium which renders observation and admiration by the artist and others possible, is meant when objectification is addressed to artistic creativity. Objectification is usually mentioned in personal stuff but it plays its role in Art in distinct image-stuff that is to say, the interplay of both material and thought, is the result of a conscious creative activity of the artist. In this sense, self-objectification remains private to the artist. It is easy to see that the image stuff has a limit, where it meets with the realm of perpetual-stuff. The latter is what objectification denotes. However, the image-stuff as a medium of artistic creativity or expression, remains empirical.
IMAGE-STUFF
Theoretically, image-stuff is possible stuff for self-objectification in so far as it does not encroach upon perceptual objectivity. Let me be more explicit – the expression in a work of Art which is a quality, is creative of something i.e. capable of being contemplated by the artist and others as well. But this is not the meaning of self-objectification.
The expression, as objective is such that in contemplation of some quality in a world of Art, it yields back to the artist`s feeling, meaning, or significance and volition, of which it was the attempted expression. Thus, an artist paints a picture or carves a figure and in desolation or dissatisfaction, destroys the work he has done because he knows that he has failed to express what he wanted. He would say, on contemplating his work, Yes, that is what I meant, or sometimes, No, that is not what I meant, if on the contrary, according as the extent to which self- objectification has manifested itself in terms of expression.
The artist may get rid of the impulse to express something, but that something may not rid him of it by objectifying it. Unsuccessful attempts at objective self-expression can only be noted, by contemplating the products – the works of Art. By obtaining back to the observer of the work, or by the artist, of what has been attempted to express, is the only proof as to the meaning of self- objectification. Objectification is a means and not an end but it is also the meaning of a work of Art, otherwise creative Art would be essentially not endotelic but ectotelic.
SELF-EXPRESSION
Artistic creativity is the act of self-expression. The act of self-expression is blind to accuracy or definite form unless it has been tutored – that is to say, the expression which the work thus produced possesses, is bound to be native, whenever expression is something original or new unless the technique is good enough. This does not deny the fact of its power or its vitality. The point I am trying to make is that when a child draws something, self-objectification remains a matter of guesswork, and in most cases, never occurs. Until he has learnt the Art and the craft, he cannot develop a sense of critical analysis. So it is with a clever draughtsman on the other hand, whose technique is superior to his capacity for self-expression, and self-objectification. Such blind acts never pass objectivity in the sense of that term, for the work produced would have no purpose except that which is purely biological or utilitarian.
DYNAMIC FORCES
Art is not merely self-expression but objective self-expression in the act of which it must be a conscious effort, only permissible of un-self consciousness in cases of primeval Art when self-objectification has been canalised into some definite purpose, categorized in various, though interrelated mechanisms as part and parcel of other dynamic forces that exist in the human society. I speak of the so-called primitive Art of which some critics of Art have described as unconscious self- objectification. Primitive Art is self-conscious, because the artist, either before or during the act of its creation, was conscious of certain elements which were to play a role in the artist`s creations he was aware of being aware, that certain elements were playing a part the question of the time when such elements became a part of the work produced is irrelevant.
Every artist, no matter what race, country, or epoch has been endowed with gifts such as capacity for artistic contemplation in word, that thing which he creates yields back to his feeling, meaning or significance and volition of which the work was the attempted expression.
PASSING THE TEST
Art is not only capable of passing the test of conscious objectivity but must have passed it before successful work is done. This means that a work of art is finished before it begun. The artist must have conceived an image of a thing before actually making it a concrete thing – a work of art. Consciousness of the act is gained by contemplation of the product, i.e. judgment as to whether or not the work truly mirrors back what Wassily Kandisky calls the inner klang.
The conscious objectification of the artist`s feeling belongs to the realm of aesthetics. Here the reason for calling Art Fine Art which is an ambiguous term crops up. The implication which the term Fine Art carries has implied, on many occasions, that Art so referred to, is an activity essentially concerned with the production of something beautiful. This, of course, is false and a wrong view of the nature of Art, as has already been pointed out in the earlier part of this article. Any activity of which the deliberate and ultimate aim is to produce something beautiful is Ectotelic Art i.e. skilled work, crafts. A craft work may be beautiful or lovely but that is its ultimate aim it does not reveal the maker`s imagination to question. As long as the eye beholds is as something attractive and `fine` or beautiful, it has performed its function.
ENDOTELIC ART
The definition of Endotelic Art or Aesthetic Art is wholly independent of the notion of the beautiful. This does not mean that its product must or must not lack beautiful lines, and beautiful colours, and beautiful forms. It only means that Art the products of which are things pre-conceived, is true to the precepts of the images thus created in concrete form.
The word aesthetic is used at random and is applied even to the emotion which an American saloon can evoke on the mind – the steam lines! Sometimes the workd is used in its etymological sense – meaning perceptible. When the etymological sense of the word is conjoined with ethnography, the word is used to standardize works produced by man living under primitive conditions or else the work of the pre-historic man.
PURE REASON
Kant`s first part of his Critique of Pure Reason dealt with aesthetics as if it has only to do with perception. Thus the word as I have stated above has been used to make all sorts of distinct enquiries such as the philosophy of beauty and empirical investigations of the characters and qualities which objects of art should possess, and then judged by standards established by society, based on beautiful things or persons, correct angles or rectangles, and anatomical proportions and so on.
Some Art critics have not resisted the temptation to judge some works of Art on such basis. But great critics of Art like John Ruskin, Herbert Read, Morris Collis and Eric Newton, would judge Art from a wider angle according as Art has satisfied all aesthetic canons. Any object may be called beautiful when, or in so far as, the feelings which one obtained in the aesthetic contemplation of it are pleasurable feelings. A beautiful object therefore may be, but need not be, a work of Art and a work of art may be, but need not be, beautiful. Beauty, being purely a matter of the sort of feeling that an object gives us in contemplation, remains wholly independent of the manner whether artificial or natural in which the object itself came into existence. On the other hand, a work of Aesthetic Art, being simply the consciously achieved objectification of a feeling, will not be beautiful unless the feeling objectified in it and reflected by it in contemplation, is a pleasurable feeling.
A mask can be a work of art if it is a successful attempt to imprison an idea or express an idea in terms of wood, and if it reflects such ideals or ideas by the effect of its shape, be they repellent or pleasurable to the onlooker. If the mask represents a goddess it could be a model of beauty in so far as the same ideal and the ideas that made the perpetual stuff possible of achievement, is triumphant. A realistic painting could be beautiful, but not a work of Art. The masks created by our ancestors are not only beautiful, but are highly sophisticated masterpieces.
The essay continues by discussing the nature of Negro African Art.
Saturday, November 25, 2006
Lilian Nabulime | Sculptor | Uganda
Lilian Nabulime
Artists Statement:
I want women to be emancipated through Art. A lot of women are illiterate. When you just talk or give them literature they won`t understand. Through Art, women can be educated. If more women artists come up and produce Art with strong messages to liberate, educate both women and men, the struggle will be faster. Through Art, one can effectively communicate social/political messages across a diversity of tribes with languages and cultural bases. Art can transcend the temporal limits of languages and speech, and that`s the challenge I would like to portray in my sculptures. Lilian Nabulime
Lilian Nabulime is one of the few female sculptors in Uganda. Born in Kampala in 1963 she graduated as Master of Fine Arts from Makerere University. Although young, Nabulime has indeed found her strengths.
She currently works on a combination of wood and sheet metal, producing monumental sculptures. Carving tree stumps has become her trademark. She selects the trunk searching for a motif from the stump. This she eventually teases out with her hammer and chisel, often making elongated, elegant sculptures, mainly women heads. Also characteristic for her sculptures is a dynamic, organic rhythm that follows the grain and growth pattern of the tree and often produces a sensation of spiral movement. She has a respect for the integrity of the trees natural form she carves. Her approach to sculpture is basically African in its intuitiveness.
Statement by Lilian in September 2001
I have enjoyed my life as an Artist mainly as a Sculptor carving wood. It had never crossed my mind that I would be a sculptor. When I embarked on my Master`s Degree, I was advised to offer sculpture because I had performed well at undergraduate level. I always knew I would proceed with painting, but today sculpture is my best form of expression. Once in a while I paint, do applique using various materials like barkcloth, textiles, jute, sisal and others.
During my masters program I worked on tree roots. It was a great experience. Prior to this roots were not valued, they were used for firewood or left to rot.
As I worked on them I discovered that they offered unique forms which had to be studied in order to derive artistic inspirations. Each root was unique because it grows under the ground where it found different obstacles which they fought and struggled with, ending up in different forms. Roots were very expressive, grotesque forms which infused me with strong emotions. With roots I often chose to distort and exaggerate the forms in order to express a particular message.
The experience with root sculptures enabled me to work on different forms of wood and use of various materials I came across. I enjoy incorporating metal on wood. I also work in other materials like clay, plaster of Paris and metal casting. My inspirations for sculptures are derived from nature, experiences, and people I meet.
Usually when I work, I have ideas in sketches and models. As I start carving wood, various ideas, messages creep into my mind and that calls for more sketches and more models leading to more sculptures. And this calls for time and space which I yearn for!
EXHIBITIONS
Women beyond Borders,
USA/other countries 1995
Africus, Johannesburg Biennale,
South Africa 1995
Uganda, the blossoming pearl of Africa art exhibition,
Brussels, 1997
May Fest. Women Exhibition,
Glasgow, UK 1997
Global Reflection,
United Nations Art Gallery, Bonn, Germany 1998
Progress of the World`s Women,
UN Conference, New York 2000
Global Women Project,
New York, USA 2000
Modern Art in Uganda,
CBK Het Kunstpaleis, Deventer, Netherlands 2000
African Women Exhibition,
Gallery Watatu, Nairobi, Kenya 2001
PhD at Newcastle University 2002-2005
Artists Statement:
I want women to be emancipated through Art. A lot of women are illiterate. When you just talk or give them literature they won`t understand. Through Art, women can be educated. If more women artists come up and produce Art with strong messages to liberate, educate both women and men, the struggle will be faster. Through Art, one can effectively communicate social/political messages across a diversity of tribes with languages and cultural bases. Art can transcend the temporal limits of languages and speech, and that`s the challenge I would like to portray in my sculptures. Lilian Nabulime
Lilian Nabulime is one of the few female sculptors in Uganda. Born in Kampala in 1963 she graduated as Master of Fine Arts from Makerere University. Although young, Nabulime has indeed found her strengths.
She currently works on a combination of wood and sheet metal, producing monumental sculptures. Carving tree stumps has become her trademark. She selects the trunk searching for a motif from the stump. This she eventually teases out with her hammer and chisel, often making elongated, elegant sculptures, mainly women heads. Also characteristic for her sculptures is a dynamic, organic rhythm that follows the grain and growth pattern of the tree and often produces a sensation of spiral movement. She has a respect for the integrity of the trees natural form she carves. Her approach to sculpture is basically African in its intuitiveness.
Statement by Lilian in September 2001
I have enjoyed my life as an Artist mainly as a Sculptor carving wood. It had never crossed my mind that I would be a sculptor. When I embarked on my Master`s Degree, I was advised to offer sculpture because I had performed well at undergraduate level. I always knew I would proceed with painting, but today sculpture is my best form of expression. Once in a while I paint, do applique using various materials like barkcloth, textiles, jute, sisal and others.
During my masters program I worked on tree roots. It was a great experience. Prior to this roots were not valued, they were used for firewood or left to rot.
As I worked on them I discovered that they offered unique forms which had to be studied in order to derive artistic inspirations. Each root was unique because it grows under the ground where it found different obstacles which they fought and struggled with, ending up in different forms. Roots were very expressive, grotesque forms which infused me with strong emotions. With roots I often chose to distort and exaggerate the forms in order to express a particular message.
The experience with root sculptures enabled me to work on different forms of wood and use of various materials I came across. I enjoy incorporating metal on wood. I also work in other materials like clay, plaster of Paris and metal casting. My inspirations for sculptures are derived from nature, experiences, and people I meet.
Usually when I work, I have ideas in sketches and models. As I start carving wood, various ideas, messages creep into my mind and that calls for more sketches and more models leading to more sculptures. And this calls for time and space which I yearn for!
EXHIBITIONS
Women beyond Borders,
USA/other countries 1995
Africus, Johannesburg Biennale,
South Africa 1995
Uganda, the blossoming pearl of Africa art exhibition,
Brussels, 1997
May Fest. Women Exhibition,
Glasgow, UK 1997
Global Reflection,
United Nations Art Gallery, Bonn, Germany 1998
Progress of the World`s Women,
UN Conference, New York 2000
Global Women Project,
New York, USA 2000
Modern Art in Uganda,
CBK Het Kunstpaleis, Deventer, Netherlands 2000
African Women Exhibition,
Gallery Watatu, Nairobi, Kenya 2001
PhD at Newcastle University 2002-2005
Jane Alexander | South African Artist

Jane Alexander
South Africa
b.1959 - Present
Image: African Adventure by Jane Alexander
Jane Alexander was born in Johannesburg in 1959. Her father’s family came from Berlin. Alexander studied art at the University of Witwatersrand, Johannesburg. She received her Bachelor of Fine Arts in 1982 and her Master’s degree in 1988. In 1982, she was awarded the University of Witwatersrand’s Martienssen Student Prize.
In 1987, Jane Alexander began teaching English in Namibia from 1988 till 1989, she taught art at a secondary school in Cape Town. Between 1990 and 1997, she worked periodically as a curator at the University of Cape Town’s Irma Stern Museum. Her international career began in 1994 with her participation at the Havana Biennale, followed by the Venice Biennale in 1995. In the same year, Jane Alexander also received the Standard Bank Young Artist Award, and a year later she won the FNB Vita Art Now Award. During 1996 and 1997, she taught part-time at the Michaelis School of Fine Art at the University of Cape Town. In 2000, she received the DaimlerChrysler Award for South African Sculpture
Jane Alexander lives and works in Cape Town. Besides working as a freelance artist, she also teaches sculpture, photography and drawing at the University of Cape Town’s Michaelis School of Fine Arts.
_________________________________________
Biography:
Group Exhibitions
Exhibition / Installation, 2000
1994
„5. Biennale von Havanna“, Ludwig Forum für zeitgenössische Kunst, Aachen
„Un Art contemporain d’Afrique du Sud“, Galerie d’Esplanade, La Defence, Paris
“5th Havana Biennial”, National Museum of Fine Arts et al., Havanna
“Xit, election exhibition”, South African Association of Arts, Metropolitan Life Gallery, Cape Town
1995
“Identita e Alterita”, Biennale di Venezia, Palazzo Grassi, Venice
1996
“Contemporary South African Art 85-95 from the South African National Gallery Permanent Collection”, South African National Gallery, Cape Town
“Fault Lines”, Castle of Good Hope, Cape Town
„Colours – Kunst aus Südafrika“, Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin
“First National Bank Vita Art Now”, Award Exhibition, Johannesburg Art Gallery
1997
“Lifetimes”, Out of Africa Kulturfestival, Munich
“South African Abhorrescence: End of the Century’s Artists”, Arts Festival Nantes
“Photosynthesis”, Standard Bank National Arts Festival, Grahamstown
1998
„Triennale der Kleinplastik“, Europa-Afrika, SüdwestLB Forum, Stuttgart
“Cape Town: Works on Paper”, Canberra Institute of the Arts
“Africa Africa”, Tobu Museum of Art, Tokyo
“Bringing up Baby”, The Castle of Good Hope, Kapstadt, Standard Bank Gallery, Grahamstown Arts Festival
“DAK’Art Biennale de l’art africain contemporain“, Dakar
“Showing and Telling“, Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation, Johannesburg
1999
“Global Art“, Galerie Seippel, Cologne
“South Meets West“, National Museum, Accra
“Emergence“, Albany Museum Grahamstown, Standard Bank Arts Festival
“Lines of Sight“, South African National Gallery, Cape Town
2000
“7th Havana Biennial“, Wilfredo Lam Centre, Havanna
“Voices of Southern Africa“, British Museum, London
“A.R.E.A. “, Kjarvalsstadir, Reykjavik
“Retreks:unSUNG City, How the other half…”, Kings Parkade, Eloff Street, Johannesburg
“Secure the Future: Care and Support for Women and Children with HIV/Aids in Africa”, fundraising exhibition of the international Aids Society Conference Durban, Washington D.C., Bruxelles, Boston
“partage d’exotismes/sharing exoticisms”, 5. Lyon Biennial
“Cross Currents: Contemporary Art Practice in South Africa”, Atkinson Gallery, Millfield School, Somerset
„South Meets West“, Kunsthalle Bern und Historisches Museum Bern 2000
2001
“Head North, Visual Cultures Dialogue”, Bildmuseet, Umea/Sweden
“The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa 1945-1994”, Museum Villa Stuck, Munich Haus der Kulturen der Welt im Martin Gropius Bau, Berlin, Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago, P.S. 1 Contemporary Art Center, New York
“Africa Today, the Artist and the City”, Barcelona Center for Contemporary Culture
“World Wide Video Festival”, Amsterdam
2001/2002
«Dis/Location, Photo Espana 2001», Circulo de Bellas Artes Madrid, Sala Rekalde, Bilbao, Centro Cultural de Maia, O’Porto
2002
„Zeitgenössische Kunst aus Südafrika», Kunst:Raum Sylt-Quelle, Rantum, Kunstverein Zehntscheuer, Rottenburg/Neckar
Solo Exhibitions
Exhibition / Installation, 2000
1986
„Sculpture and Photomontage“, Market Gallery, Newtown, Johannesburg
1995/96
Standard Bank Young Artist Award landesweite Wanderausstellung
1999
“Bom Boys and Lucky Girls”, University of Cape Town, Irma Stern Museum
2000
„Jane Alexander“, Gasworks, London
2002
DaimlerChrysler Konzernzentrale, Forum Stuttgart-Möhringen
Daimler Chrysler Contemporary, Potsdamer Platz Berlin
Pretoria Art Museum
2003
Art Museum Bloemfontein
South African National Gallery, Cape Town
Ibrahim El Salahi | The Sudan/UK

Ibrahim El Salahi
b.1930 - Present
Sudan/Oman/UK
Ibrahim El Salahi from the Sudan
Artist Ibrahim el-Salahi was born in Omdurman, Sudan and is known as pioneer of Modern Sudanese and African art. He studied at the School of Design at Gordon Memorial College, and worked as an art teacher until he was awarded a scholarship to the Slade School and Royal College of Art in London. After completing his studies in Europe, El Salahi returned to Sudan, where he taught for a number of years at the Khartoum School of Fine and Applied Art. Aside from his career as an artist, he has held posts in various Sudanese government ministries and has served as a consultant for UNESCO.
El Salahi`s Arab-African heritage is reflected in his work by his creative use of elements drawn from Sudan`s literary and visual heritage. Using modernist styles and techniques, the artist infuses Arabic calligraphy and African forms with modern shadings, creating works that reflect the crossing of cultures from the ancient to present. El Salahi divides his artistic career into three phases. The earliest is characterized by the use of subdued and earthy colors and compositions dominated by elemental forms and lines. During his very brief second phase, the artist began experimenting with abstract biomorphic figures. El-Salahi`s works from his third and current phase are executed in black and white, and emphasize line and structure. The artist started working in this manner after 1975, when he was falsely accused by the military dictatorship of Sudan of conducting anti-government activities and imprisoned for six months without trial. Since his release, El-Salahi lives and continues to work in exile in the state of Qatar and in Oxford, England.
Iba N'Diaye | Senegal/France

Iba N`Diaye
b.1928 - Present
http://www.ibandiaye.com
Iba N`Diaye was born in 1928 in Saint Louis, Senegal. As a high school student, he painted film posters for the town`s two cinemas. N`Diaye studied architecture in Senegal and continued his creative studies in France at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts, Montpellier, Ecole des Beaux-Arts, Paris and the Académie de la Grande Chaumière. At the request of President Léopold Sédar Senghor, N`Diaye returned to Senegal in 1959 to create the Department of Plastic Arts at the Ecole Nationale des Beaux-Arts in Dakar. He returned permanently to Paris in 1967.
The artist frequented jazz clubs in Paris in the 1940s, and his love of music continues to inform his artwork. In 1987, the Museum für Völkerkunde, Munich, organized the first major retrospective of N`Diaye`s works in Europe. His artwork has also been featured in numerous group and solo exhibitions in Europe, North America, Africa and Asia.
Personal Exhibitions
2000 Senegal, Saint Louis, Gaston Berger Cultural Center
1996 Holland, The Hague, Het Paleis
1990 Finland, Tampere, Museum of Modern Art
1989 Holland, Berg en Dal, Afrika Museum
1987 Germany, Munich, Museum für Völkerkunde
1981 Norway, Oslo, Artes Gallery
Austria, Vienna, Bawag Foundation
U.S.A., New York, African American Institute :
Evolution d`un style
1980 France, Bobigny, Maison de la culture
1977 Senegal, Dakar, Musée Dynamique
Expositions de groupe
2002 U.S.A., New York,
The P.S.1 Contemporary Art Center The Short Century, Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa, 1945-1994
2001 Spain, Madrid,
Madrid Cultural Council El tiempo de Africa
Germany, Munich,
Villa Stuck Museum, The Short Century ...
Germany, Berlin,
Haus der Kulturen der Weltcorriger The Short Century ...
U.S.A, Chicago,
Museum of Contemporary Art The Short Century ...
2000 France, Paris Salon de Mai
Spain, Las Palmas,
Centro Atlantico de Arte moderno El tiempo de Africa
1992 France, Jouy en Josas,
Cartier Foundation A Visage découvert
The Face Uncovered
Senegal, Dakar,
Musée d`art africain Biennal of Arts
1991 U.S.A, New York,
Center for African Art Africa Explores, 20th century African Art
Holland, The Hague,
Gemeentemuseum Rhizome
1988 South Korea , Seoul,
Museum of Modern Art Olympiad of the Arts
1983 France, Paris,
Centre national des Arts Plastiques Artistes contre l`Apartheid
Artists Against Apartheid
1982 France, Paris,
Musée d`Art Moderne Les Peintres et le Jazz
Painters and Jazz
1977 Nigeria,Lagos Second Festival of African Arts
1974 France, Paris,
Grand Palais L`art Senegalais d`aujourd`hui
Senegalese Art of Today
1971 France, Paris,
Musée d`Art Moderne Salon de la Jeune Peinture
1969 Algeria, Alger Pan-African Festival
1963 Brazil, Sao Paolo International Biennal of Contemporary Art
France, Paris,
Musée d`Art Moderne Salon de la Jeune Peinture
1962 France, Paris,
Musée d`Art Moderne Salon de la Jeune Peinture
Principal museums and public collections
Africa :
Présidence de la République du Sénégal
Ministère de la Culture de la République du Sénégal
Ministère de la Culture de la République de Côte d`Ivoire
Musée Mandela, South Africa
Europe and U.S.A. :
Musée d`Art Moderne de la Ville de Paris, France
Centre National d`Art Contemporain, Paris, France
Société des Auteurs et Compositeurs de Musique, Neuilly, France
Morgan State University, Baltimore, U.S.A.
Fondation Bawag, Vienna, Austria
Musée des Beaux Arts d`Angoulême, France
Musée des Arts Africains et Océaniens, Paris, France
Afrika Museum, Berg en Dal, Holland
MacArthur Foundation, Chicago, U.S.A.
Biography : Principal Exhibitions
Previous
Munich Catalog, 1987Dakar Catalog , 1977Bird, 1982,
oil on canvas, 130x97 cm,
Collection Sacem, Neuilly.
Goddy Leye | Cameroon/Netherlands
Goddy Leye b.1965 - Present
Cameroon/Netherlands
N.B. Source: http://www.goddyleye.lecktronix.net/about.html
The Story Behind My Work
For a decade now, I have been busy exploring my memory. It all started with painting and drawing. I would look for old signs and symbols, remove them from their initial settings and place them in a totally new environment, thus providing room for the expansion of meaning. The signs and symbols were selected on the basis of their age but also and more so because of their beauty. They were fundamentally important as they were encapsulations of ideas feelings, emotions, thoughts that we are not directly connected to but that we could imagine, recall, think of. History books provided for the bulk of this material. But MEMORY as it recognises its subjective stand and does not pretend to have any everlasting truth or dogmatic position, was the most appropriate tool here.
Having been born and bred in an environment where the past was either forbidden or intentionally distorted in order to create a schizophrenic mind in the post-colony, I guess there has always been/there is still, the need to rewrite HISTORY.
One way of doing this is by feeding our thoughts with Senghorian Negritude: before the plagues of slavery and colonisation, Africa was a land of beauty, of loving people, of dynamic culture unrivalled poetry, sculpture, architecture, painting.... This would take our minds away from the pictures in textbooks, newspapers and now TV an Internet, of Africa as a wasteland. This philosophy/ideology provided the nutrients for my artistic growth when Pascal KENFACK accepted to guide me 1987-1991.Kenfack studied in Besancon and Paris in the late 70`s and wrote a doctoral thesis on the need and ways to draw inspiration from Pre-colonial African Art in order to produce a contemporary art that is authentic.
The other way is to rewrite and print History text books in order to produce a COUNTER-HISTORY... an eye for an eye... This may end up with awkward situations like when the Bible is rewritten with a Black Jesus. The son of Joseph and Mary was born in Bethlehem: he was neither Black nor White. Saying that Christopher Columbus was Black is probably less important to claim that he never discovered America, since prior to his arrival, people were already living there. Or maybe we should say that he discovered America from the position of Europe. Just like last year, I discovered Poland from the perspective of my family. This might imply that the entire History is written from a viewpoint that cannot be universal but which can easily be imposed as such.
In Cameroon two trends emerged from the Negritude philosophy: on the one hand, Reverend Father Engelbert Mveng studied the aesthetics of African Arts and published his findings in numerous books and articles. He opened a studio where he trained a couple of artists. His teaching was based on what he called the universal rules of African Art. His obsession with the Almighty Truth in the arts of the Black Continent led to a kind of pedagogy that had strong similarities with the Socialist Realism. His Studio failed to produce artists but instead poured a bunch of craftspeople on the local art scene. But according to him, this was not a failure since in Africa, there is no distinction between Art and Craft.
Pascal Kenfack`s theory, while drawing from the same source is slightly different. Craft and Art share some similarities and connections but belong to separate realms. Kenfack is convinced that the cultural past of Africa has not been properly studied and still has a lot to offer. The past in this case is a wonderful bank of useful information for the contemporary artist from the continent. Anthropology provides him with the necessary tools to explore this wealthy source of inspiration.
For both scholars and artists there is no redemption for a contemporary artistic production that is oblivious of the PAST.But as it is always the case with NEGRITUDE no precision is given about this wonderful past that serves as the backdrop. Thus, both theories fail in putting Africa in HISTORY. The land of the Negro is a place where nothing changes, evolves. Traditions rule here. And tradition is oral culture.In this way Negritude could be seen as an ally to the views developed by the colonial West, that Africa needs civilisation or development.
Questioning the views of these local influential cultural figures, provided the basis of my current quest for MEMORY.
Art Exhibition
Dancing with the Moon [Solo exhibition, Doual`Art, 2003]
Elections [Solo exhibition, Fri`Art, 2003]
Post-Border Art [Group exhibition, SBK, Amsterdam, 2003]
Réalité ou Fiction? [Solo exhibition, Fri`Art, 2003]
Electromediascope [Group exhibition, Nelson Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas City, 2002]
Nuits Métisses [Group exhibition, La Ciotat, 2002]
Espace Doual`Art [Joint exhibition, 2001]
With Bili Bidjocka
Goddy Leye [Solo exhibition, Icba Gallery, Salvador de Bahia, 2001]
Blick- Weschel - Afrikanishe Videokunst [Group exhibition, IFA Galerie, 2000]
Boulev`Art [Group exhibition, 2000]
Dak`Art 2000 [Group exhibition, Dakar Biennale, 2000]
Havana Biennale [Group exhibition, 2000]
L`Afrique à Jour, 10 Ans de Création à la Biennale de Dakar [Group exhibition, 2000]
Sankofa Blues [Solo exhibition, Doual`Art, 2000]
Behind the Scenes [Solo exhibition, Electronic Cafe International, Santa Monica, and on internet, 1999]
Dream [Group exhibition, Doual`Art, 1999]
South Meets West [Group exhibition, National Museum, Accra and Kunsthalle, Bern, 1999]
Dak`Art 1998 [Group exhibition, Biennale de Dakar, 1998]
Triennale der Kleinplastik [Group exhibition, 1998]
Fouilles Sauvages [Solo exhibition, Doual`art, 1996]
Bois Sacré [Solo exhibition, Institut de Formation Artistique, Mbalmayo, 1995]
Ghada Amer | Egypt/France/USA

Ghada Amer
Egypt/France/USA
b.1963 - Present
Ghada Amer was born in Cairo and trained as an artist in France. She now lives in New York City. She has an international reputation and has participated in major shows around the world. In the early 1990s her installations and paintings began to address the position of women in relation to Islamic fundamentalism, but in so doing she inevitably raised questions about their position in the West. She is best known for canvases covered with lush fields of color and embroidered with line drawings of women engaged in lesbian or autoerotic sex. The images of women are usually repeated across the canvases, forming patterns that invoke both the repetition of mass cultural forms and traditional decorative arts in the East and West.
Fernando Alvim | Angola/Netherlands/Angola

Fernando Alvim
b.1963 - Present
Angola/Belgium/South Africa
Born in 1963, Luanda, Angola.
He is the mentor and director of Trienal de Arte de Luanda .
Works as a visual artist, curator and contemporary art adviser.
Biography
Solo Exhibitions
2002 Fronteras Espace C Santander Espanha
2002 Emotional Geography Mains d`Oeuvres Paris França
1997 El Hombre Solo Gate Foundation Amsterdão Holanda
1996 Limbus Gallery Tel Aviv Israel
1996 Mecanismes de Preservation de la Memoire II, Centro Cultural Francês Libreville Gabão
1995 A Urgência da Etnopsiquitria, Luanda, Angola
1995 Instalação Parlamento Europeu Bruxelas Bélgica
1994 Contaminas Sankemente / Instalação Multimédia, Bruxelas, Bélgica
1993 Circula Nius, Centro de Arte Moderna, Lisboa, Portugal
1993 Château d`Eau de la Ville Bourges França
1992 Espaço Cultural Elinga Luanda Angola
1991 Espaço Sussuta Boé Bruxelas Bélgica
1990 Espaço Sussuta Boé Bruxelas Bélgica
Group Exhibitions
2005/2006 Africa Remix
2005 Looking Both Ways / Das Esquinas do Olhar, Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, Lisbon, Portugal
2004 Chaos and Metamorphose, Kunstpalast, Dusseldorf, Germany
2004 Centro George Pompidou Paris France
2004 Hayward Gallery, London, UK
2004 Biennale de Sidney, Sidney, Australia
2003 Looking Both Ways, Museum for African Art, Nova Iorque EUA
2003 Espacio Mestizos - II Encuentro Internacional de Arte Contemporanea de Osorio, Osorio, Ilhas Canárias
2002 Video Zone, Bienal Internacional de Video, Tel Aviv, Israel
Tempo | MoMA Museum of Modern Art | New York, USA
2001 Unconscious Skin | Festival of Modern Video | Amsterdam, Holand
2000 VideoBrasil | SESC Pompeia | S. Paulo Brasil
2000 Drapeau | Musée d`Art Moderne et Contemporain | Liège, France
2000 Photo Bienalle | Rotterdam, Holland
2000 Continental Shift | Bonnefantenmuseum | Maastricht, Áustria
2000 Memórias Íntimas | Museum van Hedendaagse Kunst | Antwerp, Holland
1999 Five Continents One City | México City, México
1999 South Meets West | Kunsthalle | Bern, Switzerland
1998 Bienal de Dakar, Dakar, Senegal
1998 Intimate Memories, Johannesburg, South Africa
1998 Intimate Memories, Lisbon, Portugal
1998 Hivos Art in Freedom | Boijmans Van Beuningen Museum Rotterdam, Holland
1998 Trienal Der Kleinplastik | Estugarda, Germany
1998 Bienal de S. Paulo | S. Paulo, Brasil
1997 Bienal de Havana | Havana, Cuba
1997 Memórias Íntimas | Luanda, Angola
1997 Intimate Momories | Castle of Good Hope | Cape Coast, South Africa
1995 Bienal of Johannesburg | Johannesburg, South Africa
1992 EXPO 92 | Seville, Spain
Fernando settled in Belgium in 1987 and now lives between Brussels, Johannesburg and Luanda.
El Anatsui | Ghana/Nigeria/UK

El Anatsui
Ghana
El Anatsui
Highly regarded in Africa, where he is considered to be one of the leading sculptors of his generation, Ghanaian-born El Anatsui is now rapidly establishing a wide international reputation. Chosen to represent the African continent during the 44th Venice Biennale in 1990, he has participated in many important exhibitions abroad - in England, Germany, the United States, Japan and Brazil - and has been a leading contributor to a number of international workshops for artists.
While there have been numerous articles written that deal with his impressive body of work, this book represents the first attempt to draw together under a single cover the many aspects of this artist`s singular career. The book gives both the general reader interested in the visual arts and the reader more particularly interested in contemporary African art, an overview of El Anatsui`s career and an analysis of his work to date. The various texts are complemented by a series of beautiful colour and black & white reproductions.
Just as El Anatsui`s work is concerned with the hidden histories of many different African cultures, so too this book is a composite tissue woven from different sources and written in different languages. The contributors are John Picton, Reader in African Art at SOAS, University of London Gerard Houghton, writer and linguist at the October Gallery Yukiya Kawaguchi, Curator at the Setagaya Art Museum, Tokyo Elisabeth Lalouschek, Artistic Director of the October Gallery Simon Njami, Editor of Revue Noire, Paris, France and Elizabeth Péri-Willis, an expert on West African visual artistic practices.
David Goldblatt | Photographer | South Africa
David Goldblatt South Africa
b.1930 - Present
David Goldblatt was born in 1930 in Randfontain in South Africa. His grandparents were Lithuanian Jews who emigrated from Europe to South Africa at the end of the 19th century. Goldblatt's interest in photography began during his years at secondary school and led in the 1950s to the publication of his first works in the magazines Life, Look and Picture Post. His main source of income remained his job in his father's firm, which made clothes for men, and he did not start working mainly as a photographer till his father died and the firm was sold. He then focussed more and more on his land's unhappy social, political and cultural conditions.
Works from this photographer, now 74 years old and living in Johannesburg, are in the South African National Gallery in Cape Town, in the Bibliothèque Nationale in Paris, the Victoria and Albert Museum in London and in the Museum of Modern Art in New York. He has also published many books about his work.
Documenta11, Kassel, Germany
(Exhibition / Installation, 2002)
Group exhibition
South African National Gallery, Cape Town, South A
(Exhibition / Installation, 2002)
Krings-Ernst Galerie Köln, Cologne, Germany
(Exhibition / Installation, 2002)
Rhizomes of Memory, Three South African Photographers, Henie Onstad Kunstsenter, Oslo
(Exhibition / Installation, 2001)
Group exhibition
The Short Century: Independence and Liberation Movements in Africa 1945-1994, Museum Villa Stuck, Munich, Germany. Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin, Germany. Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago, Ill., USA. P.S.1 Contemporary Art Center, New York, USA
(Exhibition / Installation, 2001)
Group exhibition
Museum d’Art Contemporani, Barcelona, Spain
(Exhibition / Installation, 2001)
Axa Gallery, New York, USA
(Exhibition / Installation, 2001)
Blank_ Architecture, Apartheid and After, Rotterdam and Berlin, Netherlands and Germany
(Exhibition / Installation, 1998)
Group exhibition
The Museum of Modern Art, New York, USA
(Exhibition / Installation, 1998)
Netherlands Architecture Institute, Rotterdam, Netherlands
(Exhibition / Installation, 1998)
In/Sight, African Photographers, 1940 to the Present, Guggenheim Museum, New York, USA
(Exhibition / Installation, 1996)
Group exhibition
Contemporary Art from South Africa, Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin, Germany
(Exhibition / Installation, 1996)
Group exhibition
1st Johannesburg Biennial, Johannesburg, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1995)
Photographers' Gallery, London, Great Britain
(Exhibition / Installation, 1986)
Side Gallery, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Great Britain
(Exhibition / Installation, 1985)
SA National Gallery, Cape Town, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1983)
Johannesburg Art Gallery, Johannesburg, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1983)
Pretoria Art Gallery, Pretoria, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1983)
Market Theatre Galleries, Johannesburg, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1978)
Durban Art Gallery, Durban, South Africa
(Exhibition / Installation, 1977)
Photography Place, Sydney, Australia
(Exhibition / Installation, 1975)
National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne, Australia
(Exhibition / Installation, 1975)
Photographers' Gallery, London, Great Britain
(Exhibition / Installation, 1974)
Chris Ofili
Chris Ofili Nigerian/English
Chris Ofili has said of his painting: My project is not a p c project ... It allows you to laugh about issues that are potentially serious.
Ofili studied Fine Art at Chelsea School of Art, before completing a Masters degree in painting at the Royal College of Art.
In 1992, he was awarded a British Council travel scholarship to Zimbabwe - a visit which has had a lasting impact on his painting.
As a black Briton of Nigerian descent, that first visit to Africa encouraged him to reconsider his own identity and to develop a highly personal aesthetic through which he examines issues of black culture, imagery and sexual stereotyping.
His work draws on a wide range of cultural references and popular material, from 1970s comics to contemporary black music and pornographic magazines, elements which he combines with humour, subversion and an innovative approach to the use of painting as a medium.
During his stay in Africa, Ofili began to incorporate lumps of elephant dung into his canvases - both as compositional elements and as supports on which to display his paintings.
He says this is a way of - quite literally - incorporating Africa into his work.
Ancient cave paintings of Zimbabwe, with their images composed of decorative dots, have helped evolve Ofili`s painting style which combines richly-coloured patterning with collage and three-dimensional elements.
Works such as Afrodizzia 1996 and Blossom 1997 are characteristic examples of his style.
Candice Britz | South Africa
Candice Breitz South Africa/USA
b.1972 - Present
N.B. Source: http://www.artthrob.co.za/oct98/artbio.htm
Modus operandi:
Exploding the terrain of representation, Candice Breitz employs a variety of darkly humorous and often disturbing tactics to strike out at stereotypes and visual conventions as presented and accepted in the media and popular culture. Working from such diverse sources as National Geographic, Penthouse and the National Inquirer, Breitz appropriates photographs and visual fragments and recontextualises these in bold, sometimes tasteless-seeming images, which, while jarring and discomforting for the viewer, radically challenge conventional wisdom and question currently accepted assumptions.
Artist`s statement:
I am interested in deploying the art work as a catalyst, one which momentarily freeze-frames problematic ways of making meaning, and renders them strange. My interest lies not in censoring the desires inspired by the commodity be that commodity a hipper-than-thou consumer trademark or a cheaply printed centrefold, but in recasting them so as to expose their logic, and, in certain cases, to push their boundaries.
Currently:
This month, Breitz will be one of three South African artists represented on the São Paulo Biennale see News, on which she will exhibit six photographs from the `Rainbow Series`, her most controversial work to date.
Most recently:
In April 1998, Breitz exhibited her `Ghost Series` 1994-96 at the Chicago Project Room. Critic Brian K Axel wrote: Breitz uses white-out to reconstruct the spectacle of racially marked gendered bodies on display in the ethnographic postcard, which would ordinarily circulate in a predominantly white tourist market. Covering up signs of race and gender, but not quite exactly, the `Ghost Series` foregrounds and acknowledges the violence of whiting-out as a process at social and political levels. The `Ghost Series` projects a violently non-totalised body, disrupting any possibility for the simple recognition and identification which the aesthetics of national belonging requires.
Before that:
In September/October 1997, Breitz wallpapered two different spaces with her grids of images from the `Rorschach Series` 1997 - the Artists` Space in New York, and, as part of the 2nd Johannesburg Biennale, the South African National Gallery in Cape Town. With this series, Breitz comments wryly on the tendency of the viewer to assume that a photograph simply communicates a predetermined meaning. She is more than attentive to the fact that what the shrink hopes to elicit - at least in the popular imagination - when he places the little black Rorschach silhouettes before his patient, is the projective transference of sexual fantasies, desires and obsessions ... While the pornographic source-images remain fragmented here, they are overlaid with an urge towards far less specific and recognisable patterns of association. We are presented with symmetrical corpse-like lumps, fleshy bloats, mutant post-human remains, which seem to allude more to science-fiction and genetic engineering clonings gone astray than to the pornography from which they are gleaned. In short, it seems that here the subject has vacated its premises entirely, leaving those premises perversely and frighteningly available to the projections of the viewer Octavio Zaya.
For her `My Twin Series` 1997, Breitz ordered a twin of herself from a company which works from photographs to supply young girls with dolls in their own image, and then, dressed to match, Breitz took her doll for a performative walk through Manhattan. The strangeness of the pair drew few glances from New Yorkers - a comment, perhaps, on what Breitz has called the Lolita-tisation of the world. The work probes the extent to which identity is increasingly mediated through commodity consumption. At the same time, it reads as a scathing critique of the infantilisation of women, conjuring up the flip-side of the American pastime of entering five-year-old girls into beauty contests, where Lolita-like behavior is encouraged above all else. When the `My Twin Series` was shown in Munich, the photographs were installed along with the doll sitting vigilantly in the corner, the brochure, and the dress and ribbon that were worn for the urban performance which is documented by the work.
In a neat twist on usual art market/gallerist/artist relationships, in which the gallery hounds the artist to complete work for an exhibition deadline, in order to sell it on the market, Breitz agreed to have a show in New York`s Silverstein Gallery in November 1997 on one condition. The director of the gallery, Daniel Silverstein, would have to make all the paintings for the show. The installation was titled `Painting by Numbers`. A few months before the show, Breitz presented Silverstein with some brushes, acrylic paints, and colour swatches, along with blank canvases onto which she had traced linear templates of famous brandname logos such as McDonald`s, FedEx and Coke. In the months to come, Breitz`s involvement was reduced to prodding her dealer on to meet the deadline set by the opening of the exhibition.
In terms of both production and content, `Painting by Numbers` violates boundaries between artistic signature and corporate logo, between the production of work by the artist and the distribution of work by the art market. Breitz comments: What `Painting by Numbers` attempts to challenge is artistic practice which still insists that the value of an art work lies in the expressive traces left by the artist. Given that drips and dribbles and brushstrokes can only ever evoke presence by proxy, they ultimately remain little fetishes. Since Silverstein painted the works from beginning to end, the mark of the artist and the mark of trade literally collapse into each other. This is Painting by Numbers!
Next up:
In November 1998, one-person exhibitions of Breitz`s work will open in Stockholm on November 14 Galleri Roger Björkholmen and Cologne on November 6 Johnen and Schöttle. In Stockholm, Breitz will exhibit works from the `Rorschach Series` 1997. A completely new series of work will be exhibited in Cologne for the first time: the `Surrogate Portrait Series` 1998 is a series of portraits of individuals who have agreed to submit themselves to universal surrogacy - that is, to stand in as surrogates for individuals other than themselves. The portraits are part of a larger work which includes a `Surrogate Archive` and a `Surrogate Manifesto`.
CV
Candice Breitz is a South African artist and writer who is currently based in New York. Breitz has had one-person exhibitions in Munich Rüdiger Schöttle Gallery, Los Angeles Craig Krull Gallery, New York Silverstein Gallery, Caracas Sala Mendoza, Chicago Chicago Project Room and Johannesburg Gallery The Space. She has participated in group shows in New York, Graz, Cape Town, Johannesburg, the Canary Islands, Copenhagen and Madrid.
Breitz completed her BAFA at the University of the Witwatersrand Johannesburg in 1993, and has subsequently received an MA degree from the University of Chicago 1995 and an MPhil degree from Columbia University 1997. Breitz participated in the studio division of the Whitney Museum`s Independent Studies Program during 1996-97. She is currently writing her doctoral dissertation in the Department of Art History at Columbia University, and is the co-editor with Brenda Atkinson of Grey Areas: Representation, Politics and Identity in Contemporary South African Art forthcoming from Chalkham Hill Press, late 1998.
Bili Bidjocka | Cameroon/France

Bili Bidjocka
b.1962 - Present
Cameroon/France
Photo: Bili Bidjocka, Pascale Marthine Tayou and Pierre Granoux are ready to put an imaginery graffity at the New Berlin Wall
BILI BIDJOCKA was born in Douala, Cameroon in 1962, and has lived in Paris since the age of 12. He is a painter and installation artist who has held several one-person shows in Europe and America. He has contributed to several group shows, including Otros Pais, which traveled through Europe in 1995. He is widely traveled and exhibited, making his work on the road, turning the debris of urban living and its excesses into art. He creates metaphors for loss, absence, ravishment, and renewal through his installation pieces. The work deals with issues of nationality, indeterminacy, and identity. He will be exhibiting in the New Museum of Contemporary Art in New York City with Los Carpinteros in the Summer of 1998. Additional information on the artist can be found on the World Wide Web [6].
Explicit Lyrics, one of two Bidjocka installations in Cross/ing, was created during a stay in New York in 1995. Objects and ideas were collected from friends and on the streets to make a tribute to the hypocritical veneer over our indebtedness to the personal services industry, while on the other hand, investigating the underscoring insidiousness of the language of the industry. [Reference 7] The work consists of twelve boxes the meaning of which has been greatly speculated, each individually lit by a small bulb at the bottom, and hung on the wall in a row below them, on the floor, are twelve brown bags each containing a candle. Each box contains words and phrases of a sexual nature. Since Bidjocka knew very little English when he first came to New York, the work suggests that when first coming to a foreign country, the traveler will hear and use slang, obscene phrases without knowing their true meaning and proper usage. In this situation, the words and phrases are seemingly innocent yet intriguing, rhythmical and perhaps even lyrical as demonstrated by the repetition of the word `fuck` in one of the boxes. For the foreigner, there is a fascination and seduction in the meanings and their interplay. He was able to locate lyricism in a language which, devoid of meaning and social associations as it was for him, became text as curio. And even as meaning was returned to it through translation, the inevitably cynical nature of the text and its source industry froze it in the frame of the exotic. It became fetish. Such keen, almost tongue-in-cheek fascination with text and the allures and failures of language comes as no surprise to us when we position it within the tradition of French semiotic preoccupation the appeal of language for a man coming from a culture that savors language and the pleasures of the text. Nor would it fail to make sense when we consider Bidjocka`s other heritage, in Africa, where language holds the same pleasurable appeal as it does in France. [8] He truly crosses over cultures.
Explicit Lyrics generated as many alternative interpretations as it had viewers. Examples include:
• It is a reflection of the obsession with sex that exists to a greater or lesser degree in every society. The word love is used, but seems to be intertwined and confused with sex.
• It seems to suggest the notion of a religious piece - shrine-like with epitaph phrases.
• The candles signify lovemaking and the artificial light signifies meaningless sex a waste of energy.
• The candles are lighting the way to Christ, symbolized by the number twelve for the twelve disciples.
• The brown bags represent those used by street persons who over-indulge in alcohol within the red light districts.
Explicit Lyrics also generated negative responses from the community. The exhibition curator received phone calls from people who questioned the relevance of obscene words in an art exhibition. Ultimately, a warning sign was placed at the entrance to the exhibition!
Bidjocka’s mixed media installation, Untitled Witches’ Ball, 1992, deals with absence and evacuation, as well as with the resilient occupation of spaces that is characteristic of the human spirit. Reference 9. Indeed, a room full of empty black dance gowns, moving in a circle around a giant egg to the strains of a tango, conjures up the spirits. We are in the midst of a kind of fertility dance, as they help in the hatching of ancestral powers Reference 2. Pairs of gowns and jackets, seeming to represent couples, are hung on the outside of the circle. The centered egg suggests new life or rebirth. There is a representational dichotomy of life and death, new and old, unfinished and finished. Bidjocka has created a ritualistic and ceremonial environment. The garments are the lingering ghosts that stay on earth after one’s physical existence is through. The moving entities around the egg are the living beings. As the elements extend outward, they grow older in phases. The motionless spirits placed in the outer region are reflective of how the dead remain on earth waiting for their transfer into another state or realm. We are reminded of the ghost houses of Laurenco Marques, or Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s deserted cities where the spirits of the dead linger, laying continuous claim to moment and territory, reminding us that there are no terra nullis, no spaces uninhabited by the residues of our passing. [Reference 10]
REFERENCES
6. World Wide Web: http://www.artincontext.com/listings/pages/artist/k/hpac370k/menu.htm
7. World Wide Web: http://satie.arts.usf.edu/~ooguibe/a22.htm
8. Olu Oguibe, op cit
9. Olu Oguibe, op cit
10. Olu Oguibe, op cit
Kwesi Afedzi aka George Hughes

Kwesi Afedzi aka George Hughes
QT | October 2004
See Forums & Discuss
Kwesi Afedzi aka George Hughes
Q.1. Why did you choose to leave your mother country Ghana and head for the USA?
ANS. I am very curious. After receiving a Master`s degree in Art Education in Ghana in 1991 I decided to go to Europe - Paris, Boudreaux, and finally London to see for the first time the original works of Western and contemporary masters. I ended up living in London for two years during which time I met my wife Jayne originally from Ohio who was studying in London at the time. We lived in Ghana from 1993 to 1994 but found it practical at the time to relocate to the United States because my wife had College loans to pay in the States.
Q.2. What are the advantages of those that live in the US, opposed to those that live in a West African country?
ANS. There are both advantages and disadvantages to artists who live in West Africa and those who live in the US. In the US there are more galleries, art journals, critics, art historians yet the competition is very keen for the above opportunities. There is a hierarchy of opportunities available in the US and only few renowned artists benefit from them. Although West Africa may lack in some of the affluent opportunities that support art and artists, there is a sense of belonging within the artists who operate in their own countries.
Q.3. As an African/Black artist what part does race play in your work?
ANS. Every single piece that I have done is an expression of who I am, my heritage and my beliefs. The works are about my total being and my relationship with society and nature expressed in residual effect through colour and form. I hardly sit around thinking I am going to do an African/Black painting. I just paint. It is like combat, you react.
The paintings are layered technically and also thematically. The works involve all my experiences, varied processes, social, political, and psychological concerns. Race issues pop up every now and then. The paintings can be likened to a complex recipe. After the soup is done, it is difficult to separate the ingredients. The viewer has to approach my paintings like every other art form with an open mind.
Q.4. Segregation is epidemic in the United States, how does your work reflect this reality?
ANS. Since the onset of The Civil Rights movement in the 1960s, several changes have occurred in favour of integration, however there is still discrimination in the United States against minorities. My works reflect integration rather than segregation. I combine all kinds of processes and imagery in an attempt to show the cosmic unity within our being and existence.
Q.5. Professor Ablade Glover founded the Artist Alliance in Teshey, Accra, Ghana. What effect do you feel this Institution has had in Ghana West Africa Africa and on a Global basis?
ANS. Artists Alliance Gallery for a decade has been a place where West African artists have shown their work. Galleries are invaluable to artists. West African artists need more galleries such as the Artists Alliance to represent them.
Q.6. What advise would you give to an artist working on the Continent of Africa?
ANS. They should keep working, seek innovative forms of artistic expression, avoid falling into a rut, and be open to documentation.
Q.7. Do you feel that there should be a genuine authentic African art market?
ANS. Yes. However some collectors jumble all the various art forms in Africa together, because it a lot easier than to carefully research their quality. For example crafts, folk art, sign writing fall within the same category as long as they are made by an African. It is ridiculous to the point where even fake poorly made contemporary art are valued sometimes as authentic. Whereas genuine contemporary works by trained artists are considered inauthentic, because they have been influenced by Western ideas. We do not condemn modern and post-modern Western artists for being influenced by African art.
Q.8. Are artists in Africa capable of joining the International Art Community and if they are how will they fit in?
ANS. Yes, African artists are capable of joining the International Art Community. There are several great artists of African decent working at this time. There is no doubt that they can compete within an International Art Community. I think more African historians, critics and patrons should get involved in promoting both traditional and contemporary African art. It is a good thing that several books have been written about traditional African art by Westerners. However very little has been written about Contemporary African Art by both African and Western writers. There should be more institutions such as museums, galleries and organizations set up in Africa to compete with the few institutions abroad that specialize in African art. It`s easier said than done. Most African countries do not have the economic resources to
fund and promote art.
Q.9. As an artist what value do you consider an African artist can bring to the International Art Scene?
ANS. Cultural diversity, mutual understanding, an open cultural dialog and divergent aesthetics.
Q.10. What is your interpretation of Contemporary Art and do you feel a part of that Western Art Movement?
ANS. Contemporary art may mean two things at the same time- significant art being done right now and/or modern art. I consider my work as contemporary but not necessarily part of a Western Art Movement. I don`t believe in movements sounds too early C20th, and it is limiting. I have done several projects that are purely self- exploratory and cannot be classified as part of or derivative of specific Western influence but rather of tribal or shamanistic origin. For example the ritual Ego Transformation performed at The Fred Jones Museum of Art in February 2004 was meant to purge my ego by the use of confinement, exposure and vulnerability.
Q.11. Airport Art or as I call it Artport Africa, was a phrase used in the late 60`s early 70`s. What combatants do you feel is needed to create a genuine art movement in Africa - the talent is quite noticeably there - this is a specifically focused on West Africa.
ANS. As I said earlier - more galleries, museums, and art publications. West African historians should develop interest in writing about contemporary African art. Most western writers confuse the eclectic art forms and genres and they just generalize. A typical analogy would be to categorize America music genres such as rock & roll, jazz, country, blue grass, techno, rap, rhythm and blues all with the same attributes but then pick blue grass as the most authentic. Some historians even avoid speaking with experts in Africa and would not even record what the artists have to say because it is not in their favor. More often than not some Western writers see folk art as the highest form of art that Africans can produce. To them any art forms in West Africa that shows traces of vanishing point perspective, or correct anatomical proportions is not genuine. They have become victims of previous ignorant and stereotypical beliefs concerning the capabilities of black people.
Q.12. Those on the continent of Africa feel that ART is about a Menu. If the Menu feeds the buying public, well - Why change it? Congolese Music is a wonderful example - Trapped Rotational Art. The scratched record - I once saw a man in Ghana painting with both hands the same painting on two separate canvases, a trick that is best seen in a Circus. He had sold a painting to a Westerner and painted the same painting over and over again. The issue, How does the artist break the chains of poverty and start to value him/her/self as an artist? is paramount. What are those in more beneficial seats outside Africa doing to ensure that art thrives on and off the Continent?
ANS. Breaking away from poverty has always been the plight of artists everywhere, more so in Africa. Until the economic and political climate of African countries are strengthened it will be difficult to promote and fund art programs on a national basis. Marginal success has always been achieved by individual artists whose dream still is to attain mainstream international acclaim.
The Ghanaian you saw painting with both hands- that is something you
May find in most tourist cities in the world. I have travelled to several cities abroad and you always see clownish feats done to entertain tourists. The art scene in West Africa is very diverse. There are artists who show their work by street sides and those who only show in galleries. Graphic designers inn West Africa mostly work on commissioned basis and sometimes do other imaginative work self-initiated. Exclusively there are artists such as Rikki Wemega, self-taught Wiz Kudorwor, college-trained who paint for themselves.
Generalizations are dangerous especially in African countries where you have so many ethnic groups, languages, customs and therefore a wide variety of art. Ghana is a small country yet has about 72 languages spoken by several ethnic groups. Sign-writers in Ghana are very popular with some Western historians, because the later has been conditioned by misconstrued beliefs, and propaganda to think that authentic art of Africa should be naive or folk-like. The truth is that most able artists of all cultures and origins are capable of expressing themselves in any stylistic form by volition. Artists who are well equipped may choose to be influenced by the art of children or the art of the insane or by the art of ancient civilizations such as that of the Egyptians or the Greeks. There is an evidential distinction that needs to be made concerning artists who consistently express themselves by means of a naive iconography and those who use correct anatomical proportions in their work. Both approaches evolve based on cultural, traditional, and philosophic orientation and has very little bearing in measuring authenticity. Authenticity has little to do with style, but rather an individual and honest compulsion to express built up aesthetic energy by means of an effective media and process with absolute conviction. Artists who repeat themselves might have said everything they want to say. However they are better off than those who quit working all togeth










